quote:

Originally posted by ѕρι∂єямσηкєγ:
When Sophie rushed back to the bench to report her observations to Lisa regarding what was said in the Kitchen, it confirmed in my mind that she is still under Lisa's control and will continue to be until she or Lisa is evicted.

Shame, I thought she might have a mind of her own. I was wrong.

quote:

Originally posted by JacksonB:
rabbit..

quote:

Originally posted by ѕρι∂єямσηкєγ:
When Sophie rushed back to the bench to report her observations to Lisa regarding what was said in the Kitchen, it confirmed in my mind that she is still under Lisa's control and will continue to be until she or Lisa is evicted.

Shame, I thought she might have a mind of her own. I was wrong.

quote:

Originally posted by Jeggo:
I don`t reckon Sophie`s comfortable making conversation or debating stuff with the other group. Lisa and Karly seem to be more on her level.

quote:

Originally posted by BARMY BRUMMIE:

quote:

Originally posted by Jeggo:
I don`t reckon Sophie`s comfortable making conversation or debating stuff with the other group. Lisa and Karly seem to be more on her level.

Dogface hasnt got a lot to say about anything except when she's had a sniff of booze and THEN all u get out of her is 'I'm pissed' - its the only thing she says that u can understand - if though she's lying

quote:

Originally posted by mrMiller:
We only see the highlights. The other group last night was saying how much they like sophie and they have been spending more time with her.

quote:

Originally posted by mrMiller:
We only see the highlights. The other group last night was saying how much they like sophie and they have been spending more time with her.

quote:

Originally posted by Dame_Ann_Average:

quote:

Originally posted by mrMiller:
We only see the highlights. The other group last night was saying how much they like sophie and they have been spending more time with her.

They like her but obviously she cares nothing for them, it's not the first time she'd said stuff about them. Sophie may be quieter and easily led, but she can be snidey like the rest of them. If she's being nice and getting on with both groups, why run and shit stir to Lisa?

quote:

Originally posted by Cold Sweat:

In the closing moments of the show we saw that Sophie would rather go hungry than cause any further trouble. She doesn't smoke, she didn't eat, and she barely gets a say - yet the high horse brigade on here somehow find her guilty???

quote:

Originally posted by Cold Sweat:

quote:

Originally posted by Dame_Ann_Average:

quote:

Originally posted by mrMiller:
We only see the highlights. The other group last night was saying how much they like sophie and they have been spending more time with her.

They like her but obviously she cares nothing for them, it's not the first time she'd said stuff about them. Sophie may be quieter and easily led, but she can be snidey like the rest of them. If she's being nice and getting on with both groups, why run and shit stir to Lisa?

In the same way that yourself and the OP do exactly the same - by using words such as 'run' and 'rushing' which are complete fabrications of what was shown.

If anything she is nervously making her way across from the house - and Lisa plays her before she even reaches the bus stop.

In the closing moments of the show we saw that Sophie would rather go hungry than cause any further trouble. She doesn't smoke, she didn't eat, and she barely gets a say - yet the high horse brigade on here somehow find her guilty???

quote:

Originally posted by ѕρι∂єямσηкєγ:
When Sophie rushed back to the bench to report her observations to Lisa regarding what was said in the Kitchen, it confirmed in my mind that she is still under Lisa's control and will continue to be until she or Lisa is evicted.

Shame, I thought she might have a mind of her own. I was wrong.

quote:

Originally posted by Cold Sweat:
Marcus bitching, backstabbing and stirring in the kitchen about Karly and Lisa gave Sophie a dilemma to deal with. Earlier in the show we had heard her nominate Noirin and Marcus – one of the reasons that she gave was that they were scheming; now we see Sophie was correct with this assessment. I think she is in a no win situation at this point; if she doesn’t tell Lisa and Karly about the discussion in the kitchen she is two faced, if she does, then she looks to be stirring. Regardless, she at least has her nomination decisions confirmed.

If Marcus had not spoken about Lisa and Karly behind their backs the situation would not have arisen – until then, Sophie appeared to be happily chatting with Siavash in the kitchen.

quote:

Originally posted by Liverpoollass:

quote:

Originally posted by Cold Sweat:
Marcus bitching, backstabbing and stirring in the kitchen about Karly and Lisa gave Sophie a dilemma to deal with. Earlier in the show we had heard her nominate Noirin and Marcus – one of the reasons that she gave was that they were scheming; now we see Sophie was correct with this assessment. I think she is in a no win situation at this point; if she doesn’t tell Lisa and Karly about the discussion in the kitchen she is two faced, if she does, then she looks to be stirring. Regardless, she at least has her nomination decisions confirmed.

If Marcus had not spoken about Lisa and Karly behind their backs the situation would not have arisen – until then, Sophie appeared to be happily chatting with Siavash in the kitchen.

She would've earned more respect if she did not go rushing out to tittle tattle to Lisa. Why could she not have shown some individuality? I do admire your defending of her all the time, but sometimes you have to hold your hand up and say "yes she was wrong in what she did"
Oh and before you say it, as much of a Freddy fan that I am, I have criticised him when I think he has done something wrong

quote:

Originally posted by Cold Sweat:


But are you criticising Marcus who clearly orchestrasted the whole incident?

I'm sure Sophie was quite content simply chatting with Siavash at the kitchen table before Marcus began bitching.

quote:

Originally posted by Liverpoollass:

quote:

Originally posted by Cold Sweat:


But are you criticising Marcus who clearly orchestrasted the whole incident?

I'm sure Sophie was quite content simply chatting with Siavash at the kitchen table before Marcus began bitching.

Why should I criticise Marcus? I happen to think that he was spot on with what he said (if you are talkig about the food situation). No-one forced her to go running out to the garden to tell Lisa did they? She just showed how immature she was and really which "side" she would like to stay on. I was hoping to see a more pleasant side to her once Kris went. Perhaps when Karly goes, we might do.

quote:

Originally posted by Cold Sweat:

I wish you could see the errors in your perspective. There was no "running", this point is being fabricated. I think people need to watch the edit back they will see that it was a decision of conscience from Sophie. Whether it was the right decision is another matter.

Once again, if Marcus had not been bitching in front of her about the group that she is more friendly with, the incident would not have happened.

quote:

Originally posted by Liverpoollass:

quote:

Originally posted by Cold Sweat:

I wish you could see the errors in your perspective. There was no "running", this point is being fabricated. I think people need to watch the edit back they will see that it was a decision of conscience from Sophie. Whether it was the right decision is another matter.

Once again, if Marcus had not been bitching in front of her about the group that she is more friendly with, the incident would not have happened.

Well I am not going to argue with you, as it would be a waste of my time.

We obviously see things entirely differently and you will not see that Sophie is ever in the wrong

quote:

Originally posted by jessejay:
maybe she just prefers their company to that of Marcus and Noirin who have taken control of the kitchen and talk about the other group every chance they get , she gets along with Siavash and Rodrigo well enough

quote:

Originally posted by ~~KaffyBaffy~~:

quote:

Originally posted by jessejay:
maybe she just prefers their company to that of Marcus and Noirin who have taken control of the kitchen and talk about the other group every chance they get , she gets along with Siavash and Rodrigo well enough

God, anyone who enjoys the company of those two witches has a serious problem.