Originally Posted by Katerina:
They spent a good deal of that routine standing on one spot and doing dance moves!!
Exactly!
OK, I've decided....
1 Matthew
2 Chico
3 Jorgie
I know Chico dropped her and all that.. but I think he's a better skater
Happy Birthday Kat!
Originally Posted by Katerina:
Hello all, I might not be here for the whole show as it's my birthday and I will be off to stuff my face at some point, so if I disappear you'll know why
Are Matthew, Jorgie and Chico doing 3 routines? The ensemble pieces seem a bit style over substance for me.....do we really need a rain machine to prove Matt can skate, or for Jorgie to be chucked in the air by 3 pro skaters? I think not.
Katarina Witt is mad as a box of frogs
Happy Birthday Katerina x
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
OK, I've decided....
1 Matthew
2 Chico
3 Jorgie
I know Chico dropped her and all that.. but I think he's a better skater
I agree Jorgie is just coasting now and getting lifted, she never skates on her own, how can it be right that she gets to stay over 2 skaters who do a lot of solo skating?
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
OK, I've decided....
1 Matthew
2 Chico
3 Jorgie
I know Chico dropped her and all that.. but I think he's a better skater
Fortunately it was the pro who had to recover rather than the other way round. Could've been a whole lot worse
I didn't realise it was your birthday Katerina.
Hope you've had a good day.
Originally Posted by squiggle:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
OK, I've decided....
1 Matthew
2 Chico
3 Jorgie
I know Chico dropped her and all that.. but I think he's a better skater
I agree Jorgie is just coasting now and getting lifted, she never skates on her own, how can it be right that she gets to stay over 2 skaters who do a lot of solo skating?
I agree... and TBH I would rather have seen Chemmy in the finals, rather than Jorgie...... cos she was really starting to improve....
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Well I dunno...
Chico did way more skating that Jorgie I think
True, but it was his fault that Jodeyn ended up on the ice.
Jorgie wasn't on the ice much, but there were no mistakes.
Originally Posted by squiggle:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
OK, I've decided....
1 Matthew
2 Chico
3 Jorgie
I know Chico dropped her and all that.. but I think he's a better skater
I agree Jorgie is just coasting now and getting lifted, she never skates on her own, how can it be right that she gets to stay over 2 skaters who do a lot of solo skating?
I think that some of the people like the lifts better than skating talent
Originally Posted by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
Well I dunno... Chico did way more skating that Jorgie I think
True, but it was his fault that Jodeyn ended up on the ice.
Jorgie wasn't on the ice much, but there were no mistakes.
Yep, his mistake - no doubt.
Jorgie was never going to be in danger with 3 pro's to catch her though!
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
OK, I've decided....
1 Matthew
2 Chico
3 Jorgie
I know Chico dropped her and all that.. but I think he's a better skater
I think she's a lovely dancer 'though and it is 'Dancing' on Ice I suppose. Much prefer watching her to Chico...Matthew to win
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
I didn't realise it was your birthday Katerina.
Hope you've had a good day.
That is sooooo cute Sooz, clever you for finding it
Thought that was beautiful
In all honesty I really don't think it's possible to compare male and female celebs - it's a no brainer IMO that the men have to do so much more (and risk looking bad) whereas it's relatively easy for a female to be made to look good without doing very much.
Well she did more skating in that routine.....here come the 10s
Well deserved 10s imho
Thanks for the info Fluffy, I missed the start so wasn't sure exactly how many routines they were doing.
Cosi, Supes, Kaffy, Soozy - thankyou 
I agree that Matthew should be scored lower than the first routine, but 9.5 was too high I think.
Originally Posted by Baz:
They will give her 10s now I reckon...
They did
I'm obviously missing something here 'cos it looked like another routine with not much skating from Jorgie
The scores mean zilch now. They're all for effect
It's no good I've gorn right off Jorgie, and I liked her at the start.
Originally Posted by Kaytee:
Well she did more skating in that routine.....here come the 10s
Was good, but only 9.5s I think.
Aww I loved that routine by Jorgie and Matt, really beautiful.
Jorgie can skate with precision, and it's a shame that T&D seem to favour her getting carried around more than the technical stuff.
Originally Posted by Baz:
Well, what did I tell you!! Foregone conclusion
Money for votes if voters think she's tieing with Matthew
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
I'm obviously missing something here 'cos it looked like another routine with not much skating from Jorgie
The scores mean zilch now. They're all for effect
Exactly... on both points Cosmo Personally, I think Jorgie has been overscored all the way through...... but then I think most of them have.....
Originally Posted by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing:
Originally Posted by Kaytee:
Well she did more skating in that routine.....here come the 10s
Was good, but only 9.5s I think.
I sgree with you Fluffs....no mistakes, but the actual skating wasn't difficult
Originally Posted by Katerina:
Aww I loved that routine by Jorgie and Matt, really beautiful.
Jorgie can skate with precision, and it's a shame that T&D seem to favour her getting carried around more than the technical stuff.
That's what I don't get; she should be out ON the ice showcasing her skating ability. In my humble of course....
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by ~Cosmopolitan~:
I'm obviously missing something here 'cos it looked like another routine with not much skating from Jorgie
The scores mean zilch now. They're all for effect
Exactly... on both points Cosmo Personally, I think Jorgie has been overscored all the way through...... but then I think most of them have.....
The show needs to have the final 2 looking as though it's nip and tuck.
Personally I think Matthew's way in front.
I may be biased though!
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by squiggle:
It's no good I've gorn right off Jorgie, and I liked her at the start.
I did too Baz, but I just don't like that stage school personality and yappy gob
Originally Posted by Kaytee:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Well, what did I tell you!! Foregone conclusion
Money for votes if voters think she's tieing with Matthew
Although she scored higher than him on the app. Maybe she's more popular than we think?
Originally Posted by Supercalifragilistic:
Originally Posted by Kaytee:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Well, what did I tell you!! Foregone conclusion
Money for votes if voters think she's tieing with Matthew
Although she scored higher than him on the app. Maybe she's more popular than we think?
I blooming well hope not!!