Skip to main content

Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
I wud ban anything that deems woman/man to being a possession/2nd class citizen!

Face to face contact is very important in human communication
They don't though. Wearing the burka is not a must, women decided for themselves. I'm sure that there are some husbands who insist, but there are a lot of husbands in this country and all over the world who beat their wives on a regular basis.
And I would ban them too - to some floating island that never saw other land ! with wild animals & a Dr of human genetics who likes to experiment  

As for the wanting to wear the burka - I believe it is because of indoctrination of thought not out of free will at all.
We're all indocrtinated in our childhood, it's how we deal with it when we get older. We can't just deny some people their religion. I happen to be an agnostic, but I can't blame my parents for trying to educate me into their religion. It's natural. We live in a diverse society, so we have to get used to seeing things we haven't be used to before. The burka doesn't actually stop eye contact, does it. The only time  I would advise to take it off would be in a bank or on leaving the country and, after listening to a rather protracted discussion about this a few months ago, all the women concerned said that they would not be adverse to taking the burka off for those reason.
I guess this is where we differ, as my parents never christened me or my siblings as they decided we were to make up our own minds when we had learnt more & growing up moving around the world I have chosen not to conform to any as I see good & bad in all of them- mostly bad in alot unfortunately!
Did folk not look you in the eye & say Good morning to you when you were growing up cos they did me & still do - I like that but when living up in Birmingham for the best part of last year I found it very hard to even make eye contact with women who were covered up let alone pass the time of day with them...I find that rather sad!
slimfern
Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by cologne:
Yesterday, I was waiting in the car while my daughter unloaded her shopping. Out comes a young man who is in all sorts of trouble over all sorts of things. The first thing he does after closing the gate is pulling his hoodie so far over his head that he can only see a foot in front of him. No eyecontact possible, no conversation possible, he just wants to get to his mate's house unspotted, so that he can have his spliff and have a laugh about the next person they will terrorize. I know which I prefer.
I am not sure if you're missing my point Cologne, but your post suggests to me that I have a problem with Muslims but I don't;    I was just saying that I don't think anyone should be allowed to hide their face in this country; and Muslims should not be allowed to either, even if it IS part of their religion...Like I said, I am happy for anyone to celebrate their own culture, but there HAS to be give and take and they must respect our laws,.....they can't have it all their own way.  We ALL have to abide by the laws of this country, so why should Muslims be any different?

Your post confused me a bit... I think you have it in your head that because quite a lot of us on here think that muslims should not be allowed to hide their face, it's because we all dislike them.  That's not true.  We just think that them 'hiding their face' is a bit wrong.
FM
Of course it should be removed for passport checks, when teaching kids etc., but I would hate to see any type of clothing banned in this country. Would you ban sun glasses, as it restricts eye contact? Or covering your face with scarves, in cold weather?

What I have noticed, is that more and more Muslim women are choosing to cover themselves and it seems to coincide with the rise in Islamophobia, since 9/11. I think, in this country, most of them are making a statement, rather than being bullied into it by men.
Blizz'ard
Originally Posted by Blizz'ard:
Of course it should be removed for passport checks, when teaching kids etc., but I would hate to see any type of clothing banned in this country. Would you ban sun glasses, as it restricts eye contact? Or covering your face with scarves, in cold weather?

What I have noticed, is that more and more Muslim women are choosing to cover themselves and it seems to coincide with the rise in Islamophobia, since 9/11. I think, in this country, most of them are making a statement, rather than being bullied into it by men.
Why do you think they're choosing to do it more since 9/11 Blizz?
FM
Originally Posted by Blizz'ard:
Of course it should be removed for passport checks, when teaching kids etc., but I would hate to see any type of clothing banned in this country. Would you ban sun glasses, as it restricts eye contact? Or covering your face with scarves, in cold weather?

