Skip to main content

You were right to expect a lot more Eugene,in my opinion, and 'thrown out with the bath water' really  sums it up well for me.

I think the characters in the adaptation were far more shallow and ill defined, hence why I found it rushed,and I didn't like the airy fairy nightmare sequences, they seemed to be shoehorned in as a convenient mechanism to explain far too much that had been left out.

 

All in very disappointing production only relieved by Julia MacKenzie's grasp and portrayal of her character,I also thought the young actor playing Krystal and the lad playing Andrew were excellent.

jacksonb
Originally Posted by jacksonb:

If I were J K Rowling,I'm not sure I'd be too happy with the adaptation of her novel,the ending was completely different to the book,I don't think it was an improvement on the original,in fact quite a few aspects of the book were lost and the whole tv version seemed rushed muddled.

 

 

I've just watched it... and I've just seen an article where JK Rowling is gushing about what a great job they did.   She must have been paid well.     It was almost unrecognisable and not in a good way.    So much left out (Kaye's bf, Gavin and his thing for Mary, Sukhvinder's bullying and self harming, Samantha and Andrew..) and a completely different ending.  What a load of tosh.   I haven't been so let down by an adaptation since Captain Corelli's Mandolin.

Kaffs
Last edited by Kaffs
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:

Indian Summers is quite good. Took a while to take Julie Walters seriously in it though. She looks very like she did in the waitress "Two Soups" sketch... very distracting 

 

Also really enjoying The Walking Dead - been racing through it and am on S.3 already. 

I've just started watching this on the catch-up thing.  Enjoying it so far. 

Madame Arcati
Originally Posted by Enthusiastic Contrafibularities:

Pompidou - The product of someone who has had success and been given carte blanche to produce any old crap.

 

Not your finest hour Mr Lucas.

 

I must admit to having a small chuckle at the dog reading "Memoirs of a Cavelier" by Spaniel Defoe, though...

Eugene's Lair
Last edited by Eugene's Lair
Originally Posted by Eugene's Lair:
Originally Posted by Enthusiastic Contrafibularities:

Pompidou - The product of someone who has had success and been given carte blanche to produce any old crap.

 

Not your finest hour Mr Lucas.

 

I must admit to having a small chuckle at the dog reading "Memoirs of a Cavelier" by Spaniel Defoe, though...

 

That would have been funny, but I turned over before that. I switched off just after the butler fainted. 

 

Enthusiastic Contrafibularities
Originally Posted by Enthusiastic Contrafibularities:

 

 

Pompidou - The product of someone who has had success and been given carte blanche to produce any old crap.

 

Not your finest hour Mr Lucas.

 

I tried to watch it yesterday.  I think I lasted less than 2 minutes.  It was awful & from what I did see, very Mr Bean. 

Cinds
Originally Posted by Cinds:
Originally Posted by Enthusiastic Contrafibularities:

 

 

Pompidou - The product of someone who has had success and been given carte blanche to produce any old crap.

 

Not your finest hour Mr Lucas.

 

I tried to watch it yesterday.  I think I lasted less than 2 minutes.  It was awful & from what I did see, very Mr Bean. 

Well... Let's not forget that there are a lot of people who really love Mr Bean.

FWIW, I thought the first episode was a lot funnier, with some very clever gags. However, Sunday's episode was a disappointment, IMO.

Eugene's Lair
Originally Posted by Cosmopolitan:
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:

Is Poldark any good? I'm waiting for reviews before taking the plunge 

Especially as that Banished on BBC2 last week was bleedin' awful  

 

Oh hell.  I was hoping it might be a go-er  

You could give it a go Cosi  Within about 15 mins I decided it was too sh*te to bother with. Mind you I didn't take to Downton either. What do I know ?

FM
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:
Originally Posted by Cosmopolitan:
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:

Is Poldark any good? I'm waiting for reviews before taking the plunge 

Especially as that Banished on BBC2 last week was bleedin' awful  

 

Oh hell.  I was hoping it might be a go-er  

You could give it a go Cosi  Within about 15 mins I decided it was too sh*te to bother with. Mind you I didn't take to Downton either. What do I know ?

 

I was relying on it instead of going with Poldark... which I don't fancy at all.

I'll give it a go, but I'll probably end up deleting the series record like I did for Fortitude, Indian Summer and goodness knows how many others 

I've been spoilt by Wolf Hall!

Cosmopolitan
Originally Posted by Cosmopolitan:
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:
Originally Posted by Cosmopolitan:
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:

Is Poldark any good? I'm waiting for reviews before taking the plunge 

Especially as that Banished on BBC2 last week was bleedin' awful  

 

Oh hell.  I was hoping it might be a go-er  

You could give it a go Cosi  Within about 15 mins I decided it was too sh*te to bother with. Mind you I didn't take to Downton either. What do I know ?

