Skip to main content

Originally Posted by Rosgirl:
Originally Posted by MrMincePie:

Louis spouts the same shite every act...

 

 

 

 

*waves pen*

 

 

"You're a popstar, you were born to do this, you can sell records... I want you in the final, I want (insert region here) to pick up the phone for you, well done"

yes

still LoL LOLLing at this - so spot on

Rocking Ros Rose
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Eileen Over:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

We seem to be calling singing loud 'shouting' now?

there is a difference Kathy.

Elaine Paige projects

Witney projects]

Mischa and Amelia shout,


I disagree.... Elaine Paige doesn't sing rock.    As cupcake says - amelia is a rock singer.  

 

let's have her do 'dont cry for me Argentina' and see how she goes....

 

then we'll have Elaine Paige do 'Final Countdown'  

She could do it

FM
Originally Posted by Eileen Over:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Eileen Over:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

We seem to be calling singing loud 'shouting' now?

there is a difference Kathy.

Elaine Paige projects

Witney projects]

Mischa and Amelia shout,


I disagree.... Elaine Paige doesn't sing rock.    As cupcake says - amelia is a rock singer.  

 

let's have her do 'dont cry for me Argentina' and see how she goes....

 

then we'll have Elaine Paige do 'Final Countdown'  

She could do it


Yeah... but I bet she'd be shouty! 

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by Rosgirl:
Originally Posted by Videostar:

BTW, what did Gary mean when he said "it's great to hear that song sung in tune"    surely he's not slating the original version of that song.?? 

I wondered about that vids

T'PAU was a much under-rated band, I loved them.

yes they were good - loved them singing that song

Rocking Ros Rose
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

We seem to be calling singing loud 'shouting' now?

Each to their own, but IMO, someone needs their ears unclogging of wax if they think Amelia can't sing.

Okay I'll make it easy for you and everyone else on here who seem to think she's a great singer. Next time she performs, listen. Listen to the first part of the song, then listen to the chorus. As soon as she reaches a note she can't 'sing' she yells it. That basically means she has a very limited vocal range but can get away with it by shouting or yelling the note.

 

Tell-tale signs: the note is yelled in one long line with no intonation and no character just a long drone that tails off suddenly, just stops DEAD. That's what you get when someone is shouting because they can't control the note.

 

That's my last word on this except to say it's Kelly's fault for not teaching her how to sing properly and control the notes. She really should know better, maybe she can't be arsed I don't know. She probably thinks Amelia is popular enough with all the yelling anyway so why bother.

Prometheus

Disagree Prom 100%.  You are clearly hearing something that we are not ... and Eileen over too....... Amelia is a rock singer and she sings like all the good rock singers.. yes she is a bit shouty, but that is part of her and her singing...  Some people obviously like Janet's out of tune warbling, but it makes me wanna switch off...  But Amelia is amazing IMO.  It has to be a case of agreeing to differ... coz I can't agree that Amelia can't sing and she just shouts.  I am 100% in disagreement.

 

LITTLE MIX; beautiful.  GREAT!

FM
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

Nice condescending post there, Prom.

 

I still think you're wrong.

It wasn't meant to be condescending sorry Kaffy 


No probs..   all about debate innit.

 

Now... do you agree that Tulisa looks like she's tucked her skirt into her knickers?

She does  Shame she didn't stuff it into her gob so we wouldn't have to listen to her drivel 

Prometheus

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×