Sadly his voice aint strong enough
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
i usually spend the ads going to the loo or puting the kettle etc - but I'm scared I miss a christmas ad - I'd love to know how much STV made selling the ad breaks during X Factor tonight - they've all been on there!
My pronouncement that there's far too many Crimbo Ads already (it's not even Mid November fgs)...went down like a lead balloon here. It's a veritable Ad Ma's delight apparently 
Don't be pretending to be a cynic now... Mrs Snowing Tree....
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
But the fact is that song won an OSCAR, it is a popular song, and Adele sang it, now unless your saying with a straight face that Adele is shite or that she is no better than Hannah then you cant say that Hannah sang that song well.
The GBP agreed with me as she was in the bottom two that week, just because the X Factor judges liked it doesn't make it true.
I couldn't give a stuff about what's popular - you're talking to someone who LOATHES that Swedish foursome with a passion, Vids, and apparently everyone likes them. I don't like the song, but I thought Hannah gave it a good shot.
Why the hell it's turned into a who's right or wrong debate is beyond me.
People like what they like; you can't tell them not to 
This Sam fella is shite. My opinion and I ain't changing it even if I'm the only woman in the world who thinks so. Simples, as they say.
no argument here...
Now I know what the C stands for in Sam C....CRAP.
A singing competition, four judges... and not one touched on vocals, honestly
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
But the fact is that song won an OSCAR, it is a popular song, and Adele sang it, now unless your saying with a straight face that Adele is shite or that she is no better than Hannah then you cant say that Hannah sang that song well.
The GBP agreed with me as she was in the bottom two that week, just because the X Factor judges liked it doesn't make it true.
I couldn't give a stuff about what's popular - you're talking to someone who LOATHES that Swedish foursome with a passion, Vids, and apparently everyone likes them. I don't like the song, but I thought Hannah gave it a good shot.
Why the hell it's turned into a who's right or wrong debate is beyond me.
People like what they like; you can't tell them not to
This Sam fella is shite. My opinion and I ain't changing it even if I'm the only woman in the world who thinks so. Simples, as they say.
no argument here...
Or indeed here.
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
i usually spend the ads going to the loo or puting the kettle etc - but I'm scared I miss a christmas ad - I'd love to know how much STV made selling the ad breaks during X Factor tonight - they've all been on there!
My pronouncement that there's far too many Crimbo Ads already (it's not even Mid November fgs)...went down like a lead balloon here. It's a veritable Ad Ma's delight apparently
I agree ...........I'm very entertained tonight but I'll be happy if they're on hold until beginning of December. I won't let my boys watch Polar Express, Father Christmas, Snowman etc. until we are into December.
Oh.. this was mercifully short this week. See you tomorrow for the results!
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
i usually spend the ads going to the loo or puting the kettle etc - but I'm scared I miss a christmas ad - I'd love to know how much STV made selling the ad breaks during X Factor tonight - they've all been on there!
My pronouncement that there's far too many Crimbo Ads already (it's not even Mid November fgs)...went down like a lead balloon here. It's a veritable Ad Man's delight apparently
Don't be pretending to be a cynic now... Mrs Snowing Tree....
But that's not coming out until at least Mid December - if at all.
The Fig Fag Tree on the other hand might be given an early airing
Jeeze - just hearing Abi again there after some of the others - she sounds about five.
I shall be very grumpy if Dave the Hairy non dancer and Sam the non singer don't both go home this week!
Laters 
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
But the fact is that song won an OSCAR, it is a popular song, and Adele sang it, now unless your saying with a straight face that Adele is shite or that she is no better than Hannah then you cant say that Hannah sang that song well.
The GBP agreed with me as she was in the bottom two that week, just because the X Factor judges liked it doesn't make it true.
I couldn't give a stuff about what's popular - you're talking to someone who LOATHES that Swedish foursome with a passion, Vids, and apparently everyone likes them. I don't like the song, but I thought Hannah gave it a good shot.
Why the hell it's turned into a who's right or wrong debate is beyond me.
People like what they like; you can't tell them not to
This Sam fella is shite. My opinion and I ain't changing it even if I'm the only woman in the world who thinks so. Simples, as they say.
You are right, people like what they like.
However, I thought personality counted on this show too, and Hannah's personality is awful, not as awful as her voice mind you, but still she comes across so badly.
