Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by Jenstar:

It was the big good bye speech from Matt Smith that i didn't like EC, the whole old Bloke Doctor in the bell tower was better and should have been where Peter was first seen!

 

Yes, the bell tower would have been a more logical place for me given all the mouthing off at the Daleks he did there and that is also where the fairy dust hit him.

 

But recent Doctors all seem to want to do some protracted speech now - it's a bit overdone for me. I would like just one of them to go "see ya" and change.

Enthusiastic Contrafibularities
Originally Posted by moonie:
Originally Posted by Jenstar:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

what can I say... I must be easily pleased

 

'Kidneys!'     I love him already.

I think he will make a great Doctor Who Kaffy I was just a miffed at all the farewell stuff from Matt

David Tennant is still my fave of them all

 

Pertwee or Baker for me. Baker shades it.

 

Tennant was a much better Doctor than Smith and he took his name from Neil Tennant of the Pet Shop Boys - so another plus point 

 

Enthusiastic Contrafibularities
Originally Posted by Enthusiastic Contrafibularities:
Originally Posted by moonie:
Originally Posted by Jenstar:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

what can I say... I must be easily pleased

 

'Kidneys!'     I love him already.

I think he will make a great Doctor Who Kaffy I was just a miffed at all the farewell stuff from Matt

David Tennant is still my fave of them all

 

Pertwee or Baker for me. Baker shades it.

 

Tennant was a much better Doctor than Smith and he took his name from Neil Tennant of the Pet Shop Boys - so another plus point 

 

I don't believe that.. he's Scottish, he must have taken it from the lager...

Kaffs
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Enthusiastic Contrafibularities:
Originally Posted by moonie:
Originally Posted by Jenstar:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

what can I say... I must be easily pleased

 

'Kidneys!'     I love him already.

I think he will make a great Doctor Who Kaffy I was just a miffed at all the farewell stuff from Matt

David Tennant is still my fave of them all

 

Pertwee or Baker for me. Baker shades it.

 

Tennant was a much better Doctor than Smith and he took his name from Neil Tennant of the Pet Shop Boys - so another plus point 

 

I don't believe that.. he's Scottish, he must have taken it from the lager...

 

I actually heard it today in a quiz!

 

Just looked it up.

 

taking his stage name from the Pet Shop Boys frontman Neil Tennant after reading a copy of Smash Hits magazine because there was another David McDonald already on the books of the Equity union. Tennant has stated that he later had to legally change his name to Tennant in order to meet Screen Actors Guild rules.

 

 

 

Enthusiastic Contrafibularities
Last edited by Enthusiastic Contrafibularities
Originally Posted by Enthusiastic Contrafibularities:
Originally Posted by Jenstar:

I only just got round to watching it a little while ago and i thought it was really good.... up  until the last 3 mins or so! The whole bit back in the Tardis at the end was rubbish imo

 

I felt a bit let down. I expected something all together more impressive, not a head shake and that's yer lot!

 

 

But his big regeneration was from old to young again...that would have used up a lot of it then, aaaatchooooo, one big sneeze and it's 'Helloooooooo, Mr Capaldi'!! It was a nice change, I thought!

Izzy Gonyett
Originally Posted by Enthusiastic Contrafibularities:
Originally Posted by Jenstar:

It was the big good bye speech from Matt Smith that i didn't like EC, the whole old Bloke Doctor in the bell tower was better and should have been where Peter was first seen!

 

Yes, the bell tower would have been a more logical place for me given all the mouthing off at the Daleks he did there and that is also where the fairy dust hit him.

 

But recent Doctors all seem to want to do some protracted speech now - it's a bit overdone for me. I would like just one of them to go "see ya" and change.

 

I am probably wrong as I am sure that some of the Classic regens were outside, but do they have to be in the TARDIS to regen?? In the one where Ten-inch does the hand thingy, Capt Jack says that they have to get him to the TARDIS...or was that justan easy way to write the hand in??!!

 

I have confused myself now!!!

Izzy Gonyett
Originally Posted by Jenstar:

I know why the actors do it but the actual doctor isn't going anywhere so for him to say an emotional good bye just doesn't make sense it should be more of a "Oh hang i'll brb"

 

I liked Matt's farewell more than Ten-inches as his was more of a 'thank you'  to the viewers than Ten-inches 'I don't want to go' which seemed a bit 'poor me' to me...Matt's was more positive and meant that Peter Capaldi is not the nasty person who stole Matt's job like Matt was with the Ten-inch fans....hope that makes sense!!!!

Izzy Gonyett
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

what can I say... I must be easily pleased

 

'Kidneys!'     I love him already.

 

Me too!! I was excited about him before the regen, he will be fabulous!! Also, he will make losing Matt a bit easier to handle. Matt was born to be The Doctor, it seems to be in his bones and Peter is a life long fan who will only want the best for the show...what could be better??!!

Izzy Gonyett
Originally Posted by Izzy Gonyett:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

what can I say... I must be easily pleased

 

'Kidneys!'     I love him already.

 

Me too!! I was excited about him before the regen, he will be fabulous!! Also, he will make losing Matt a bit easier to handle. Matt was born to be The Doctor, it seems to be in his bones and Peter is a life long fan who will only want the best for the show...what could be better??!!

I've lost the cast list for the MM, so I don't know who I'm talking to, but, I was the same.. the only problem I had with the long regen scene was my impatience!    I was really looking forward to his first appearance and I loved his first line  - wasn't disappointed, I think he's going to be as great as we expect.

Kaffs

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×