Misha B and subtlety. Ne'er the twain will meet, just belt everything out from start to finish why not?
Originally Posted by Yogi19:
Originally Posted by Rosgirl:
Originally Posted by Yogi19:
Not the sob story stuff.
they are just trying to soften her image - I am not fooled - a leopard and all that
I'm not fooled either, Ros. You could sharpen tools on that lass.
she looked what she was at the start and still is - agree yogi
Bad ending.. ouch!
I don't particularly like the girl - but I do think she can sing
Prefer her to whiney ass whitney anyway
Well sang Mischa B 
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.Tell that to Robbie Williams
EXACTLY, stage presence and personality is of paramount importance .. it's not just about being the best voice... look at Madonna and gaga.... and britney and kylie... not the best voices, but they have that special something, and Amelia has it IMO
That bored me. Wouldn't be sorry to see her go.
I'm in Manchester and I'm not gonna lift the phone for anyone... so shut the hell up with this Manchester backing Misha crap.
Janets grandfather died last week and she had less tears.
Misha just sings (loudly) don't feel the song or her tho......My phone stays well down!....BORING!
I wish Louis would piss off with the 'everyone in manchester pick up the phones bullshit' 
Originally Posted by Supercalifragilistic:
Well sang Mischa B
Yep! 
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Rexi:
Hmmmmmmmmm, I just thought it was very loud and very ordinary
I agree Rexi and they're all making every excuse in the book for her. Worst X Factor winner ever if she gets it.
Must disagree. Leon, shit singer, no personality Jackson and Matt boring as hell Cardle win hands down when it comes to the title of worst winners! Amelia is already 100 times better than them! At least she has personality and stage presence.. as well as a voice!
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.
Well I guess its a matter of opinion, but I do like her... but can you honestly say that Leon jackson was actually BETTER? If you say she is the worst, then I gather you think he was better??
I've no idea who Leon Jackson is I never saw that one. I don't like Matt McCardle either he's a right wimp but he can at least sing. Amelia shouts everything because she can't reach the notes. When Gary said it was a semitone too high for her he was talking rubbish. She HAS to shout because she can't hold the notes it's nothing to do with range.
Originally Posted by disley21:
That bored me. Wouldn't be sorry to see her go.
yup 
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Add to that, Leon Jackson couldn't even sing, unless you like a flat out of tune voice. 
He was dreadful Vids... and so dull, like Matt from last year... Amelia pisses all over them.. That said, Craig or Marcus or littlemix winning would be OK for me too 
Not sure how it would go down if Amelia won as she kind of got a free ticket into the top 7, when the others had worked hard for 6 weeks while she was away.....
Again, I love your views, i've been saying this about the past bland winners for ages on here, but you listen to most on here and they talk about Matt as if he is the second coming of John Lennon. lol
This show is called The X Factor, that to me means someone who has not only a great singing voice but who has personality, who puts on a performance and who is different to the norm.
Not some bozo who stands rooted to the spot week after week hamering out ballards and smiling sweetly to camera....that is in no way X Factor.
Sorry....bored with Mischa now........
What the hell is 'set it off'?
Getting taxis!? No way, wonder what that feels like
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Videostar:
Add to that, Leon Jackson couldn't even sing, unless you like a flat out of tune voice.
He was dreadful Vids... and so dull, like Matt from last year... Amelia pisses all over them.. That said, Craig or Marcus or littlemix winning would be OK for me too Not sure how it would go down if Amelia won as she kind of got a free ticket into the top 7, when the others had worked hard for 6 weeks while she was away.....
Again, I love your views, i've been saying this about the past bland winners for ages on here, but you listen to most on here and they talk about Matt as if he is the second coming of John Lennon. lol
This show is called The X Factor, that to me means someone who has not only a great singing voice but who has personality, who puts on a performance and who is different to the norm.
Not some bozo who stands rooted to the spot week after week hamering out ballards and smiling sweetly to camera....that is in no way X Factor.
Thanks Vids Like I said up there ^^^ its not just the voice that sells records... looks and personality and stage presence are important too. One of the most bland winners ever IMO was Leona Lewis... can't stand her.. I would sooner watch paint dry than watch her...
