Well, everyone was sort of spectacularly bad this weekend.  She's been in the bottom two more often than not, I think it's fair to assume that the (voting!) public aren't that keen.. at least not keen enough for her to win - unless there's a huge upset.  That's not to say she's not going to have a career, it's pretty obvious Mr Cowell has something invested in her somehow...

Probably  Don't get me wrong, I couldn't really care less. But I found  this last week quite a watershed. I would have staked my house on Matt or Rebecca winning, and Katie disappearing. It was not to be.

Rumour has it that Wagner will be singing creep!!

Oh gawd help us

The more they try to humiliate him ,the more people will support him.

I don't think anyone is trying to humiliate him - I think he is doing a pretty good job of that himself

 Wagner cant sing thats for sure,he embarasses himself every week ,but they are giving him the song Creep to further mock him .It will just make more people support him.
Keep voting Wagner

The X Factor semi-final will take place over the weekend of December 4 and 5.
So is this the last week when the judges can vote someone off?
I can see the "rules" being changed AGAIN.

Wagner wins will be a blessing fot them all, Wagner doesn't really want a recording contract he just wants into showbiz. The likes of Rebecca are better as far away from Cowell as they can get, he's proved that the basically tears peoples lives apart, see any other winner outside maybe Leona and Alexandra.  JLS are with a different label and they are doing far better than Alexandra.

I want Wagner to win..he's shit but so are the rest of them.However any vote is lining Cowalls pockets.He doesn't give  a damn..he's laughing at the gullible public that still think this stupid arsed show matters.

Student shown with Wagner to win banner( got this on DS)
http://img199.imageshack.us/img199/3482/44706466.jpg

I doubt that Wagner will sing the correct version of Creep. It would cause all manner of problems.

I disagree Katty, no way is Matt or Rebecca shit.  They both have great voices and one of them should win - but alas I think it will probably be One Direction because of the teenies voting cos "they're fit"

I do agree, however, about Simon Cowell.  He is loving all this controversery this year and is adding to it, but keeping Katie in each time she is in the bottom - something he has not done on previous shows.  This year the show has patently shown itself up for the fix that it is with the producers and Cowell making up the rules as they go along.

That's what I thought, but The Beatles sorted 'em out good and proper.

Admittedly, their performances were not as good as previous weeks, but it still doesn't mean that they do not have great voices - imo of course.

..and mine.

http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/ho...or-the-X-Factor.html
Hope double eviction is true ,we will definately get Katie/Cher

If David Bowie released the song 'Heroes' and put the same price and gave the same per copy sold to charity, which would you buy?

I thought it was a poor week all in all.

Yes

Why does the single cost double what other singles cost?

Bowies without a doubt.

I will willingly donate to the charity but I refuse to buy that heap of dross

If it's a double eviction, I just hope that one of them is Rebecca.  I can't understand how she can still be there after last week. 

Latest from Matt,I am going off the guy week by week
         

Cardle - who has previously expressed his dismay at Carrilho's progress on the show - again questioned the Brazilian's place in the competition as he made his prediction.

Cardle said: "It would be fun to win, I'd like that - but I have a really terrible feeling that bloody Wagner is going to win now. It is a joke."

According to The Sun, Cardle made the comments at a London record store while promoting the X Factor finalists' charity single 'Heroes', but was soon instructed by show staff to stop talking.

The 27-year-old had previously promised that he would "shut the hell up" following a string of comments about Carrilho. Insiders admit that the singer is worried his remarks could have affected his chances.

"Matt thinks he has blown it," a source said. "He was loved by everyone but this spat with Wagner has turned fans against him. He knows he should keep his mouth shut but finds it infuriating that somebody who is tone deaf is still on the show."

So the show isnt rigged!
http://www.getbracknell.co.uk/...w_over_katie_waissel

Matt is saying what everyone else is thinking but he should be careful the Wagner fans dont turn on him .. Matt for the win

Matt could make it even if he doesn't win ... look at JLS


And lets be honest, if Vagner does win, who's going to buy his albums ? .... certainly not all those who voted for him to win.

I see your point, but I think that applies  to 'em all.

Not really.

Those who are voting for Vagner to win have ulterior motives .... Those who are voting for instance: Matt or Rebecca, are voting for all the right reasons, & will probably go on to buy thier music.

Absolutely.

I always buy the album, if I've voted for them.

A bit value laden if I may say so.

http://www.heatworld.com/XFact...-week-The-song-list/

Show's a shambles.

Full slaughterhouse.

Nuff said  

I was always concerned about the rock theme week... glad they not chosen any Oasis songs Can't stand muppets trying to do covers of them, great bands should be left alone.

The only one I may object to this week is "Welcome to the jungle"... I suppose Matt is singing it, so fingers crossed he doesnt fook it up.


Pisses me off watching wannabes try copy great bands like The Beatles, Oasis, Led Zeppelin and Guns N Roses

Can someone translate?cheers
http://www.oddschecker.com/spe...tor/next-elimination

Indeed you may .... this is a public forum and we are all entitled to our opinion

Although I agree with you and your views on the "voting for Wagner" fiasco, my point is that everyone votes for the right reasons.

Ahhh rock week. Cher's finished then.