What I have noticed, is that more and more Muslim women are choosing to cover themselves and it seems to coincide with the rise in Islamophobia, since 9/11. I think, in this country, most of them are making a statement, rather than being bullied into it by men.
Well there are some sunglasses that should never have been produced  but I see what you are saying - the facial expression can still be seen & in the instances of scarf wearing - folk are in too much of a hurry to get indoors to be saying hello/goodbye anyhoo!
I just think it a shame that these women for whatever reason feel the need to cover up when in public....
I definitely would not do as the French do & rip one off a person - that is indeed a violation of a persons rights!
slimfern
Yes, ban them. And ban religion too while we're at it. We can do without all the wars, terrorist attacks, hatred between one group of deluded religious clowns and another, corrupt churches with more money than sense who protect their homegrown paedophiles having given them a perfect place to hide and groom children, homophobia in the name of religion, plain, inarguable STUPIDITY in the name of religion, forced marriages, suppressed women, dreadful songs (sorry hymns) warbling on about some ridiculous imaginary deity or other... ban the lot and if any of them don't like it deport the lot of them and make sure they don't come back, job's a good 'un.
Prometheus
Originally Posted by sparkles:
But how is hiding their face more going to make people less against muslims/Islam?    If anything, it is going to turn people against them more, surely??  If they want to be accepted more, because of 'Islamaphobia,' then surely them hiding behind their burkha is going to make things worse, isn't it?
The idea is that we should accept them as they are no matter what they look like! & indeed we should...but therein lies the great shame of them feeling the need or being made to cover up!
slimfern
LOL Velvet  

I do agree slim that I wouldn't rip it off their face, as that is really rude.  My point is that if WE have to stick to laws in this country, then other cultures should stick to the laws too.  By all means, live by your culture, but they have to meet us halfway at least some of the time.

If anyone from the west violates THEIR laws in the east, they go to prison, even something like kissing in public or showing your legs or arms off in public.  So IMO they have no right to violate our laws and do things their way ALL the time.  We give a lot to different cultures over here and are actually pretty soft... many other countries would not allow such leniancy...

Anyway, I have to go now, so don't think I'm being rude if I don't respond to any more posts, I am just having to sign off now.  No disrespect intended to anyone.  And i understand that everyone has different views.  Take care everyone.  See you again soon 
FM
Originally Posted by slimfern:
Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
I wud ban anything that deems woman/man to being a possession/2nd class citizen!

Face to face contact is very important in human communication
They don't though. Wearing the burka is not a must, women decided for themselves. I'm sure that there are some husbands who insist, but there are a lot of husbands in this country and all over the world who beat their wives on a regular basis.
And I would ban them too - to some floating island that never saw other land ! with wild animals & a Dr of human genetics who likes to experiment  

As for the wanting to wear the burka - I believe it is because of indoctrination of thought not out of free will at all.
We're all indocrtinated in our childhood, it's how we deal with it when we get older. We can't just deny some people their religion. I happen to be an agnostic, but I can't blame my parents for trying to educate me into their religion. It's natural. We live in a diverse society, so we have to get used to seeing things we haven't be used to before. The burka doesn't actually stop eye contact, does it. The only time  I would advise to take it off would be in a bank or on leaving the country and, after listening to a rather protracted discussion about this a few months ago, all the women concerned said that they would not be adverse to taking the burka off for those reason.
I guess this is where we differ, as my parents never christened me or my siblings as they decided we were to make up our own minds when we had learnt more & growing up moving around the world I have chosen not to conform to any as I see good & bad in all of them- mostly bad in alot unfortunately!
Did folk not look you in the eye & say Good morning to you when you were growing up cos they did me & still do - I like that but when living up in Birmingham for the best part of last year I found it very hard to even make eye contact with women who were covered up let alone pass the time of day with them...I find that rather sad!
Sorry slim,but I don't get your point at all. Yes people look(ed) me in the eye, in fact in those days, blokes would still take their hats off to a woman (that's a whole different discussion ) It might not make for immediate community spirit, but if you want it, you could start a tea/coffee hour when most of the kids are in school and see how that would go down. If you met them for a few weeks, you'd probably be able to tell them what you thought of their attire and they'd tell you why they wear it.
cologne 1
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Yes, ban them. And ban religion too while we're at it. We can do without all the wars, terrorist attacks, hatred between one group of deluded religious clowns and another, corrupt churches with more money than sense who protect their homegrown paedophiles having given them a perfect place to hide and groom children, homophobia in the name of religion, plain, inarguable STUPIDITY in the name of religion, forced marriages, suppressed women, dreadful songs (sorry hymns) warbling on about some ridiculous imaginary deity or other... ban the lot and if any of them don't like it deport the lot of them and make sure they don't come back, job's a good 'un.

