but she wasn't judging herself, she's not a contestant, the twins can't sing, so she  had a point.

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooo she can never have a point.

Not even if it's a really really REEEEALLY good point?

No Cagney, noooooooooooooooooooooo.

Not 'hypocrisy' at all, unless she really thinks they sing well.

We could say it's the pot calling the kettle black, maybe!

So hang on a minute...

Cheryl says they can't sing? Someone says she has a point and then someone else says she can't sing either so she has no point...?

So if I'm correct it means that you cannot have a point of opinion at all if you can't do what you have an opinion on either...?

I'm no singer but I can see that those twins aren't the best singers in the competition by far but my opinion doesn't count apparently because I can't sing well either so my point is nul and void...

Only people who can sing really really well or dance really really well are allowed to comment from now on... Am I correct in saying this?

A tad confused 

Whether Cheryl can sing or not is not the point. She is a judge on a talent show and she's flippin right. They can't sing. I've yet to hear Simon Cowell singing and Louis Walsh should be retired.

i think blue diamond was being  tongue in cheek ,lol.

That's as maybe Jackson but the general vein of the replies on here seem to point at the fact she can't sing either so how can she comment on the twins singing - I was just wondering what qualifications one needed to be able to know who can sing and who can't. I know I can spot an awful singer and I can appreciate a good singer... Maybe I put my serious head on this morning lol

Ask Simon & Louis.

Ah yes the Cowell-Walsh qualification - of course!

i agree with you lazy.