Enjoy the concert

was he spaced out last night?

Dunno but he entertained us. I think that was the second best guest performance so far. Though to be fair there has been a load of dross.
Whilst I remember.... does anyone know why Dermot looks and acts so excited when he comes out? He's kicking and a jiggling those little legs fit to bust, yes he is.

I really like Dermot. I listened to him being interviewed the other week and he just sounds like a normal person who likes the jobs that he does and hopes it may continue. I know I couldn't stand up in front of that crowd, the judges and 14 million viewers.

I couldn't stand him in BB but I do like him in this.

I liked Robbie Williams when he went solo loved his music but I dont think Take That should have had him back they dont need him, and he is very fickle wondering when he will pull out as I cant see it lasting this time round either ...

Same here Isadora

He is there to rescue his ailing career Marg - he needs them more than they need him and that will become obvious.

I agree 

It came across to me on that documentary on at the weekend that he is like some wayward child that they are helping.  They are so strong they are like a family having to rescue him.  I dont think he will stay for long, and i hope he doesnt wreck them in the process. I also dont like the music they have made with him as much as the stuff they do on their own. I think they are all really strong to have him back after all the stuff he did to them and said about them.

worst mistake they've ever made having him back..........

Apart from disliking him intensely, I cannot stand his voice and his singing face.

TBH that's what made the venture so exciting in the Joe household! Mrs J. was heard to say, "I can't bear to watch" as she viewed the proceedings through her fingers. Sighs of relief at the end. Job well done!

My feelings exactly. Why have they taken him back?He was on a downhill slope(all of his own doing) He used to be good but has turnened into someone who thinks the public cant do without. Get back in your world of depression Robbie and think of the folk who have to cope without your £Millions.

The so-called fame has gone to his head and he thinks himself as a god. Hope he bombs-the arrogant asshole.

Robbie Williams has more talent in his little finger than the rest of Take That put together

I thought it was painful watching the documentry, like walking on egg shell, waiting for it kick off , also a bit on the gloomy side, although I did like the way they were working towards the new album, Robbie is still one of the biggest selling pop stars in the world, He could tour solo tomorrow and sell more tickets than most, yet it's  emotionally I don't think he could handle it alone, He seemed at ease on X factor with the band on Sunday, unlike last years perormances.


have fun in Ireland Gypsie, your have a brilliant time,

we've 2 nights at Wembley so far, still trying for Villa Park tickets.

yes, yes,

and yet it's the Gary Barlow penned Album that looks set to be one of the fastest selling albums on record.   maybe the writing isn't the talent.

He is a Giant nob but then Barlow and the cute wee daemon Mark are not far behind. The orange one and the one I forget seem to be nice gay men 

Erm...Robbie was writing tunes for it from what i saw of the docu.  And if he was that good, where were all his fans during his solo 'career'

Hah!  No response, therefore I win! 


Lori close the thread quick

Don't be daft this will trundle on for years till one of you scrawls the last word on the others grave stone 

*dances on the report button*

His first solo album sold well, before he showed the world his acting skills,

have you never seen Heartbeat.

  wasn't that Nick Berry?

 If he wasn't it was a good impression  

 have I been had.

I've think I might of had this conversation with you before, in a previous life.

 just seen your profile pic, I should have known,

  When you started picking on me you made me sad

robbies career is flailing. FACT (look im ranting in caps...this wont end well) and for some mental reason i honestly feel, based on what i saw, that take that are giving him a rescuing hand up. I think it makes them really quite astonishing people because i would have laughed at him after all the things he said about them and the personal attacks he made at gary on his years when he thought he ruled the world (see what i did there )

Correction Howard is a Nob too, maybe so Orange is a nice gay man on his own. 

I agree with this...i think most people would have stood up and applauded had TT told robbie to bog off rather than let him come back.  It says far more about them as people than him, that they didn't do it.

Take That have been asking Robbie to rejoin the band since 2006.  It was their idea not his.


Robbie doesn't need Take That, for any other reason than to lay old scores to rest and anyone who thinks that it's because his career is 'failing' really hasn't a clue what they're talking about.


Robbie is the only one who made a solo career for himself, out of nothing and that is fact.  No need for caps or ranting, because it is undeniably true.  When he was kicked out of Take That it was widely believed he would fade into oblivion and nothing more would be heard from him.  But he made a crackin, multi-award winning, solo career for himself.



Take That always needed the big theatrics on tour, the spectacle on stage.  Robbie sold out to stadiums with no gimicks or tricks.


 Maybe if the Gary and Mark fans had supported their 'faves' when they needed them, instead of jumping back on the bandwagon when they became popular again they wouldn't feel this guilty need to trounce on Robbie all the time.  As for the Howard and Jason fans, well lets just leave those poor souls be

is that the little finger that's been stuck on redial to Sir Barlow's mobile 

  coughs "killer net"......coughs...

Isn't that what they were famous for, even going back to Wembley Arena & Earls Court days , they alway put a lot into the live shows.

" The only trick I saw on the last tour was when I gave me daughter some notes for a programme, and she made the lot disappear, returning with tee shirts, bracelets, and an unbrella"

owns 1  copy of Green Man...    ,

Don't you try and lecture me on TT RZB, i was screaming at the concerts whilst you were still listening to T-Rex!