I know what you mean.

Ok Matt was good tonight, but im not a fan of men singing womens songs, it just doesn't work.


Matt still isn't as good as Cher.

Pure class from Matt!!!!

And Wagner,... please!  He is just bloody bloody awful.. MAry was HORRID, and proved she is an average karaoke singer.    Not impressed tonight.  Loved cher last week but not good this week IMO.

He's gorjuss - really hope he wins - not a prima donna at all - very likeable

;ello, lady xx

HEAR HEAR.


I cant take her comments seriously because she has little talent herself.

I wonder if Matt sang exactly as he did, but wasn't good looking, if people would still think he 'sang well' ??    I wonder if it's the 'halo' effect?

I agree with all of that, Ros.

here you go ladies!

http://www.facebook.com/#!/mattcardlemusic

 Do you want some in full Technicolor Panavision?  

I'm old enough to be his Mum and don't think he's that good looking - so I say yes.

and you.

Yes please Velvet.

But Matt isn't good looking    True, he doesn't make me struggle to hold onto the contents of my stomach in the same way that Aiden does, but he's very, very averagely ordinary.

What a stupid post... im a male and I still think he sang well. And no im not gay either

so do I - with knobs on

Matt`s been my fave so far but I didn`t like that too much.

not keen on treyc

BTW, the song Matt sang was in no way an American Anthem, it was a random song once sang by an American that meant something personal to him, so he broke the theme week rules too.


Lets hear some stick for him too.

 

Dull song, playing it safe...

She looks lovely ,sings well.

well I am old and have a hearing disability so most sound terrible to me but Matt voice is PURE and i can hear every note. he has to be the winner! he, rebbeca abd Ganu all excellent. any newsof her by the way? poor kid. who would want to go back to nightmare Zimbardwi.. hope they let her stay.

I love this song, a proper American Anthem imo!!!!

This looks to be one of Treyc's best performances...

After Rebecca and Matt she is the best of the rest!

NO!

sorry - not keen on this -

This is the only real singer left in the competition. Blows them all out of sight from the first line to the last.

Hello all *waves*

Matt is usually my favourite, but I thought he wailed a bit during that song....sorry!

Shockingly, Rebecca is my fave tonight, the way she sang that song, it really got me. I found her bland in the previous weeks but tonight she stood out IMO.

double no

Assuming that I would think a man is gay because he enjoys hearing a man sing is a ludicrous and laughable and childish thing to say.   I did expect a comment like this though.   No surprise at all. 

Cher and Katie were sh*t tonight along with Mary.

I think the family's been given leave to appeal. FGN


TreyC - was good, but it just didn't move me.

Her best week I think


Z.

Well she was great but sadly does not have a dead relative, nor children nor has she been got up to look like a tragic dead singer - so she will not get anywhere.

yes - exactly how I feel

TreyC is very pedestrian. 

If she's pedestrian the rest of them are six feet under.