All i heard was Sam shouting for Josie, they only had a minute, and to be honest i dont think they really understood what was going on IMO

I dont think they even know who voted for who, Corin put her hand up for someone, dont remember who, then someone else said you can only vote once, then sam was shouting Josie over the top of everyone. So in a word, No.

Think they going to show it on HL show, thats started now

think when josies name got mentioned JJ, Andrew and JJ2 said yeah ................it kind of went round the group in an odd sort of way and no one got any more than that.

It was a sort of organised chaos.

They should have got them to write it down it would have been more organised it was to quick to get a fair vote.

I agree but they don't have pens and paper! TBH ................I'd go crackers withoit pen and paper - it helps me prganise my thoughts.

if they had more time, or had to write it down, i think it woulda been a totally different result.

I know soozy but they could have been given them just to write down a name and took them back none of them were really saying anything 

Mono, who do you think they would have picked.

Agree Marg - plus I dont think they actually understood what they had to do.  On the one hand they were saying that she was a cert for the final and then giving her the free pass - wasted vote in other words - bunch of thickos

As far as I can tell......

Corin voted for Mario
Dave voted Josie
John James voted Josie
Mario voted Corin

The rest of the votes were unclear.  Although C4 website says Josie received the majority of the votes.

It does Smarting, it also said elsewhere that it was unanimous

But, they then stuck with who they had chosen Barmie, in case they were wrong

Watched it on hls and still can't work out all of the votes!

That's definitely untrue - at least as far as the "show-of-hands" is concerned. It was all very confused, but I think she only got 3 votes (though that was still the most for any HM).

I've got it recorded, so if I get the time, I'll go back over it and report back...

Oo would you Eugene please:
I think it was:
Corin: Mario
Steve?
Dave: Josie
JJ1: Josie
JJ2 Josie??
Mario: Corin
Sam: Mario
Andrew: Josie 
Josie: JJ1

Noone wanted to vote incase it took the vote off them..Dave's face was a picture, he evin coughed and sat forward as if to point votes towards him....

OK - the following is based entirely on HLs. I'm 99% certain that HMs voted as I've ascribed them, but because of the editing, it's possible (indeed very likely) that I've missed some votes.  I don't know how Sam or Steve voted - if at all. I had a look back at the live footage, but it was very confusing because the producer concentrated on close-ups.

This is listed as HM (as Andrew called them): who voted for them:
Mario: Corin
JJ: No one
Josie: Andrew, Dave, John James
Sam: No one
John James: Josie
Corin: Mario (Josie still had her hand up)
Dave: No one
Andrew: No one
Steve: JJ

Two points:
Andrew's call for "Sam" was almost drowned out in the confusion: on first viewing, I thought he'd been missed-out.
After Andrew called for "Corin", the whole thing degenerated anyway with increased calls that "Josie will be there anyway", so I doubt many took it seriously after that...

Thanks Eugene....so we still don't know who Steve voted for? Sam said afterwards that he'd voted for Mario. Also, not sure about who JJ2 voted , he looked like he was about to vote for JJ1 but then realised that he'd already used his vote???

Did Steve just point to himself?

I did not see either Steve or Sam stick their hand up at all. (That's not to say they didn't: just that if they did, it wasn't - as far as I could see - broadcast live or on HLs.)
On HL, they cut to a wide camera shot as Andrew called for votes for "Mario", and only Corin had her hand up. If Sam did stick his hand up, he did it "late" and it was lost in the editing...
(On the live broadcast, the camera was tight on Corin and Dave at that point, so doesn't help here.)
JJ definitely went to put his hand up when Steve's name was called but, as I said, the whole thing had degenerated by that point, so I'm not sure anyone noticed!

Ahhhh, so Steve voted for Josie.... he just said so on hls, and that if he'd had more time to think he wouldn't have because she would have made the final anyway

Probably ................do you know what? I really don't like him.