i always wanted too be a cop  i do usually get these things right 

I agree with you, Aims. I've been telling Mr Yogi it was Zak, for days.

i've always thought it was moira (or amy and possibly zak) , but in dancingon ice they are saying "EX emmerdale actor matthew"  aka david, soooooo i think i'll add david to the list (there are valid reasons for it being him - protective of amy/pollard etc)

Didn't know he had left Emmerdale 

they kept it very quiet aimee which increases my suspicions

ummm *rubs chin* 

hmmmmm *joins Aimes in the chin rubbing*

Ooo David - hadn't even considered him

Ooo - that soon - thank goodness, I hate waiting for aaages

I hadn't even thought of David, can see the motive but he's not the type

do we ever know the type?

he did help amy and he was angry, and if he thought his dad was in danger too?

guilty!

(don't need to bother with a trial and jury)

Only 2 more night til we know ( i really hope im right about that now!)

I am beginning to wonder if it was Belle, she was very angry the baby went into care. it wouldnt take much to belt him with a spanner, and i get the feeling Cain is protecting someone. i could be well off track of course!

See thats what i was thinking Skylark but now i'm not too sure.

Yes i was trying to remember who said Belle ! Didnt see tonights episode , were there anymore clues?

or perhaps he is hoping to blackmail them???  which would make sense re david because of pollards money - but then it also applies to moira, but not for money 

roll on thursday when hopefully i will have my tv back!

I think it's Zack

Good to see you back, hope all is well with you.

Just been reading in the TV mag that Cain tells Charity who did it  i think if it was David he wouldn't be covering up for him, so i'm still going for Zak 

usually baddies get their  "comeuppance"  but i don't see how they can get around this - cain will want his revenge but it would split the family completely and aaron would definitely go off the rails, so is cain off loading any potential  guilt onto charity?  is he winding her up? is zak too obvious along with charity and jai?  what came first the chicken or the egg?

too many questions and not enough answers!!!

Oh hello

Hmmmm, that just looks a bit too obvious though ...

I liked Jai in tonights eppy!

no tv yet - sat dish still hanging from the wall!

Me too

oh dear machel hope it gets fixed soon

*two pages later*

What did Mikhil do?

Erm.... I mean Nikhil

Well, we don't know do we? That is the point of this thread. I mean ... he might have whacked Cain over the head which resulted in him going to hospital, or he might just have been sat at home at the time having a nice cup of tea.

Mind you, June from The Bill was probably at home making the tea - so I bet that Rikhil would prefer it if it was him that did it

Clear now?

We're not sure who it was yet. Rexi thinks it was Nikhil and Aimee's sure it was Zak.

Is June still in the Bill?

Yeah much clearer thanks Rexi

*wonders if an Emmerdale dictionary would help*

Nah the police station was closed down so she went back in time, married and had 3 kids 30 something years ago and moved to yorkshire

See, that's brilliant Jen ... Ducky must surely understand now

Hang about........ you just called him Rikhil!

Are you purposely trying to confooose me?

Me not being confusing?!? Now that's a first!

Ha. You noticed. You are secretly really interested as to whether he did it or not aren't you?

Ok, I admit it.  I'm dying to know if he used Tetley teabags or Typhoo

Pfft - *whispers* she spends all day talking logarithms and algebra ... it's about time someone confused her

Didn't you read Jen's post up there? It was Yorkshire.

I sometimes wonder why we bother ...

Uh ok were you just talking a different language in the first half of that post?