And so sayeth Mr PC!
Evening Promiscuous one
slimfern
Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
I wud ban anything that deems woman/man to being a possession/2nd class citizen!

Face to face contact is very important in human communication
They don't though. Wearing the burka is not a must, women decided for themselves. I'm sure that there are some husbands who insist, but there are a lot of husbands in this country and all over the world who beat their wives on a regular basis.
And I would ban them too - to some floating island that never saw other land ! with wild animals & a Dr of human genetics who likes to experiment  

As for the wanting to wear the burka - I believe it is because of indoctrination of thought not out of free will at all.
We're all indocrtinated in our childhood, it's how we deal with it when we get older. We can't just deny some people their religion. I happen to be an agnostic, but I can't blame my parents for trying to educate me into their religion. It's natural. We live in a diverse society, so we have to get used to seeing things we haven't be used to before. The burka doesn't actually stop eye contact, does it. The only time  I would advise to take it off would be in a bank or on leaving the country and, after listening to a rather protracted discussion about this a few months ago, all the women concerned said that they would not be adverse to taking the burka off for those reason.
I guess this is where we differ, as my parents never christened me or my siblings as they decided we were to make up our own minds when we had learnt more & growing up moving around the world I have chosen not to conform to any as I see good & bad in all of them- mostly bad in alot unfortunately!
Did folk not look you in the eye & say Good morning to you when you were growing up cos they did me & still do - I like that but when living up in Birmingham for the best part of last year I found it very hard to even make eye contact with women who were covered up let alone pass the time of day with them...I find that rather sad!
Sorry slim,but I don't get your point at all. Yes people look(ed) me in the eye, in fact in those days, blokes would still take their hats off to a woman (that's a whole different discussion ) It might not make for immediate community spirit, but if you want it, you could start a tea/coffee hour when most of the kids are in school and see how that would go down. If you met them for a few weeks, you'd probably be able to tell them what you thought of their attire and they'd tell you why they wear it.
My youngest is 18 & I have never drank coffee let alone done mornings of it 
My point is if the wearing of this garment is not enforced then I see it as an ignorance to the needs of other humans - we need to see faces !
slimfern
Originally Posted by sparkles:
 If anyone from the west violates THEIR laws in the east, they go to prison, even something like kissing in public or showing your legs or arms off in public.  So IMO they have no right to violate our laws and do things their way ALL the time. 
Sorry I've arrived pretty late and can't be arsed ploughing through. Are you saying that they are breaking the law by covering their faces?
Garage Joe
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Yes, ban them. And ban religion too while we're at it. We can do without all the wars, terrorist attacks, hatred between one group of deluded religious clowns and another, corrupt churches with more money than sense who protect their homegrown paedophiles having given them a perfect place to hide and groom children, homophobia in the name of religion, plain, inarguable STUPIDITY in the name of religion, forced marriages, suppressed women, dreadful songs (sorry hymns) warbling on about some ridiculous imaginary deity or other... ban the lot and if any of them don't like it deport the lot of them and make sure they don't come back, job's a good 'un.
So, we're just left with wars about each other's land. You're right mind, it would take away a huge excuse.
cologne 1
I don't like seeing them at all although there are days when I think it would be a godsend to wear one
I don't know really about banning them though. I think people have the right to wear what they like provided it causes no harm. I would agree that there are probably quite a few women forced to wear them by male relatives and their communities and so banning them would solve that problem but I feel really uneasy about the state intervening in someones personal choice of clothing.
That being said I don't think that anyone should be able to refuse to take them off for the purposes of easy identification such as passport control and exams etc
FM
Originally Posted by slimfern:
My youngest is 18 & I have never drank coffee let alone done mornings of it 
My point is if the wearing of this garment is not enforced then I see it as an ignorance to the needs of other humans - we need to see faces !
But that's just our western outlook slim. what does it matter in the scheme of things. Find out about the individual and I reckon give it a month or two and you wouldn't give a fig what they wear.
