Skip to main content

This book is extraordinary.  I have never read a historical novel that seems like I am reading real history, but this book does it.  It could never be compared with other Tudor novels in that the detail in Wolf Hall is so finely described, down to Henry's pudgy fingers covered in ruby rings. 

The book itself is based around Thomas Cromwell and Hilary Mantel writes him as a sympathetic figure and not the tight lipped and narrowed eyed brute depicted in the Holbein portrait. 

Wolf Hall is part one of a two part story.  The title is misleading.  Wolf Hall is the country home of the Seymour family and it hardly warrants a mention in the book save for a few references.  You find out on the final page, in the final sentence why the book was called Wolf Hall.  To avoid spoiling it for any other reader, I will not comment further. 

Hilary Mantel is up for the Man Booker prize on 6 October 2009.  She should win it, given that she has defined a new genre of historical writing.  I listened to a talk she gave in May about the book and I will try and find the link and add it to the bottom of this post.

Hilary Mantel writes with an assured style.  Her use of the English Language is so beautiful and her descriptive powers so assured that I have actually read some sentences twice to enjoy the beauty of her words.  Yes, she is that good.  It is a long book (Wolf Hall) and it does not end with Cromwell's death .. I expect part two will deal with that.

If you want to have a reading treat, read Wolf Hall.  Get it from Amazon .. it is ÂĢ8.50, as opposed to W H Smith where it retails at circa ÂĢ16.  I can't find the link atm, but will post it when I can.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

oh brill angelica, you won't regret it.  It is cheaper if you buy it from Amazon.  But if you buy it from Play.com, you don't have to pay postage.  I bought it from Amazon for ÂĢ8.50. 

It has to be one of the best books I've read for period detail.  Her use of the English Language astounds me, and her descriptive powers in the book are amazing.  As I said in my first post ^^^^, I have read some sentences and paragraphs twice to appreciate the beauty of her words.  She has deservedly won the Man Booker Prize, but I have to admit that I haven't read any of the others listed.  But I cannot see anyone matching her for this new literary genre she has created, where fiction reads as real history. 

She has kept to the known historical facts but she has centred Cromwell round them all, with her own interpretation of events from Cromwell's point of view.  Her writing style is unusual too.  She rarely refers to Cromwell by name in the book, but refers to him as 'He' throughout, which is a bit puzzling at the start but you tend to get used to it.  Wolf Hall is only part one, and she is currently writing part two which will deal with the remaining five years of his life (when Wolf Hall ends). 

Do get it.  You have a real treat in store.  Let me know what you think of it.
Twee Surgeon
Gawd...I'm now considering the AS Byatt 'The Children's Book'. Sounds intriguing...

"
Olive Wellwood is a famous writer, interviewed with her children gathered at her knee. For each of them she writes a separate private book, bound in different colours and placed on a shelf. In their rambling house near Romney Marsh they play in a story-book world - but their lives, and those of their rich cousins, children of a city stockbroker, and their friends, the son and daughter of a curator at the new Victoria and Albert Museum, are already inscribed with mystery. Each family carries their own secrets. Into their world comes a young stranger, a working-class boy from the potteries, drawn by the beauty of the Museum's treasures. And in midsummer a German puppeteer arrives, bringing dark dramas. The world seems full of promise but the calm is already rocked by political differences, by Fabian arguments about class and free love , by the idealism of anarchists from Russia and Germany. The sons rebel against their parents' plans; the girls dream of independent futures, becoming doctors or fighting for the vote. This vivid, rich and moving saga is played out against the great, rippling tides of the day, taking us from the Kent marshes to Paris and Munich and the trenches of the Somme. Born at the end of the Victorian era, growing up in the golden summers of Edwardian times, a whole generation grew up unaware of the darkness ahead. In their innocence, they were betrayed unintentionally by the adults who loved them. In a profound sense, this novel is indeed the children's book. "
subatomic partygirl
Reference: 
Just ordered on amazon just now along with William Marshal: Knighthood, War and Chivalry, 1147-1219 by David Crouch I will let you know what I thought, thanks Twee
hi angel   I think Amazon are the cheapest at the moment.  I noticed that play are charging about ÂĢ12.50, but with free postage.  The only trouble with Amazon is that you have to spend ÂĢ15+ to qualify for free postage.  I ordered another book at the same time as Wolf Hall .. believe it or not - the absolute polar opposite of Wolf Hall .... wait for it .. 'Treat them mean and keep them keen' by Gerry of BB7.  This is a lovely little book where Gerry gives tips on the dating scene, from a gay Greek point of view.  It's a little gem actually.  I am half-way through it at the minute.  The dating scene is the farthest thing from my lifestyle atm but I love his saucy humour, and he was my favourite HM of that year. 

