Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I thought that was splendid.
Beautifully directed and acted and written (by the Billy Elliot man)
Everything seemed to be pitched just right.
You could almost touch Nigel's growing and flourishing interest in food as it fascinated him more and more.
To retain a sense of self through all the strains of those relationships must have been arduous.
And the lovely, slightly floundering first kiss.
Then the glorious sense of optimism and hope.
I loved it.  It left me with a really nice feeling.
brisket
Nigel Slater has revealed that the sex scenes in the BBC adaptation of his autobiography Toast will be "subtle".

The writer admitted on the BBC TV blog that he was initially unsure how the sexual elements of the book would be portrayed.

"The sexual element... was an integral part of the book and I was concerned how it would translate onto the screen," he explained. "The film touches on the sexual thread of the book, but in a more subtle way. This may disappoint a few readers who are hoping for a visual romp through the book's more colourful and varied sex scenes, but it makes it easier viewing."

Slater added that the adaptation maintains the book's combination of humour and darker drama.

"As soon as I read the first draft, I relaxed a little," he said. "[Writer] Lee [Hall] had captured not just the initial sadness of a story of a little boy who loses his mother at Christmas, but had captured the humour of the book too."

He continued: "I felt an immediate bond with the director SJ Clarkson too. We shared a vision for the film [and] neither of us wanted it to end up as a grey and gritty drama."

Toast airs tonight at 9pm on BBC One
FM
I found this difficult to watch despite the amazing production and breathtaking attention to detail. Helena Bonham Carter was fabulous and the rest of the cast were very good too. Loved the music. Was reminded just how fab Dusty Springfield was. 

I found the content difficult to watch. The isolation that the boy felt was relentless. For me the joy he found in food was just another disturbing aspect of the story. It all felt cold and soul-less and sad....utterly joyless.

I can't quite put my finger on why exactly why I found Toast so disturbing. Perhaps it was the very real depiction of an unhappy and aggressive parent. I grew up in with someone who was deeply unhappy, aggressive and impossible to please. Perhaps it took me back a little too much. 

A line from the father sums it up for me... Enough is enough!. Enough fighting, enough food ... this is miserable.  

 
Green&Pink
G&P - nice post. I suppose  the empathy you feel reflects creditably on the production which conveyed so well the emotional impact of living with such a person.
Interesting that you were impressed by the attention to detail, because I have just read the TV critic in The Guardian who gave high praise to the art director.
I loved it as I watched it last night, and on reflection I admire it even more. I thought it was smashing.
brisket
Reference:Brisket
I suppose  the empathy you feel reflects creditably on the production which conveyed so well the emotional impact of living with such a person. Interesting that you were impressed by the attention to detail, because I have just read the TV critic in The Guardian who gave high praise to the art director. I loved it as I watched it last night, and on reflection I admire it even more. I thought it was smashing.


Yes brisket, it was a bit too close to home for me perhaps. Ken Stott played the dad brilliantly. 

The detail was phenomenal... the little duffel bag nigel had in primary school... my brother and I had one exactly the same!!  The colours of the clothes and interiors... you don't get those shades of green and brown now... Just shows you how powerful a a well made drama can be....not always comfortable but powerful nonetheless.
Green&Pink
Reference:
I am from Wolverhampton so the accent made me feel right at home
Funnily enough her accent was the one thing in this production that I didn't like because I felt she'd done the 'generic West Midlands accent' which for some reason everyone seems to think should be Brummie   I thought the accent was more Brummie than Wolverhampton 


Having said that - she was superb in the role and I thoroughly enjoyed it and as has been said a nice touch having him there at the end 
FM
Aimee - my guess is that whether you like the present-day Nigel Slater or not,  this play could be enjoyed on its own merits.
I thought it was a lovely production - writing, directing, acting, art direction and costumes, lighting, editing.  A good piece of work I thought.
Of course you may not agree, but I think it's worth giving it a try. 
brisket
Reference:
Funnily enough her accent was the one thing in this production that I didn't like because I felt she'd done the 'generic West Midlands accent' which for some reason everyone seems to think should be Brummie   I thought the accent was more Brummie than Wolverhampton

The trouble with a Wolverhampton accent is that it can vary drastically from one end of the street to the other. My husband was born just around the corner from me and his accent is completely different to mine. Helena gave it a good stab but some of the other actors got it spot on.
I also loved the fact that a lot of the early scenes were filmed at The Black Country Museum I think that's what made the early scenes so authentic.
longcat
Reference:
I also loved the fact that a lot of the early scenes were filmed at The Black Country Museum I think that's what made the early scenes so authentic.
I absolutely love the Black Country Museum 



@ Aimee I totally agree with what Croc said - this stands up a really good drama irrespective of whether you like Nigel or not 

The scene that had me wetting my knickers is when Mrs Potter was scrubbing the floor and Mr Slater Snr was looking down from the stairs at her as it looked like she was humping the floor
FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×