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Rexi:
Hmmmmmmmmm, I just thought it was very loud and very ordinary
I agree Rexi and they're all making every excuse in the book for her. Worst X Factor winner ever if she gets it.
Must disagree. Leon, shit singer, no personality Jackson and Matt boring as hell Cardle win hands down when it comes to the title of worst winners! Amelia is already 100 times better than them! At least she has personality and stage presence.. as well as a voice!
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.
Well I guess its a matter of opinion, but I do like her... but can you honestly say that Leon jackson was actually BETTER? If you say she is the worst, then I gather you think he was better??
I've no idea who Leon Jackson is I never saw that one. I don't like Matt McCardle either he's a right wimp but he can at least sing. Amelia shouts everything because she can't reach the notes. When Gary said it was a semitone too high for her he was talking rubbish. She HAS to shout because she can't hold the notes it's nothing to do with range.
The song was too big for her voice ...its Aretha FFS bad song choice really
Little Mix have been growing on me the past few weeks - looking forward to what they do this week.
That Mischa's got a fair set of pipes on her.
WTF was Louis KNOW NOTHING fuggin' Walsh yammering on about earlier?
Licence to Kill not a good Bond song? Is he having a laugh??? 
Hello everybody xxx
Already this is more rock than the song they sang in rock week.
Evening Cos.... all shopped out?
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.Tell that to Robbie Williams
Are you seriously saying Robbie Williams can't sing?
Hi Cosmo.
As girl bands go, these girls aren't bad.
Originally Posted by Rexi:
Originally Posted by disley21:
That bored me. Wouldn't be sorry to see her go.
yup
same here
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:Well I guess its a matter of opinion, but I do like her... but can you honestly say that Leon jackson was actually BETTER? If you say she is the worst, then I gather you think he was better??
I've no idea who Leon Jackson is I never saw that one. I don't like Matt McCardle either he's a right wimp but he can at least sing. Amelia shouts everything because she can't reach the notes. When Gary said it was a semitone too high for her he was talking rubbish. She HAS to shout because she can't hold the notes it's nothing to do with range.
Just a thought - but IMO you can't say that Amelia is the worst X factor winner ever if you havent seen every X factor ........
Best to agree to differ here I think..............
Loved that!
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.Tell that to Robbie Williams
Are you seriously saying Robbie Williams can't sing?
No.. but I'm saying he's no Pavarotti
Very good
Originally Posted by Yogi19:
Hi Cosmo.
As girl bands go, these girls aren't bad.
agree yogi - just going to post that
hi cosi
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Evening Cos.... all shopped out?
Might be 
Just sat and stuffed my face while I watched from Craig onwards.
I may have to kill Louis Walsh after dissin' Glady's song 
I like these girls ... they get better each week
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Go into any karaoke in the country and you'll find drunk people with better voices than her. She's incredibly average and has to shout the notes she can't hit. Stage presence and personality doesn't sell records.Tell that to Robbie Williams
Are you seriously saying Robbie Williams can't sing?
No.. but I'm saying he's no Pavarotti
I'll elaborate.. you're slagging singers off for not being note perfect. I'm sure even Robbie will confess he's not note perfect.
Originally Posted by disley21:
Already this is more rock than the song they sang in rock week.
Tulisa doesnt know what rock is and doesnt know what soul is going by today but somehow she has a group thats good.
"Best girl group to come out of the UK"
Not much of an achievement when every girl group in the UK is shite
Yes that was brilliant. I have not disliked ONE Little mix performance yet! I am actually OK with them winning X factor.....
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by Christmas Cupcake:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:Well I guess its a matter of opinion, but I do like her... but can you honestly say that Leon jackson was actually BETTER? If you say she is the worst, then I gather you think he was better??
I've no idea who Leon Jackson is I never saw that one. I don't like Matt McCardle either he's a right wimp but he can at least sing. Amelia shouts everything because she can't reach the notes. When Gary said it was a semitone too high for her he was talking rubbish. She HAS to shout because she can't hold the notes it's nothing to do with range.
Just a thought - but IMO you can't say that Amelia is the worst X factor winner ever if you havent seen every X factor ........
Best to agree to differ here I think..............
Second worst then