- Share on Facebook
- Share on Twitter
- Share on Pinterest
- Share on LinkedIn
- Share on Reddit
- Copy Link to Topic
Replies sorted oldest to newest
Its lovely and very moving isn't it Sprout
I know some people who have bought a poppy, what a very special & unique item to own
Why are we celebrating THE START of WWI. Shouldn't the centenary be in 2018, the centenary of the END of WWI?
Poppies had no particular significance in 1914.
Why are we celebrating THE START of WWI. Shouldn't the centenary be in 2018, the centenary of the END of WWI?
Poppies had no particular significance in 1914.
We're not celebrating......commemorating ?
Why are we celebrating THE START of WWI. Shouldn't the centenary be in 2018, the centenary of the END of WWI?
Poppies had no particular significance in 1914.
Maybe they didn't in 1914.....it's what those people gave for us since then
Well, much of it is coming across as more of a celebration to me. And why was there no commemoration on 28th July? That's when WWI started - officially.
Well, much of it is coming across as more of a celebration to me. And why was there no commemoration on 28th July? That's when WWI started - officially.
Think there was Fluffy - people lit a candle and there was a service on tv?
Its more a remembrance I think.
Know what you mean though, it looks like an art installation. Think its good to have a focal point maybe?
Well, much of it is coming across as more of a celebration to me. And why was there no commemoration on 28th July? That's when WWI started - officially.
Celebration to me is flags and banners unfurled....this is 'muted' I think. Therefore time to think about what everyone gave in their life for us
I like This Week.
It's random.
Why are we celebrating THE START of WWI. Shouldn't the centenary be in 2018, the centenary of the END of WWI?
Poppies had no particular significance in 1914.
Fluffs, just wondering if you ever connect with the emotional rather than the literal and having to be 'right' about the 'facts'?
I don't imagine that you have any idea how insensitive some of your comments are : this is one of many!
Well, much of it is coming across as more of a celebration to me. And why was there no commemoration on 28th July? That's when WWI started - officially.
Celebration to me is flags and banners unfurled....this is 'muted' I think. Therefore time to think about what everyone gave in their life for us
I agree wth you, Sprout. To me, this is about remembering, with sadness and gratitude, all those who gave their lives so that we could live in freedom.
I can see what Fluffy's getting at... it could be seen as a bit gimmicky and disconnected from the actual history of it? That's what I thought too when I first saw the ceramic poppies. Its beautiful so looks like a celebration.
In contrast, there's an artwork / monument to the Irish Famine in Dublin which is harrowing to look at and instantly reminds the onlooker of the horrors.
Think the ceramic poppies will be sold for charity though, so that's something?
Why are we celebrating THE START of WWI. Shouldn't the centenary be in 2018, the centenary of the END of WWI?
Poppies had no particular significance in 1914.
Fluffs, just wondering if you ever connect with the emotional rather than the literal and having to be 'right' about the 'facts'?
I don't imagine that you have any idea how insensitive some of your comments are : this is one of many!
That's not fair Supes I haven't noticed that about Fluffy.
And stop being a grumpy pants!
*runs*