I've heard better singers than her on past shows get slaughtered on here for not seeming to be a nice person, or being sulky...but for some reason Hannah gets away with it.
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
i usually spend the ads going to the loo or puting the kettle etc - but I'm scared I miss a christmas ad - I'd love to know how much STV made selling the ad breaks during X Factor tonight - they've all been on there!
My pronouncement that there's far too many Crimbo Ads already (it's not even Mid November fgs)...went down like a lead balloon here. It's a veritable Ad Man's delight apparently
Don't be pretending to be a cynic now... Mrs Snowing Tree....
But that's not coming out until at least Mid December - if at all.
The Fig Fag Tree on the other hand might be given an early airing
Yeah, i do take your point - i like to see the ads, but I don't put the tree up till the week before chrimbo
Just watching the re cap .................Nicholas is an irritating little weed isn't he?
Sam C and Abi 
in the bottom two.
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Sam C and Abi in the bottom two.
if there's any justice.
don't hold your breath.
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
But the fact is that song won an OSCAR, it is a popular song, and Adele sang it, now unless your saying with a straight face that Adele is shite or that she is no better than Hannah then you cant say that Hannah sang that song well.
The GBP agreed with me as she was in the bottom two that week, just because the X Factor judges liked it doesn't make it true.
I couldn't give a stuff about what's popular - you're talking to someone who LOATHES that Swedish foursome with a passion, Vids, and apparently everyone likes them. I don't like the song, but I thought Hannah gave it a good shot.
Why the hell it's turned into a who's right or wrong debate is beyond me.
People like what they like; you can't tell them not to
This Sam fella is shite. My opinion and I ain't changing it even if I'm the only woman in the world who thinks so. Simples, as they say.
You are right, people like what they like.
However, I thought personality counted on this show too, and Hannah's personality is awful, not as awful as her voice mind you, but still she comes across so badly.
I've heard better singers than her on past shows get slaughtered on here for not seeming to be a nice person, or being sulky...but for some reason Hannah gets away with it.
Now see - we see it quite differently. I don't see her as sulky at all. I think she has had a bit of an unhappy life and was somewhat depressed if anything. I'm loving the fact that her self esteem has been given a boost and that she seems genuinely happier.
I'll be honest I think it's the sadness in her life that makes her really soulful.
Originally Posted by Videostar:
I do wish Sam B would sort that gap in her teeth out, it's doing my loaf in.
You could drive a bus through that gap.
Ohh, me too .... I'd even pay for her to have it done.
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Just watching the re cap .................Nicholas is an irritating little weed isn't he?
When he does that 'smile' in the promo pic before each show, he always looks as if he's about to throw up on his shoes.
Sam B and Tamera were good.
Abi and Sam C were terrible.
Vids, I agree that Hannah doesn't come across well - the words surly and sullen come to mind.
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Just watching the re cap .................Nicholas is an irritating little weed isn't he?
How could you....? He comes from Motherwell (just down the road) and some of my relatives know him.
) was 'forced' to watch it today....it was awful....reminded me why I don't watch it!
Originally Posted by Angel:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
I do wish Sam B would sort that gap in her teeth out, it's doing my loaf in.
You could drive a bus through that gap.
Ohh, me too .... I'd even pay for her to have it done.
I'll chip in some cash too.
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
But the fact is that song won an OSCAR, it is a popular song, and Adele sang it, now unless your saying with a straight face that Adele is shite or that she is no better than Hannah then you cant say that Hannah sang that song well.
The GBP agreed with me as she was in the bottom two that week, just because the X Factor judges liked it doesn't make it true.
I couldn't give a stuff about what's popular - you're talking to someone who LOATHES that Swedish foursome with a passion, Vids, and apparently everyone likes them. I don't like the song, but I thought Hannah gave it a good shot.
Why the hell it's turned into a who's right or wrong debate is beyond me.
People like what they like; you can't tell them not to
This Sam fella is shite. My opinion and I ain't changing it even if I'm the only woman in the world who thinks so. Simples, as they say.
You are right, people like what they like.
However, I thought personality counted on this show too, and Hannah's personality is awful, not as awful as her voice mind you, but still she comes across so badly.
I've heard better singers than her on past shows get slaughtered on here for not seeming to be a nice person, or being sulky...but for some reason Hannah gets away with it.
