I find it strange that in this day and age some say the girls dress like tarts etc. In another situation if a girl friend/sister was attacked or raped and she happened to like wearing short skirts etc would you as a friend/relative say she didn't deserve that just because of her choice of clothes? or would you tell her she deserved it because of how she dressed. That scenario is at times played out in Courts where judgements can be made by how the girl/woman dresses.
I watched this programme last year and because I was interested in the culture I'm watching the present one. There isn't any culture that's perfect, good and bad everywhere, I think the positive's of their culture is that young girls don't sleep around and get drunk which is what happens in other cultures, particularly in the uk.
quote:It makes you wonder if the girls are not aware of the way they dress because of the way they are brought up.If that makes sense?
They must just not associate skimpy clothes with the same things we do... they dress that way cos everyone else in their community does and it's the norm. As they all know there is no sex before marriage (girls and boys) then its not seen as an invitation of any sort
quote:In another situation if a girl friend/sister was attacked or raped and she happened to like wearing short skirts etc would you as a friend/relative say she didn't deserve that just because of her choice of clothes? or would you tell her she deserved it because of how she dressed. That scenario is at times played out in Courts where judgements can be made by how the girl/woman dresses.
No one deserves to be raped.
Nail on head Saz.
I know what you mean Longcat and Saz's post imo is spot on in relation to it....Another point may be given smoking and drinking are not permitted they take advantage of the fact their choice of clothing isn't restricted ,who knows.
quote:Nail on head Saz.
quote:The no sex before marriage thong is probably why they all get married so young.
Thats what I thought too!
I used to go up and hang out round their swimming pool with the two sons when my daughter was a baby. Their Mum used to come tottering out... gin in hand.. wanting to take my daughter for a walk in her pushchair (I used to let her... on the condition that the pitbull didn't go with them)...
Their house was massive, their clothes all designer (yet casual), but the carpets were all threadbare, in amongst the dad's rolls royce there would be 3 or 4 clapped out old cars in the drive... oh & of course the mandatory shabby caravan!
Youngest son was hot though... til he got into body building, got stretch marks & a fat neck... & then stopped doing it and it all went flabby!
Yeah, OK, disaster!
I felt very uncomfortable.. .tho I am sure the kids have no idea how suggestive it looks the Editor of the show isn't of their world yet chose to show loads of footage of that dancing..
and I think the dresses are rank... can't understand why anybody would want to look like they are sat on top of a toilet roll
I agree with Olly on the camera time spent watching the young girls dance and gyrate was uncomfortable as was the scene when the little girl who's communion it was having her spray tan in the nuddy Could just picture my parish priest Fr Maguire's face if we'd have turned up for our first holy communion dressed like that
As for the pink dress that lit up - well at least she tried to accommodate her new life style (personally it was horrendous but that's just my opinion) although I couldn't stop staring at her tangoed mother it's wrong to make personal assertions but she looked as rough as a badgers backside. Having said that the girl, her young sister and her father looked very respectable so I'm probably being unkind here
It wasn't nice for the family having their home destroyed but why do travellers seem to think they have a God given right to park their vans anywhere and that they should be accommodated??? I really do believe that councils need to arrange more sites for them static or otherwise but they should definitely not be on green belt land - brown belt land could be redeveloped and they should pay for the utilities to be fitted properly like everyone else has to
I totally agree because there is a big difference between romany gypsies and travellers
It was their land they just didn't have planning permission.
I heard that Saz but they know when they buy the land that they are not allowed to build on it hence why the do it surreptitiously and install utilities during weekends when they know it's a bank holiday and the council won't be in work for 4 days.
My point (prolly didn't make it clear enough) is that there is lots of brown belt land available that no manufacturing is being built on so couldn't that be redeveloped to accommodate them by the council or let them buy brown belt land and leave the green belt as field - just my opinion though
I think you need planning permission to set up a caravan park.
Just watched this on catch up... What I want to know is where the bloody hell do they get their money from? The wedding that I saw with the ridiculous pink dress all lit up with the butterflies, must have cost fifty grand. And that was just one celebration. And even the communion dresses must have cost a tidy packet too. Everything was so expensive and horridly chavvy, from the naff orange tans to the nasty make up. And I know I sound like a horrid snob - (although I am really not.. I have to say that they are really really common and mouthy and just generally a bunch of chavs.
And do they work? How do they get their money? I know they perhaps don't have massive mortgages because of having caravans, but they seem to spend 10s of 1000s on weddings, parties, confirmations and so on.... so where does it come from?
And this 'she will never be a part of our community no matter how long she lives here,' and 'she will never be accepted' was just a bit weird and scary. These people want to be accepted and be allowed to stay where they want, and yet, they cast everybody out - even people who want to marry into their community. Frankly, I would rather live alone with my dogs for the rest of my life than join a freakshow like that.
And I do agree that to teach girls that the only life for them is to be accepted by a man and taken as his wife is the most they can get out of life, is actually rather sad and tragic. It's basically a cult. Nothing more, nothing less.