Skip to main content

Originally Posted by Pengy:
<small class="time"> 23s</small>

Masipa: Dr Vorster may have had very little time to compile her report. (True) Cannot replace proper report

 

she's deffo gonna grant it 

 

I'm surprised at her wording...she's more or less ignored Dr Vorster report, if she hadn't granted it I don't doubt she would have totally ignored it as not being a safe diagnosis after two sessions  

Dame_Ann_Average
Originally Posted by Dame_Ann_Average:

 

 

just had a phone call...youngest grandson is coming round, he's been sent home from school with chicken pox  I have got him all morning....he wants him to be an outpatient 

awww poor thing 

 

 

OP is getting special treatment cos he's gonna be treated via OPD rather than as an inmate 

FM

Today's trial

The chief prosecutor in the murder trial of Oscar Pistorius has asked for the Paralympian to be placed under psychiatric evaluation after an expert witness testified that he had an anxiety disorder.

Gerrie Nel noted that a psychiatrist for the defence had testified that the disorder she diagnosed in Pistorius may have played a role in his fatal shooting of his girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp at his home on Valentine's Day last year. Nel acknowledged that an evaluation of Pistorius's state of mind at a government facility could mean the trial, which began on 3 March, would be delayed.

Judge Thokozile Masipa ordered an adjournment and said she would rule on Nel's request on Wednesday morning.

Nel questioned why the defence had decided to ask Dr Merryll Vorster to testify. He suggested that the trial was not going well for Pistorius, and that his lawyers were floating the idea that a disorder contributed to Steenkamp's shooting to suggest that the athlete bore less responsibility for her death.

Pistorius says he mistook Steenkamp for an intruder when he shot her through the closed door of a toilet cubicle. Prosecutors say he killed her in anger after an argument.

In asking for further evaluation of Pistorius's mental state, Nel appeared to be trying to ward off any attempt by the defence to argue that he should be treated favourably by the court because of a disorder linked to his disability.

Pistorius's chief lawyer, Barry Roux, said at the start of his defence that the double-amputee's vulnerability and disability lay at the centre of his case. He said Pistorius should not be sent for a 30-day psychiatric evaluation and that he wanted to call another witness to continue testimony.

Vorster met Pistorius this month, prompting Nel to question whether the timing of her late appearance as a defence witness signified a change in tactics.

 

FM
Last edited by Former Member

Does this mean there will be no action in this thread for a while. I've enjoyed catching up with the trial with a  mid morning cuppa following the trial and you lot too. .what will I read instead

 

I had to Google GAD as didn't have a clue what it was. . turns out it is the actual name for what I have suffered with for the past 20 yrs or more and is a daily constant in my life with added agoraphobia on top . .  You learn something new everyday. .never knew what to call what I had before other than a garbled explanation, and now I know..

 

Can't see that OP has anything like what I have, after having read the description of the illness and its effects..  he seems to be able to function normally especially socialise and travel and have relationships etc  but, if he does have it I cannot fathom what that has to do with the case anyway,  I am not about to, nor have I ever wanted to, run around and shoot people no matter how anxious I have felt ..  

 

 

Mount Olympus *Olly*
Last edited by Mount Olympus *Olly*
Originally Posted by Mount Olympus *Olly*:

Does this mean there will be no action in this thread for a while. I've enjoyed catching up with the trial with a  mid morning cuppa following the trial and you lot too. .what will I read instead

 

we can come in daily and pretend to be OP - might get Dame to draw the animation that never was.  Frank Moonie can keep cleaning and bringing breakfast, Aimee can keep breaking things, I'll pretend to be a member of SAPS and nick stuff and you have to guess what item I've taken and how  

 

, if he does have it I cannot fathom what that has to do with the case anyway,  I am not about to, nor have I ever wanted to, run around and shoot people no matter how anxious I have felt ..  

 

 

I would put my house, sorry mah hause on it that he doesn't have this condition and that's why Roux didn't want him evaluated.  If he'd been institutionalised, there is no way in hell he could have kept it up for 30 days. Now we know he's being evaluated as an outpatient I'm not so sure as he can prepare for it but I live in hope that the professionals will see through it 

FM
Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by Pengy:
Originally Posted by moonie:

*switches my alarms off*

get back here Frank Moonie I still want brekkie and tea and bikkits every day 

 

 

anyone would think I wasn't paying you 

Hmmm well the way I am sleeping at present you may have your brekkie at 5-30

Paying, did you say paying? *sets about making bills out*

Moonie
Originally Posted by Pengy:
 

I would put my house, sorry mah hause on it that he doesn't have this condition and that's why Roux didn't want him evaluated.  If he'd been institutionalised, there is no way in hell he could have kept it up for 30 days. Now we know he's being evaluated as an outpatient I'm not so sure as he can prepare for it but I live in hope that the professionals will see through it 

Yup I agree with you. If you have this disorder you cna hold it together for short periods of time . .if he is being evaluated for it he needs to be looked at on an ongoing basis and also observed in the company of others, strangers in particular. One of the main features of the disease is normal feelings are escalated so general nervousness with strangers becomes a huge deal and increases anxiety etc.. 

 

Sound to me like they are just going to go thru a check list of Psych Q&A's asking things like how do you feel if xyz happens instead of seeing how he reacts during and after xyz happens. . He'll be coached on the correct answers to give to a question type evaluation no doubt. Also probably coached in a way to get whatever result the defence wants from it

 

LOL at your suggested attempts to keep the thread going during down time at court

Mount Olympus *Olly*
Originally Posted by moonie:
Originally Posted by Pengy:
Originally Posted by moonie:

*switches my alarms off*

get back here Frank Moonie I still want brekkie and tea and bikkits every day 

 

 

anyone would think I wasn't paying you 

Hmmm well the way I am sleeping at present you may have your brekkie at 5-30

Paying, did you say paying? *sets about making bills out*

you get bed and board and a few Rand to send home [#workfare] what more do you want 

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×