Now see - we see it quite differently. I don't see her as sulky at all. I think she has had a bit of an unhappy life and was somewhat depressed if anything. I'm loving the fact that her self esteem has been given a boost and that she seems genuinely happier.
I'll be honest I think it's the sadness in her life that makes her really soulful.
What sadness? the only thing that's happened to her is that she doesn't get on with her mum...shock horror, teenage daughter doesn't get on with her mum...well I never!!!.
Please let Abi go home tonight!
evening.. wonder what kind of crazy voting we'll get this week
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
But the fact is that song won an OSCAR, it is a popular song, and Adele sang it, now unless your saying with a straight face that Adele is shite or that she is no better than Hannah then you cant say that Hannah sang that song well.
The GBP agreed with me as she was in the bottom two that week, just because the X Factor judges liked it doesn't make it true.
I couldn't give a stuff about what's popular - you're talking to someone who LOATHES that Swedish foursome with a passion, Vids, and apparently everyone likes them. I don't like the song, but I thought Hannah gave it a good shot.
Why the hell it's turned into a who's right or wrong debate is beyond me.
People like what they like; you can't tell them not to
This Sam fella is shite. My opinion and I ain't changing it even if I'm the only woman in the world who thinks so. Simples, as they say.
You are right, people like what they like.
However, I thought personality counted on this show too, and Hannah's personality is awful, not as awful as her voice mind you, but still she comes across so badly.
I've heard better singers than her on past shows get slaughtered on here for not seeming to be a nice person, or being sulky...but for some reason Hannah gets away with it.
Now see - we see it quite differently. I don't see her as sulky at all. I think she has had a bit of an unhappy life and was somewhat depressed if anything. I'm loving the fact that her self esteem has been given a boost and that she seems genuinely happier.
I'll be honest I think it's the sadness in her life that makes her really soulful.
What sadness? the only thing that's happened to her is that she doesn't get on with her mum...shock horror, teenage daughter doesn't get on with her mum...well I never!!!.
yeah, but you were probably a really annoying teenage girl....
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
But the fact is that song won an OSCAR, it is a popular song, and Adele sang it, now unless your saying with a straight face that Adele is shite or that she is no better than Hannah then you cant say that Hannah sang that song well.
The GBP agreed with me as she was in the bottom two that week, just because the X Factor judges liked it doesn't make it true.
I couldn't give a stuff about what's popular - you're talking to someone who LOATHES that Swedish foursome with a passion, Vids, and apparently everyone likes them. I don't like the song, but I thought Hannah gave it a good shot.
Why the hell it's turned into a who's right or wrong debate is beyond me.
People like what they like; you can't tell them not to
This Sam fella is shite. My opinion and I ain't changing it even if I'm the only woman in the world who thinks so. Simples, as they say.
You are right, people like what they like.
However, I thought personality counted on this show too, and Hannah's personality is awful, not as awful as her voice mind you, but still she comes across so badly.
I've heard better singers than her on past shows get slaughtered on here for not seeming to be a nice person, or being sulky...but for some reason Hannah gets away with it.
Now see - we see it quite differently. I don't see her as sulky at all. I think she has had a bit of an unhappy life and was somewhat depressed if anything. I'm loving the fact that her self esteem has been given a boost and that she seems genuinely happier.
I'll be honest I think it's the sadness in her life that makes her really soulful.
What sadness? the only thing that's happened to her is that she doesn't get on with her mum...shock horror, teenage daughter doesn't get on with her mum...well I never!!!.
yeah, but you were probably a really annoying teenage girl....
Yeah, but since the op I've been much happier in myself. 
I don't love Robbie Williams.
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
But the fact is that song won an OSCAR, it is a popular song, and Adele sang it, now unless your saying with a straight face that Adele is shite or that she is no better than Hannah then you cant say that Hannah sang that song well.
The GBP agreed with me as she was in the bottom two that week, just because the X Factor judges liked it doesn't make it true.
I couldn't give a stuff about what's popular - you're talking to someone who LOATHES that Swedish foursome with a passion, Vids, and apparently everyone likes them. I don't like the song, but I thought Hannah gave it a good shot.
Why the hell it's turned into a who's right or wrong debate is beyond me.
People like what they like; you can't tell them not to
This Sam fella is shite. My opinion and I ain't changing it even if I'm the only woman in the world who thinks so. Simples, as they say.
You are right, people like what they like.
