Oh dear god.......a who's the best Star Trek captain argument?

That's worse than who's the best HM!


*runs for cover*

I couldn't even remember his name (Sisko) just then when I was replying to your first DS9 post!   He was crap.

Picard - sometimes I love him.... but he is a bit up himself sometimes.   But probably is the best Captain.

I like a lot of the Voyager storylines best though (though Janeway gets on my norks sometimes too)...    

I think my fave character has got to be the borg queen ...    and Seven's breasts (I have to acknowledge Seven's breasts...  hubby insists they get the respect they deserve whenever Voyager is discussed! )

BUT there is usually a universal agreement that Sisko was the worst.... that unites us.

Its the old school KIrk lovers that get most upset in this debate

I like and dislike Sam in equal measures.
I like him for being a viewer and mixing it up the way we all want to when we watch at home
I dislike him for actually being like that in real life

I know,, I'm all mixed up!

The trouble with Voyager is that they all got a bit intense,
BUT I loved the doctor..

"please state the nature of your medical emergency.."

Oh and Worf cracked me up - he used to get so indignant over everything.

A bit like Dave then?

Crappest head of security ever!!

I reckon I could beat up Worf!

& yeah.. the doctor was funny...   I quite liked the Paris/Torres relationship as well

Yes....  Dave is the evil twin of Sisko  (Sisko is not evil.... just very wet, weak & a crap actor)

LOL at this thread...obviously Sam is appealing to the geek population of the forum.

oh and the answer is Picard 

I want Sam to win and I'm not a geek. I'm one of those amazingly cool and trendy types, honest 

Picard to win!

Me too

I embrace my inner geek

Picard is the man of my dreams *sighs*

I read something ages ago that geeks make the best partners...

Oh, flippin eck! I've just told Rexi I'm goin to bed (bah this work thing)! and am lurking and that has made me laugh out loud - again! Trouble is, I'm the only one in this house

It's the voice..

you're a football geek which is lower down the evolutionary scale to a Trekkie, but  a geek nonetheless

You lied 

I would just like to point out in a non geeky way that Captain Kirk was by far the best Star Trek captain. It's just something I heard, I would never watch it, I'm far too cool 

It's true! My sister was with this bloke once, he was truly a geek and his name was Trevor.

He will now be forever known as "Good in bed Trev"

ooooh...   old school Kirkie alert 

Yes, that voice, that bald head that quiet authorative air 'sigh'

"make it so"

There is no room for Kirk in this Inn
He was a terrible captain

As for Captains - I'm with Weird Al Jankovich - The only Question I've found hard, is do I like Kirk or do I like Picard?     Think Picard just edges it 

every away mission was all about him getting his end away 

Number one....
*swoons*...

Oh why, oh why couldn't this thread  have been over the weekend. I could've had fun in here

....and he was soooo clever, and honourable , and brave, and insightful, and trustworthy, and adventurous, and kind ....

He was good in his day though

I think that Riker in the earlier series of TNG was definitely based on Kirk.
He was always at it

I will do a Dave and resurrect it.

Bring us about 1/4 impulse - Engage! *sighs*

For sure ....he even looked a bit like him in the earlier episodes when he was younger

You've all lost me now.

yeah.... he was as well...  and ooooh yeah!   

now you have said that I won't be able to look past the similarities.

I loved the original star trek... but I was just a kid when they were first on...   and at the beginning & end credits they had the picture of the people with big heads....  and they used to scare the bejesus out of me...   I used to hide behind the sofa

I saw Patrick Stewart AND David Tennant in Hamlet..
Soooo good