Skip to main content

Originally Posted by Baz:
an outfit for every occasion Maggie Smith does it again .

Isn't she just fab?   The 'an appropriate costume for effectivity' followed shortly by 'seems a pity to miss a good pudding' had me hooting.

And as for Penelope Wilton's (non) reactions to Ethel's cooking over the last 2 episodes... she's been superb.

 

Glad Lord G and Cora are sorted.  Much as he's a prig, Cora was getting on my norks.

Cosmopolitan

Downtown Abbey recap

Downton Abbey pulled a brilliant episode out of the bag last week with the shock death of Lady Sybil, but the problem with having such a surprise storyline - and a good episode - is that there's then a pressure to keep the standard high.
Whether Downtonmanaged that this week is a bit of a mixed bag; unsurprisingly, the aftermath of Sybil's untimely passing was the most intriguing part of the instalment, while the other storylines largely struggled to keep up.

Downton Abbey S03E06: Ed Speleers as Jimmy Kent

Perhaps the most moving parts of the episode came courtesy of Robert and Cora. As was hinted last week, Cora is furious that Robert - in her eyes - could have prevented Sybil's death if he'd only listened to Dr Clarkson. She's in full passive-aggressive mode, making veiled comments at every opportunity and refusing to allow Robert to return to the marital bed.
While Cora fumes, Robert is heartbroken - shouldering not only the death of his youngest daughter, and the guilt that he may have had something to do with it, but also his wife's opprobrium. So he turns where every man would - to his mother.
It's a testament to Maggie Smith that even when Violet is not spitting out one-liners or wry asides, she's still a captivating character. Whether she's murmuring about grief making one "so terribly tired" or counselling Robert, Smith's allowed to display even more dimension to Violet than she already brings.

Downton Abbey S03E06: Amy Nuttall as Ethel Parks and Penelope Wilton as Isobel Crawley

But Robert isn't just moping around, either - in fact, he's furious with everyone and everything. So when Tom announces that his daughter will be Catholic, Robert is forced to "start his morning" early (and he's not happy about Tom's decision to name the baby Sybil, either, describing it as "ghoulish" when in fact everyone else sees it as kind of a lovely tribute).
Matthew, too, continues to show the worst timing ever as he forges ahead with his attempts to change the way the estate is managed. Naturally, this doesn't sit well with Robert, who takes everything as a personal attack in his vulnerable state. But a surprisingly entertaining consequence of Robert's anguish are the scenes with Mary, who refuses to appease her father, instead gently forcing him to see an alternative viewpoint.
Perhaps she's the only one able to get through to him at this point, but for whatever reason, these small moments - both when Mary defends Tom over the Catholicism and the name Sybil, and when she sticks up for her husband over the (actually quite tedious) management issues - are fantastic. The latter was a particularly poignant scene as she suggests Robert isn't really angry with anyone else: "It's because the world isn't going your way. Not anymore."

Downton Abbey S03E06: Amy Nuttall as Ethel Parks and Lesley Nicol as Mrs PatmoreElsewhere, I wasn't particularly invested in Ethel learning to cook with the help of Mrs Patmore - although any storyline which gives Carson a chance to huff is, obviously, golden - but it did climax in a wonderful moment. Robert is shocked to hear (via Carson via Molesley) that Isobel's lunch party, thrown to cheer up the downcast Downton ladies, is being catered by a FALLEN WOMAN.
So he bursts into the luncheon, all red-faced and puffy, to bring everybody home again. It's a wonderful moment as each and every one of the women refuses to leave - led, admittedly, by Cora, who will do whatever she can to defy her husband at this point. For once, the women have overruled the man, and even Violet puts her concern for etiquette aside for a bit of pudding. Things truly are changing in Downton.
Of course, Robert and Cora can't be angry with each other forever, so Violet does a little scheming to bring them back together. She contacts put-upon Dr Clarkson and urges him to "research" eclampsia - to lie, basically, and tell Robert and Cora that there was no real chance of saving Sybil. Clarkson mumbles and fumbles about ethics and all that, but of course he comes through for Violet, because who would defy the Dowager Countess?
Downton Abbey S03E06: Rob James-Collier as Thomas Barrow

I wasn't wild about this storyline - it seemed pat and unfair and dishonest and an easy way out for the couple to reconcile - but it does lead to a magnificent moment at the end of the episode, as Cora and Robert rush into each other's arms, racking with cathartic sobs, as Violet holds onto the mantlepiece and delicately looks the other way. Everything about this was touching, right down to the very framing.
If only everything about the episode could have been so accomplished; I still struggle to muster up any sort of feeling about the staff love triangle (though there was a curious sense of joy at hearing Mrs Patmore grumpily exclaim: "You're all in love with the wrong people"). And while Alfred was introduced as a sympathetic character caught between O'Brien and Thomas, he's souring faster than milk left on a radiator, using as he does poor Daisy - this week, by dancing the foxtrot with her but conveniently forgetting to mention that he just wanted to impress Ivy with his moves.
Meanwhile, the less said about the increasingly uncomfortable storyline between Thomas and Jimmy, the better - there's just a niggling, unsavoury sense of unwanted advance about it, and I'm just praying it doesn't tip over into assault territory. Surely the character of Thomas could be better served than this?

Downton Abbey S03E06: Jonathan Coy as George Murray

The relationship between Daisy and Mr Mason, on the other hand, continues to be wonderfully sweet, and while I'm not particularly invested in whether or not she takes up his offer to run the farm, I was pleased to see them together again.
Elsewhere, Banged-Up Bates trundles incessantly on as Mrs Bartlet retracts her testimony under the advice of vaguely evil prisoner and vaguely evil prison guard. Only Downtoncould hinge a murder case on whether or not someone had pastry under their fingernails. But Bates is not in jeopardy for long - one knife against the throat and guttural threat later, the guard and prisoner hastily retreat and Mrs Bartlet agrees to testify. So Bates will be out shortly, bringing to an end my attempts to care about the prison side of the show. Still, it was at least enjoyable to see everyone's joy at the news.

Downton Abbey S03E06: Jack Furnival as Craig and Brendan Coyle as Bates

Overall, this episode of Downton had a lingering sense of gloom throughout - understandable, given last week, though I hope that the light relief will return sooner rather than later, because the show needs to get the balance right (it managed this with the incessant religion discussion, as Carson exclaims pompously about having "no great wish to persecute Catholics" and Mrs Hughes mutters: "They'll be relieved to know you no longer want them to be burned at the stake", brilliantly pricking his smug-balloon).
It's always a fine line to draw, but Downton is best when it has both the drama and the comedy. While the best bits of the episode were those focusing on the time after Sybil, that didn't stop it from feeling a little too heavy at times. Hopefully now that Robert and Cora have reconciled - and Bates is due for release - we'll get something lighter in the coming weeks.

FM
Originally Posted by Pengy:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

Pengy - as soon as I heard that I expected it would be this week's 'star comment'     

 

is it just me or does anyone else just want to give Lord Grantham a slap?

me too with a slimy haddock round the chops 

 

Originally Posted by Baz:
Stand in line As for Maggie Smith's one liners , she makes the programme for me

i don't remember him being just quite so pompous and annoying before.

Kaffs
Did anyone see the Q&A session with Elizabeth McGovern in yesterday's G2? I didn't realise she fronted a band. Sadie and the Hotheads finest moment was playing live at the Isle of Wight festival. Whilst we all love Joni Mitchell, it disappoints to learn that her other favourite artists are Dylan, Simon, and yes you've guessed it, Laughing Len.
Garage Joe

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×