Skip to main content

quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
Ok Big Grin

The answer is for British English.........



Razzer



Cool



You are all right Big Grin


It is in fact optional. Team seems to be a special case where each use is valid.

In other cases where the noun is acting as one unit it is singular, but if the unit consists of lots of people acting individually then it is plural

e.g.

  • The committee has announced its decision. (The committee is regarded as an impersonal unit.)

  • The committee are divided on this issue. (The committee is regarded as a group of individuals.)

  • The average Indian family has 4.2 members. It is small and richer than 20 years ago.

  • My family have decided to move to Mumbai.



So for instance in the last example all members of the family are deemed to have acted individually even though the collective noun is singular.


You have just copied that from the link, posted in a previous thread.
Heartache
quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
quote:
Originally posted by Supercalifragilistic:
quote:
Originally posted by CaptVimes:
I know when to insert colons Smiler

See that's what I like about you Capt, (flutters eyelashes,) thought my double entende was going to go unnoticed Laugh


I saw it but didn't want to lower the tone! *sniff*
Thats what I am here for Smiler
CaptVimes
quote:
Originally posted by Supercalifragilistic:
quote:
Originally posted by Mount Olympus:
I swear that all reads as gobble-de-gook to me... but thanks for trying Big Grin

**picks up maths books instead.. they make much more sense to me Laugh **

Laugh if you want it right, change your ; for a , or a : for dramatic effect Laugh Wink
**dashes back**

Will do, and thanks again Big Grin
Mount Olympus *Olly*
quote:
Originally posted by Hotpants Helen:
Is it always wrong to split an infinitive?


It is technically possible to split an infinitive in English but it is not in Latin. When the rules clarifying what was emerging as a 'standard' English language were being set (took many hundreds of years from the middle ages right up to the 18th century), the leading authorities on language took Latin as their model and therefore deemed it unacceptable to split an infinitive.

However it has been widely accepted since early in the twentieth century that there is no reason why this should not be perfectly acceptable practice in contemporary English.

There are still some fusty types who prefer to hang on to ancient rules however even when they make no sense.

Right that's it, I'm leaving the thread - I'm on holiday, no more grammar for me! Shake Head
skive
quote:
Originally posted by Mount Olympus:
quote:
Originally posted by greenandpink:
quote:
Originally posted by old hippy guy:
BOTH of mine are dead, one died before I was born, and the other one in 1987, dont know if they were ever lonely though,
Took a while, but.. Laugh Laugh Laugh
I am rubbish at words. I know this is meant to be funny but I can't work out why Red Face

I am the forum dimwit Crying


hehe,grammar, grandma? only makes sense if, like Stokies, grandma, used to/still does, get pronounced, " grommar " I know, LAME, but couldnt resist, I'll get me coat.
old hippy guy
quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
quote:
Originally posted by Supercalifragilistic:
quote:
Originally posted by CaptVimes:
I know when to insert colons Smiler

See that's what I like about you Capt, (flutters eyelashes,) thought my double entendre was going to go unnoticed Laugh


I saw it but didn't want to lower the tone! *sniff*


Does that mean I have to like you too? Wink
FM
quote:
Originally posted by Supercalifragilistic:
quote:
Originally posted by Mount Olympus:
I am never going to get my colon lesson so am offski to cook a spag bol sulk now Razzer

Oi, I did it twice for you Hug look back.....makes note of Olly's id for when I need help with mathematics


That colon should be a semi colon! But you have to make the part before the semi into a full sentence.

e.g. Permanently grumpy and without any rays of sunshine; Zaph or the mods may think otherwise.
Flossie
quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
quote:
Originally posted by Mount Olympus:
quote:
Originally posted by greenandpink:
M O not a dimwit so there!!!.. Hug
awwwww you're too kind. . but in truth I am more a maths person than a words person. Big Grin

right where was I? ah yes, off to do stuff... wavey


Prove the surface area of a cone Big Grin
I shall need infinity and a housemate of my choice. Smiler
CaptVimes
quote:
Originally posted by skive:
quote:
Originally posted by Hotpants Helen:
Is it always wrong to split an infinitive?


It is technically possible to split an infinitive in English but it is not in Latin. When the rules clarifying what was emerging as a 'standard' English language were being set (took many hundreds of years from the middle ages right up to the 18th century), the leading authorities on language took Latin as their model and therefore deemed it unacceptable to split an infinitive.

However it has been widely accepted since early in the twentieth century that there is no reason why this should not be perfectly acceptable practice in contemporary English.

There are still some fusty types who prefer to hang on to ancient rules however even when they make no sense.

