I've just got back from Manchester after seeing JC Superstar.
First let me say - I loved the contemporary staging - set amongst urban UK riots etc. It translated very well to modern day. The sound/vocals/music in general was amazing - really enjoyed it. The visual was very disappointing though unfortunately. I feel that if you're going to perform a show in an arena the stage shouldn't be firmly facing the front as in a theatre. Sadly our seats weren't good - we were side on and there was lots of paraphenalia hanging from the ceiling - a large black box obscured our view of where the main protagonists stood to sing most of their stuff. Our view of the big screen was partially obscured by the equipment too. I have no doubt if we'd been seated directly in front of the stage it really would have been visually stunning - sitting on the sides however gave a really distorted view. The cross (which was probably quite spectacular) looked very odd from the angle we were viewing. TBH - I'd rather have seen it in a theatre and compromised on the sound quality.
Tim Minchin as Judas stole the show - he surpassed my expectations 1,000 fold. Simply superb.
Mel C was excellent.
Chris Moyles was great as Judas but .................not exceptional IMO - it's a great song and I think any number of performers could have done it justice.
Ben - well .................... he delivered some of his numbers brilliantly and others were a bit screechy. I know I'm biased but I honestly do believe that either Rory or David would have done better. Ben was IMO a bit wooden. I also thought he lacked charisma - the contemporary setting would have suited Rory's style so much better and let's face it he is very easy on the eye.
It sounds like I didn't really enjoy it but I did. I just think that at ÂĢ52.00 for a ticket our view was pretty poor and I felt a little disconnected. For me the stadium thing didn't really work.
Tim Minchin made it all worthwhile though - he has found a new fan in me.