However, I thought personality counted on this show too, and Hannah's personality is awful, not as awful as her voice mind you, but still she comes across so badly.
I've heard better singers than her on past shows get slaughtered on here for not seeming to be a nice person, or being sulky...but for some reason Hannah gets away with it.
Now see - we see it quite differently. I don't see her as sulky at all. I think she has had a bit of an unhappy life and was somewhat depressed if anything. I'm loving the fact that her self esteem has been given a boost and that she seems genuinely happier.
I'll be honest I think it's the sadness in her life that makes her really soulful.
What sadness? the only thing that's happened to her is that she doesn't get on with her mum...shock horror, teenage daughter doesn't get on with her mum...well I never!!!.
yeah, but you were probably a really annoying teenage girl....
Yeah, but since the op I've been much happier in myself.
Doesn't show...
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
But the fact is that song won an OSCAR, it is a popular song, and Adele sang it, now unless your saying with a straight face that Adele is shite or that she is no better than Hannah then you cant say that Hannah sang that song well.
The GBP agreed with me as she was in the bottom two that week, just because the X Factor judges liked it doesn't make it true.
I couldn't give a stuff about what's popular - you're talking to someone who LOATHES that Swedish foursome with a passion, Vids, and apparently everyone likes them. I don't like the song, but I thought Hannah gave it a good shot.
Why the hell it's turned into a who's right or wrong debate is beyond me.
People like what they like; you can't tell them not to
This Sam fella is shite. My opinion and I ain't changing it even if I'm the only woman in the world who thinks so. Simples, as they say.
You are right, people like what they like.
However, I thought personality counted on this show too, and Hannah's personality is awful, not as awful as her voice mind you, but still she comes across so badly.
I've heard better singers than her on past shows get slaughtered on here for not seeming to be a nice person, or being sulky...but for some reason Hannah gets away with it.
Now see - we see it quite differently. I don't see her as sulky at all. I think she has had a bit of an unhappy life and was somewhat depressed if anything. I'm loving the fact that her self esteem has been given a boost and that she seems genuinely happier.
I'll be honest I think it's the sadness in her life that makes her really soulful.
What sadness? the only thing that's happened to her is that she doesn't get on with her mum...shock horror, teenage daughter doesn't get on with her mum...well I never!!!.
yeah, but you were probably a really annoying teenage girl....
Yeah, but since the op I've been much happier in myself.
Doesn't show...
I just hate sulky rubbish "singers". 
Evening all
Really not sure who I want to be in the sing off/who I want to go
Originally Posted by Videostar:
What sadness? the only thing that's happened to her is that she doesn't get on with her mum...shock horror, teenage daughter doesn't get on with her mum...well I never!!!.
yeah, but you were probably a really annoying teenage girl....
Yeah, but since the op I've been much happier in myself.
Doesn't show...
I just hate sulky rubbish "singers".
Has to be said, this probably isn't the show for you then eh?
Originally Posted by Supes:
Evening all
Really not sure who I want to be in the sing off/who I want to go
Evening again supes (or should I call you 'your maj?') I'm gone off Abi again, big time. I wouldn't mind if she was in the bottom with Sam C
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Supes:
Evening all
Really not sure who I want to be in the sing off/who I want to go
Evening again supes (or should I call you 'your maj?') I'm gone off Abi again, big time. I wouldn't mind if she was in the bottom with Sam C
As long as you curtsied Yeah, they were the two worst vocals, but Sam B did nothing for me, nor Rough Copy...as long as it's not Luke or Tamera
Every time I hear Celine Dione singing 'my heart will go on ' now - I just picture the two scouse lads on Gogglebox re-enacting Titanic.
Someone call her an ambulance, poor woman is obviously in pain
Originally Posted by Supes:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Supes:
Evening all
Really not sure who I want to be in the sing off/who I want to go
Evening again supes (or should I call you 'your maj?') I'm gone off Abi again, big time. I wouldn't mind if she was in the bottom with Sam C
As long as you curtsied Yeah, they were the two worst vocals, but Sam B did nothing for me, nor Rough Copy...as long as it's not Luke or Tamera
I still like rough copy and I think Sam B can sing, but I don't think this is her show. My top three are Luke, Tamera and Rough Copy (I like hannah but I seriously don't think her voice will hold up - she's been on voice rest, what? three time now?)
What a strange outfit.