Right that's it, I'm leaving the thread - I'm on holiday, no more grammar for me! Shake Head


I agree with all of that.
Flossie
quote:
Originally posted by Supercalifragilistic:
quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
quote:
Originally posted by Supercalifragilistic:
quote:
Originally posted by CaptVimes:
I know when to insert colons Smiler

See that's what I like about you Capt, (flutters eyelashes,) thought my double entendre was going to go unnoticed Laugh


I saw it but didn't want to lower the tone! *sniff*


Does that mean I have to like you too? Wink


Well .......... there are benefits Big Grin
Flossie
quote:
Originally posted by CaptVimes:
quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
quote:
Originally posted by Mount Olympus:
quote:
Originally posted by greenandpink:
M O not a dimwit so there!!!.. Hug
awwwww you're too kind. . but in truth I am more a maths person than a words person. Big Grin

right where was I? ah yes, off to do stuff... wavey


Prove the surface area of a cone Big Grin
I shall need infinity and a housemate of my choice. Smiler


Just one infinity?
Flossie
quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
quote:
Originally posted by skive:
quote:
Originally posted by Hotpants Helen:
Is it always wrong to split an infinitive?


It is technically possible to split an infinitive in English but it is not in Latin. When the rules clarifying what was emerging as a 'standard' English language were being set (took many hundreds of years from the middle ages right up to the 18th century), the leading authorities on language took Latin as their model and therefore deemed it unacceptable to split an infinitive.

However it has been widely accepted since early in the twentieth century that there is no reason why this should not be perfectly acceptable practice in contemporary English.

There are still some fusty types who prefer to hang on to ancient rules however even when they make no sense.

Right that's it, I'm leaving the thread - I'm on holiday, no more grammar for me! Shake Head


I agree with all of that.
lol I have seen threads go over pages and pages arguing it and Skive nailed it totally.
CaptVimes
quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
quote:
Originally posted by CaptVimes:
quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
quote:
Originally posted by Mount Olympus:
quote:
Originally posted by greenandpink:
M O not a dimwit so there!!!.. Hug
awwwww you're too kind. . but in truth I am more a maths person than a words person. Big Grin

right where was I? ah yes, off to do stuff... wavey


Prove the surface area of a cone Big Grin
I shall need infinity and a housemate of my choice. Smiler


Just one infinity?
I am not greedy Razzer
CaptVimes
quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
Ok Big Grin

The answer is for British English.........



Razzer



Cool



You are all right Big Grin


It is in fact optional. Team seems to be a special case where each use is valid.

In other cases where the noun is acting as one unit it is singular, but if the unit consists of lots of people acting individually then it is plural

e.g.

  • The committee has announced its decision. (The committee is regarded as an impersonal unit.)

  • The committee are divided on this issue. (The committee is regarded as a group of individuals.)

  • The average Indian family has 4.2 members. It is small and richer than 20 years ago.

  • My family have decided to move to Mumbai.



So for instance in the last example all members of the family are deemed to have acted individually even though the collective noun is singular.


So, basically, one uses 'are' if one could comfortably insert members? Glance
Blizz'ard
quote:
Originally posted by Flossie:
That colon should be a semi colon! But you have to make the part before the semi into a full sentence.

e.g. Permanently grumpy and without any rays of sunshine; Zaph or the mods may think otherwise.

it was a semi colon but I just changed it.. Big Grin

that new version is too long for one line and doesn't sound like me, it's too correct, if there can be a too correct..

thanks anyway, I shall stick with what I have.. Big Grin
Mount Olympus *Olly*
quote:
Originally posted by CaptVimes:
quote:
Originally posted by Supercalifragilistic:
quote:
Originally posted by CaptVimes:
quote:
Originally posted by Hotpants Helen:
Is it always wrong to split an infinitive?
Oh lets have the Star Trek debate Big Grin

I'll go boldly if anyone fancies splitting my infinitive Wink

Engage

Toddles off to find the ring Laugh
FM
quote:
Originally posted by Supercalifragilistic:
quote:
Originally posted by CaptVimes:
quote:
Originally posted by Supercalifragilistic:
quote:
Originally posted by CaptVimes:
quote:
Originally posted by Hotpants Helen:
Is it always wrong to split an infinitive?
Oh lets have the Star Trek debate Big Grin

I'll go boldly if anyone fancies splitting my infinitive Wink

Engage

Toddles off to find the ring Laugh
She goes straight for my ring! Eeker
CaptVimes
Probably be hung for this but:-

I think either in the case of a singular that describes a plural body of things or people.

For instance, a team could be described as a 'they' rather than an 'it'

Norwich [the football club] did well, they beat Colchester 6-0

Norwich did well, it beat Colchester 6-0

Norwich will feel it can win this/The team will feel it can win this.

The team will feel they can win this/The team will feel it can win this.

The second doesn't sound quite right, the inference of Norwich [team] is a group of people rather than a singular object.

How about "The government [it] is awful"
Or "The government [they] are awful"
Carnelian

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×