Originally Posted by Yogi19:
I agree with a lot of what you've said but I'm not sure he can get a grip on himself. Whenever he has to relive what happened, he falls to pieces - and I think it is genuine. Whatever happened that night, I think he is struggling to cope with what he did to Reeva.
I believe he is guilty of culpable homicide, because discharging four bullets means he meant to kill whoever he thought was in the toilet, but I have not been convinced that he is guilty of the premeditated murder of Reeva.
I do think he lied about shooting the gun through the sun roof of the car but I actually believed his version of events in the restaurant.
The more I have heard of his heightened perception of crime, the more I think that his version could be true and that he freaked out, and believing Reeva was still in bed, shot at who he thought was a burglar.
For the record, Mr Yogi thinks he is as guilty as sin, but predicts Oscar won't be convicted of premeditated murder. He suggested I might be gullible (but said he meant it in a nice way). However, I pointed out that I am a much better judge of character in RL than he is.
I am not following this as closely as you lot and just pop in each day to read all your comments.. but from what I have seen on the news my feeling is that the BIB is more to do with him struggling to come to terms with how what he did to Reeva is now affecting his life .. all I get is poor me poor me from anything I see about this..
I don't think he planned to murder her before that night ..I do think they had a row and he killed her in anger tho.. which is kinda premeditated if you reach for a gun in an argument
Still got loads to catch up on the thread just saw this bit and I thought nah he's all about himself and is only sorry he killed Reeva cos of his current predicament..