quote:
Originally posted by brisket:
The standard last night was the lowest in a pretty poor week.
Leaving aside the Drama and furore surrounding Holly Steel, and simply focusing on talent:
I think she has a very thin, squeeky little voice (yes I know she is a child, but nevertheless thin and squeeky). She did not hit all her notes accurately. She should not have attampted those final rising notes, which sounded terrible. And of course she forgot or froze.
Staggered that she is in the final. Her "talent" such as it is did not appeal to me.
The dancer boy I thought was aided by back-screen technology. Just focusing on him alone, I thought he was just fairly ordinary.
Poor lot last night.
And tonight there are people in the final who I think should not be there based on talent.
I absolutely agree with everything you say, brisket. Those notes that the girl sang at the end should have been the final nail in the coffin that contains her dubious 'talent', instead of which she was admired for it!
The style of dancing that the other child did just does not appeal to me - it's just hyperactivity with an epileptic twist!
Children under the age of 17 should not be allowed to enter the competition, imo. The gormless public vote on the cuteness factor rather than raw talent which is very, very wrong.
We'd be far better judges!