Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by Rawky-Roo:

My English is getting the better of me, ok so:

 

If I were to talk about a group of friends arriving at my house I could say:

 

"They're here" right?

 

If I were to talk about a load of breadcrumbs on a table I could say:

 

"There're a lot of breadcrumbs on the table"  right?

 

I freaking out about this, it's making me feel proper stupid.

The first one is right

 

The second one should be there's (there is) a lot of breadcrumbs

 

hope that helps

Yellow Rose
Originally Posted by Yellow Rose:
Originally Posted by Rawky-Roo:

My English is getting the better of me, ok so:

 

If I were to talk about a group of friends arriving at my house I could say:

 

"They're here" right?

 

If I were to talk about a load of breadcrumbs on a table I could say:

 

"There're a lot of breadcrumbs on the table"  right?

 

I freaking out about this, it's making me feel proper stupid.

The first one is right

 

The second one should be there's (there is) a lot of breadcrumbs

 

hope that helps

FANKS!!!  I knew the first one was right, but the second one was really rocking my cockles.

Rawky-Roo

'Breadcrumbs' is plural - therefore it is 'There ARE breadcrumbs....' however if you were talking about a Pile of breadcrumbs it would  be 'There IS a pile of breadcrumbs....'

Furthermore if the breadcrumbs were in several small piles then we are back to 'are' - There are (several) piles of breadcrumbs....'

 

It's all to do with whether the main noun is singular or plural.

 

Breadcrumbs - plural....therefore ARE

Pile - singular....therefore IS

Piles - plural....therefore ARE

 

In this Case 'A LOT' is effectively the same as saying 'A PILE' so it should be treated as singular.

 

Thus There IS A LOT of breadcrumbs.

Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing
Last edited by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing
Originally Posted by Yellow Rose:
Originally Posted by Rawky-Roo:

My English is getting the better of me, ok so:

 

If I were to talk about a group of friends arriving at my house I could say:

 

"They're here" right?

 

If I were to talk about a load of breadcrumbs on a table I could say:

 

"There're a lot of breadcrumbs on the table"  right?

 

I freaking out about this, it's making me feel proper stupid.

The first one is right

 

The second one should be there's (there is) a lot of breadcrumbs

 

hope that helps

Or there are........?

Moonie

Re-posts for moonie (who's still not found his specs!)

Originally Posted by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing:
'Breadcrumbs' is plural - therefore it is 'There ARE breadcrumbs....' however if you were talking about a Pile of breadcrumbs it would  be 'There IS a pile of breadcrumbs....'
Furthermore if the breadcrumbs were in several small piles then we are back to 'are' - There are (several) piles of breadcrumbs....'

It's all to do with whether the main noun is singular or plural.

Breadcrumbs - plural....therefore ARE
Pile - singular....therefore IS
Piles - plural....therefore ARE

In this Case 'A LOT' is effectively the same as saying 'A PILE' so it should be treated as singular.

Thus There IS A LOT of breadcrumbs.
Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing
Originally Posted by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing:

Re-posts for moonie (who's still not found his specs!)

Originally Posted by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing:
'Breadcrumbs' is plural - therefore it is 'There ARE breadcrumbs....' however if you were talking about a Pile of breadcrumbs it would  be 'There IS a pile of breadcrumbs....'
Furthermore if the breadcrumbs were in several small piles then we are back to 'are' - There are (several) piles of breadcrumbs....'

It's all to do with whether the main noun is singular or plural.

Breadcrumbs - plural....therefore ARE
Pile - singular....therefore IS
Piles - plural....therefore ARE

In this Case 'A LOT' is effectively the same as saying 'A PILE' so it should be treated as singular.

Thus There IS A LOT of breadcrumbs.

Never said I was good at da Inglish 

Moonie
Originally Posted by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing:

Re-posts for moonie (who's still not found his specs!)

Originally Posted by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing:
'Breadcrumbs' is plural - therefore it is 'There ARE breadcrumbs....' however if you were talking about a Pile of breadcrumbs it would  be 'There IS a pile of breadcrumbs....'
Furthermore if the breadcrumbs were in several small piles then we are back to 'are' - There are (several) piles of breadcrumbs....'

It's all to do with whether the main noun is singular or plural.

Breadcrumbs - plural....therefore ARE
Pile - singular....therefore IS
Piles - plural....therefore ARE

In this Case 'A LOT' is effectively the same as saying 'A PILE' so it should be treated as singular.

Thus There IS A LOT of breadcrumbs.

You missed the S out there ! 

FM
Originally Posted by Slinkiwitch x:
Originally Posted by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing:

Re-posts for moonie (who's still not found his specs!)

Originally Posted by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing:
'Breadcrumbs' is plural - therefore it is 'There ARE breadcrumbs....' however if you were talking about a Pile of breadcrumbs it would  be 'There IS a pile of breadcrumbs....'
Furthermore if the breadcrumbs were in several small piles then we are back to 'are' - There are (several) piles of breadcrumbs....'

It's all to do with whether the main noun is singular or plural.

Breadcrumbs - plural....therefore ARE
Pile - singular....therefore IS
Piles - plural....therefore ARE

In this Case 'A LOT' is effectively the same as saying 'A PILE' so it should be treated as singular.

Thus There IS A LOT of breadcrumbs.

You missed the S out there ! 

....I mean - shock horror!!!

Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×