I like the sound of your other book ^^^ and I will go and read up about it. 

Enjoy Wolf Hall when it arrives.  Let us know what you think of it.
Twee Surgeon
Reference: 
Just ordered it, Twee (Amazon) ÂĢ8.50-ish. Love this line from the description...."It was a time of men who weren't like us, but who were creating us" Looking forward to it. ~x

hi sub   You have a treat in store, believe me.  Enjoy.

The A S Byatt book was her main competition for the prize.  The other books did not get a mention when the Booker was discussed in the papers or on TV.  It was always Hilary Mantel or A S Byatt to win.  From the description you quoted, I think I would like this book too, so I am going to order it from the library.  Thanks for the tip-off sub.  I also noticed that BBC2 did not broadcast the Booker prize giving this year, which I was disappointed with. 

The one thing I failed to mention about Wolf Hall is the immediacy of the events.  She writes in the first person, as if the events are actually happening as she is writing them.  If Cromwell is going to see Wolsey, we travel along with him on the boat and dock at the Stairs, and walk up to his Palace, and then the conversation takes place there and then, with Hilary Mantel's clever little descriptive asides about the furnishings and pictures, and what Wolsey is wearing, and how he is lolling back on silk cushions .. giving us a mental picture of Wolsey as a person.  It's the same with Henry and Thomas More.  She more or less paints us a picture to set the scene.

 

Twee Surgeon
Reference:
Hilary Mantel's clever little descriptive asides about the furnishings and pictures, and what Wolsey is wearing,
That is exactly what I like to read in historical (or pretty much any) novel; the small detail that truly transports us to that place or time....so much that you can almost smell it.

I didn't know that Byatt had been nominated this year (didn't know the shortlist at all)...but the description grabbed me so I can see why. I like a bit of 'quirk' in a book (as long as it still tells a good tale). I think that's why I:ve always loved Peter Ackroyd's books (and Patrick Suskind's 'Perfume')
subatomic partygirl
hiya sub
Hope you are well.  Yes, the description can sometimes set the scene.  I'm not sure what you call Hilary Mantel's writing style in Wolf Hall.  I think it's called First Person Narrative, where the events are happening as she writes.  She transports us back to the Sixteenth Century and we can 'see' the people and the buildings.  It's very clever.

Yes, A S Byatt was Hilary Mantel's main competition for the Booker.  From your quote, I can tell I will like this book but I will order from the library rather than buy it I think.  I love books with an edge, where the totally unexpected happens and you are left gasping.  I am in the Book Club on LiveCloud and our first book, reading as a Group, is Prey by Michael Crichton.  Why don't you join us Sub?  It is all done very democratically .. the majority chose Prey out of about 10 listed books.  It is not a genre I would normally be interested in but I want to branch out and read other types of books and this will make me open my mind to something other than history books.  Let me know if you would like to join us and I will send you the link.  Shar is running it, and I'm sure she would be chuffed to have you join because you would most definitely add to the discussions.
Twee Surgeon
Reference:
I am in the Book Club on LiveCloud and our first book, reading as a Group, is Prey by Michael Crichton. Why don't you join us Sub?
Funnily enough, I found The Book Club by accident and joined yesterday! Off to buy 'Prey' tomorrow. Like you, it's not a genre I wuld normally read but I'm willing to give it a go. I've never really met a book I didn;t like in *some* way. They're all journeys to be experienced.
subatomic partygirl
hi sub   It's great that you have joined the Club.  I have read Prey and it's very good.  It's not my usual genre but it was great to explore another type of book.  I think the deadline for discussing it is next Saturday but I think we will be discussing it in sections.  I will re-read it again as we are discussing it so that it is fresh. 

How are you getting on with Wolf Hall?
Twee Surgeon

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×