 

I was relying on it instead of going with Poldark... which I don't fancy at all.

I'll give it a go, but I'll probably end up deleting the series record like I did for Fortitude, Indian Summer and goodness knows how many others 

I've been spoilt by Wolf Hall!

Cosi me too! 

Indian Summers is allright, still sticking with it  

FM
Originally Posted by Eugene's Lair:
Originally Posted by Cinds:
Originally Posted by Enthusiastic Contrafibularities:

 

 

Pompidou - The product of someone who has had success and been given carte blanche to produce any old crap.

 

Not your finest hour Mr Lucas.

 

I tried to watch it yesterday.  I think I lasted less than 2 minutes.  It was awful & from what I did see, very Mr Bean. 

Well... Let's not forget that there are a lot of people who really love Mr Bean.

FWIW, I thought the first episode was a lot funnier, with some very clever gags. However, Sunday's episode was a disappointment, IMO.

I wasn't criticising Mr Bean as such, what I meant was it had already been done.

Cinds
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:
Originally Posted by Cosmopolitan:
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:
Originally Posted by Cosmopolitan:
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:

Is Poldark any good? I'm waiting for reviews before taking the plunge 

Especially as that Banished on BBC2 last week was bleedin' awful  

 

Oh hell.  I was hoping it might be a go-er  

You could give it a go Cosi  Within about 15 mins I decided it was too sh*te to bother with. Mind you I didn't take to Downton either. What do I know ?

 

I was relying on it instead of going with Poldark... which I don't fancy at all.

I'll give it a go, but I'll probably end up deleting the series record like I did for Fortitude, Indian Summer and goodness knows how many others 

I've been spoilt by Wolf Hall!

Cosi me too! 

Indian Summers is allright, still sticking with it  

I gave up on Indian Summers  during the second episode, but then I saw a trailer and gave it another go on catch up and got in to it again!    I'm quite liking it now.

 

I've got Banished recorded - haven't seen it, also got Poldark on series link and have heard nothing but raving about it since Sunday, so I'll give that a go too.

 

 

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:
Originally Posted by Cosmopolitan:
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:
Originally Posted by Cosmopolitan:
Originally Posted by Roger the Alien:

Is Poldark any good? I'm waiting for reviews before taking the plunge 

Especially as that Banished on BBC2 last week was bleedin' awful  

 

Oh hell.  I was hoping it might be a go-er  

You could give it a go Cosi  Within about 15 mins I decided it was too sh*te to bother with. Mind you I didn't take to Downton either. What do I know ?

 

I was relying on it instead of going with Poldark... which I don't fancy at all.

I'll give it a go, but I'll probably end up deleting the series record like I did for Fortitude, Indian Summer and goodness knows how many others 

I've been spoilt by Wolf Hall!

Cosi me too! 

Indian Summers is allright, still sticking with it  

I gave up on Indian Summers  during the second episode, but then I saw a trailer and gave it another go on catch up and got in to it again!    I'm quite liking it now.

 

I've got Banished recorded - haven't seen it, also got Poldark on series link and have heard nothing but raving about it since Sunday, so I'll give that a go too.

 

 

Ta Kaffs reckon I'll give Poldark go. Indian Summers is a bit hard to categorize... its like a big budget, slow moving soap opera. I missed the second episode but happily continued with it none the wiser  They go over the plot points again and again anyway  

FM

I'm looking forward to Ordinary Lies.     I like a lot of the cast and the idea of all the storylines intertwining.  (I expect some will be put off by the fact that one of the characters is played by Michelle thingy - Tina from Corrie though (from what I see on the trailers, she's playing pretty much the same character too)

Kaffs

DOCUMENTARY: Back in Time for Dinner

Channel: BBC 2

Date: Tuesday 17th March 2015

Time: 20:00 to 21:00

Duration: 1 hour'

 

1950s. Episode 1. 

Historical cooking show. One British family embark on an extraordinary time-travelling adventure to discover how a post-war revolution in the food we eat has transformed the way we live. In this first episode, they travel back to 1950 - so it's goodbye open-plan living, hello formal dining room and basic kitchen. Guided by presenter Giles Coren, food historian Polly Russell and the National Food Survey (a 50-year collection of food diaries), the family can only consume the food of the period - cue a diet of dried eggs, national bread, dripping and liver. And taking on the roles of the period, mum is doing all the cooking, while dad relaxes with a pipe and slippers. The family mood is lightened by the end of rationing in 1954, heralding the consumer boom of the late 50s - Mary Berry sells them an electric oven on hire purchase (a job she actually used to do in the 1950s!) and mum discovers that, with all the new food, fads and gadgets on offer, cooking gets a lot more complicated.

 

Copyright GipsyMedia Ltd.

 

 

Sounds worth a go.

Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×