Skip to main content

Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.

Tell that to Robbie Williams

Are you seriously saying Robbie Williams can't sing?


No.. but I'm saying he's no Pavarotti


I'll elaborate.. you're slagging singers off for not being note perfect.  I'm sure even Robbie will confess he's not note perfect.

Fat ballet dancer from Take That...

MrMincePie
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:Well I guess its a matter of opinion, but I do like her... but can you honestly say that Leon jackson was actually BETTER?  If you say she is the worst, then I gather you think he was better??

I've no idea who Leon Jackson is I never saw that one. I don't like Matt McCardle either he's a right wimp but he can at least sing. Amelia shouts everything because she can't reach the notes. When Gary said it was a semitone too high for her he was talking rubbish. She HAS to shout because she can't hold the notes it's nothing to do with range.


Just a thought - but IMO you can't say that Amelia is the worst X factor winner ever if you havent seen every X factor ........   

 

Best to agree to differ here I think..............

Second worst then

FM
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.

Tell that to Robbie Williams

Are you seriously saying Robbie Williams can't sing?


No.. but I'm saying he's no Pavarotti


I'll elaborate.. you're slagging singers off for not being note perfect.  I'm sure even Robbie will confess he's not note perfect.

 

It's nothing at all to do with being note perfect. I didn't say she was out of tune I said her voice is average and far too weak to hit the high notes so they does what all bad singers do in that situation, she shouts. Robbie has a very strong voice and he knows how to use it and I'm not a fan of his.

Prometheus
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.

Tell that to Robbie Williams

Are you seriously saying Robbie Williams can't sing?


No.. but I'm saying he's no Pavarotti


I'll elaborate.. you're slagging singers off for not being note perfect.  I'm sure even Robbie will confess he's not note perfect.

 

It's nothing at all to do with being note perfect. I didn't say she was out of tune I said her voice is average and far too weak to hit the high notes so they does what all bad singers do in that situation, she shouts. Robbie has a very strong voice and he knows how to use it and I'm not a fan of his.

He wouldnt take on a song like that ...knows his limits

CaptVimes
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.

Tell that to Robbie Williams

Are you seriously saying Robbie Williams can't sing?


No.. but I'm saying he's no Pavarotti


I'll elaborate.. you're slagging singers off for not being note perfect.  I'm sure even Robbie will confess he's not note perfect.

 

It's nothing at all to do with being note perfect. I didn't say she was out of tune I said her voice is average and far too weak to hit the high notes so they does what all bad singers do in that situation, she shouts. Robbie has a very strong voice and he knows how to use it and I'm not a fan of his.

Amelia-Lilly has more talent than most who are left, she is (apart from Misha B) the only credible act left.

Videostar
Originally Posted by CaptVimes:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.

Tell that to Robbie Williams

Are you seriously saying Robbie Williams can't sing?


No.. but I'm saying he's no Pavarotti


I'll elaborate.. you're slagging singers off for not being note perfect.  I'm sure even Robbie will confess he's not note perfect.

 

It's nothing at all to do with being note perfect. I didn't say she was out of tune I said her voice is average and far too weak to hit the high notes so they does what all bad singers do in that situation, she shouts. Robbie has a very strong voice and he knows how to use it and I'm not a fan of his.

He wouldnt take on a song like that ...knows his limits


exactly Captain.. you have to bear in mind that they ALWAYS push the contestants to sing songs outwith their comfort zone

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Videostar:

Little Mix are evolving, getting better week after week. 


At first glance, that looked like Little Mix are revolting! 


Only the girl with the squashed looking face, you know the one.


LOL, I think she looks like a character from over the hedge....

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×