I don't think either of them are Xmas No one material...

bring back Shaking Stevens

I don't like Rebecca's sheepy voice. She doesn't project any personality and gives no "performance", IMO.

Louie is like a broken-down record might as well not be there

well, based on those performances, it is Matt to win

so there Issy

Not sure about the song.. but I like her.  Hmmmm.......  think I'll go for Matt though.

WHY DOESN'T REBECCA EVER FINISH HER SONGS PROPERLY FFS!!!! 

She just cuts off with no big ending.

matt to win based on that

When she finds her music - and that wasn't it - she'll be good  

Oh I know he is going to win...

But is he a star?
Will he have staying power?

Not a chance in hell

Hmmmm - not sure 

Not in love with that song.

I don't get this gripe about her not moving...?  Far too often they use dancing as a distraction from their poor singing on this show.
Biffa's keen on such tactics too.

Yep Matt to win and Rebecca to still do well... she is from Liverpool... did you know?


Z.

I agree it can be anti-climatic sometimes. She has an amazing voice though.

It took me a minute to realise they both have sang the same song.
Matt was better.

When Rebecca is on her game she has a very strong voice,  I wish her luck.

I call all my friends girls - most of us in our 50's some 60's - I don't find it offensive. I still see my mates as girls - I'd never, ever call them women or ladies TBH.

Makes me sound a bit sad - perhaps I am

Much preferred Rebecca's song to Matt's.

Still think he might clinch it though

Another Leon/Steve/Shayne??

** What cosi said.

Still want the raw talent  

replies lack intelligence from Rebecca - sorry

I don't necessarily think she needs to move around much, but she is just like a plank, to the extent that if you couldn't see her lips moving, you wouldn't be sure that she wasn't really a dummy.  

Erin... different songs!

Rebecca's voice is so much better than Matt's and I think shes been the stronger tonight, but I think the public like a "passive modest guy"  which Matt pretends to be so he'll sadly win.

Piss off Cheryl.

Then we shall sit in the Sad Corner together.
Mr. Cosi and his mates always call us 'The girls'.

He's such a charmer........

I've been to Liverpool   

I dont find it offensive either. We should be allowed to feel as young as we feel.

Is anyone in Liverpool allowed to vote for Matt?

I call my mates "girls"

I don't see the problem

I just can't imagine watching her in concert ... she really wouldn't need a big stage would she!!??

Thanks for the reply - it made me do a very un-ladylike *snort*. 

Not according to Louis.

I go one worse - I call mine 'girlies'

It's ironic, I dislike Cheryl with a passion and im still backing her singers and yet Dannii is my favourite judge( for several different reasons )  and yet I cant stand her guy.

If they were horses....

Matt's exposed.

Spot on Vids and apparently he is the "housewive's favourite"

Which explains why I can't stand him - I was always a rubbish housewife

I think Matt has staying power. I can see him doing acoustic sets with his little hat on.

I'd definitely go to see him

is thsi site stuck? only at least 10 mins have gone by and still on same page, even though refreshed over and over again .. scream a little, not to loud though

Is that a good thing?