cologne 1
Originally Posted by Veggieburger:
I don't like seeing them at all although there are days when I think it would be a godsend to wear one
I don't know really about banning them though. I think people have the right to wear what they like provided it causes no harm. I would agree that there are probably quite a few women forced to wear them by male relatives and their communities and so banning them would solve that problem but I feel really uneasy about the state intervening in someones personal choice of clothing.
That being said I don't think that anyone should be able to refuse to take them off for the purposes of easy identification such as passport control and exams etc
Veggie, in the radio programme I listened to the discussion (probably 5), all the women said they were not forced into wearing the burkas by their spouses, but wanted to wear them because of their religion. One of them was a teacher and said she does not wear it during school hours, none of them would wear it going into a bank or through custom. In the last few weeks, I've been very taken aback about how many women in egypt, Tunesia and Libya are prepared to talk to western stations, risking their lives to tell what's going on and it makes me believe even more that the burka is a personal choice, not forced and put upon.
cologne 1
Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
My youngest is 18 & I have never drank coffee let alone done mornings of it 
My point is if the wearing of this garment is not enforced then I see it as an ignorance to the needs of other humans - we need to see faces !
But that's just our western outlook slim. what does it matter in the scheme of things. Find out about the individual and I reckon give it a month or two and you wouldn't give a fig what they wear.
See this is just my point - not seeing my face you can't see my expression of exasperation- I don't give a jot what a person wears - but this garment is a barrier, which I think is a great shame!
Anyways it is Friday nite & I have a date with Mr Smirnoff so if you don't mind am gonna vacate this thread & maybe have a lil fun elsewhere
slimfern
Originally Posted by slimfern:
Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
My youngest is 18 & I have never drank coffee let alone done mornings of it 
My point is if the wearing of this garment is not enforced then I see it as an ignorance to the needs of other humans - we need to see faces !
But that's just our western outlook slim. what does it matter in the scheme of things. Find out about the individual and I reckon give it a month or two and you wouldn't give a fig what they wear.
See this is just my point - not seeing my face you can't see my expression of exasperation- I don't give a jot what a person wears - but this garment is a barrier, which I think is a great shame!
Anyways it is Friday nite & I have a date with Mr Smirnoff so if you don't mind am gonna vacate this thread & maybe have a lil fun elsewhere
I'll await the hangovers (yours and mine).
cologne 1
Originally Posted by Veggieburger:
Good points Cologne but surely the women who are forced to wear it are the ones who are extremely unlikely to have the freedom to say so!!
I'm sure there are women who are happy to wear it though, like I said I would be glad of it on some days when I have to go out but don't want to be seen
I completely agree veggie, but I go back to what I said to slim, there are many, many women in this country who are told by their partners what to do and feel their fist when they don't. It's no different. I'm convinced that the muslims who follow the Koran they way it's meant to be treasure women and their children, family and community.
cologne 1
To be honest I've seen very few women wearing it but the ones I have seen look intimidating. It doesn't mean I want them to stop wearing it but none the less it is intimidating seeing someone covered from head to toe and you can't make eye contact. It has no place in schools etc though. The story a while ago about a teacher being forced to take it off IMO is right. If someone is teaching kids it's not only about words. It's about eye contact and facial expressions
Cagney
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
 have you seen what it does to the work surface! 

Straight from the jar on to the plate with the rest of the salad  You're supposed to eat it not build little houses out of it or whatever you were doing 
 Not houses! -  towers 

You tellin me you have never dripped 
slimfern
Originally Posted by slimfern:
Originally Posted by Prometheus:
Originally Posted by slimfern:
 have you seen what it does to the work surface! 

Straight from the jar on to the plate with the rest of the salad  You're supposed to eat it not build little houses out of it or whatever you were doing 
 Not houses! -  towers 

You tellin me you have never dripped 

The transfer of vital salad ingredients is not to be taken lightly. Utmost care young slim, utmost care that's what's required 
Prometheus

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×