Ive been told its because Fanny met Dick and things in the books and its considered rude now? There was plenty of Fanny's and Dicks about back then when it was written so why ban it now? 
Replies sorted oldest to newest
It's political correctness gone mad 
There! That's that one sorted.
There! That's that one sorted.
My eight year old only found out the other day that Dick is a real name.
He's still laughing about it!
He's still laughing about it!
ahhh you see if it was in America, that'd be okay...you see because in America fanny means something else....I can't get away with that joke twice can i? 
(is this a joke btw toots because if it's not it's very disturbing...I used to love the Famous Five when I was a kid...poor Enid...between Fannys, Dicks and golliwogs, she's not standing the test of time very well is she?)
(is this a joke btw toots because if it's not it's very disturbing...I used to love the Famous Five when I was a kid...poor Enid...between Fannys, Dicks and golliwogs, she's not standing the test of time very well is she?)
There were Enid Blyton books in the library of the school I was trained in and my kids' schools.
I think sometimes some Heads take daft decisions and then the gossip spreads that all schools have banned things.
When the Head banned chocolate and fizzy pop (which I agreed with) to hear the parents carry on you'd think she'd banned eating
I think sometimes some Heads take daft decisions and then the gossip spreads that all schools have banned things.
When the Head banned chocolate and fizzy pop (which I agreed with) to hear the parents carry on you'd think she'd banned eating
quote:Originally posted by Blizzie:
My eight year old only found out the other day that Dick is a real name.
He's still laughing about it!
Mary loves Dick.
theyve changed the names in the new prints-personally, ive never had trouble with 'fanny' but 'dick' bothered me
im on about the NAMES blizzie, before you splutter and start nudging and winking
im on about the NAMES blizzie, before you splutter and start nudging and winking
quote:Originally posted by Garage Joe:
It's political correctness gone mad
There! That's that one sorted.
'elf an' safety!
There's a (whispers) golly in one of the books, isn't there?
quote:Originally posted by Garage Joe:
It's political correctness gone mad
There! That's that one sorted.
Enough said! Packs up thread and leaves
quote:Originally posted by Blizzie:
My eight year old only found out the other day that Dick is a real name.
He's still laughing about it!
Is it banned though?
Waits for thread to descend into Smutt!
quote:Originally posted by china:
theyve changed the names in the new prints-personally, ive never had trouble with 'fanny' but 'dick' bothered me
Dick was a bit of a pain though..the self righteous little git...not like Julian...Julian was lovely
quote:Originally posted by Daniel J*:
There's a (whispers) golly in one of the books, isn't there?
Yes
In Noddy
Don't think they're banned, but I do know all the naughty golliwogs in the Noddy books have mutated into naughty teddy bears instead.
quote:Originally posted by Templetonpeck:
ahhh you see if it was in America, that'd be okay...you see because in America fanny means something else....I can't get away with that joke twice can i?
(is this a joke btw toots because if it's not it's very disturbing...I used to love the Famous Five when I was a kid...poor Enid...between Fannys, Dicks and golliwogs, she's not standing the test of time very well is she?)
No its not a Joke Temps, I been informed its been removed from school librarys and maybe public ones so was really wanting to know if its true.
quote:Originally posted by Templetonpeck:quote:Originally posted by china:
theyve changed the names in the new prints-personally, ive never had trouble with 'fanny' but 'dick' bothered me
Dick was a bit of a pain though..the self righteous little git...not like Julian...Julian was lovely
dick was always starving
julian was 'grown up' especially when he set his chin in a determined manner
anne was the housewife-she could make a home out of a tin can that girl could
george was fierce,stubborn and proud-and quite possibly a lesbian
timmy was a dog
How stupid 
, used to love reading all them books at School sitting on the Beanbag pillow things we had in class with all the others .
, used to love reading all them books at School sitting on the Beanbag pillow things we had in class with all the others .
Maybe it's more of a case of some schools and libraries replacing their old copies with the new (tinkered with) copies...not so much banning them?
quote:Originally posted by electric6:
There were Enid Blyton books in the library of the school I was trained in and my kids' schools.
I think sometimes some Heads take daft decisions and then the gossip spreads that all schools have banned things.
When the Head banned chocolate and fizzy pop (which I agreed with) to hear the parents carry on you'd think she'd banned eating
Awww the voice of reason, ok thats one sensible school.
quote:Originally posted by Tootall:quote:Originally posted by Templetonpeck:
ahhh you see if it was in America, that'd be okay...you see because in America fanny means something else....I can't get away with that joke twice can i?
(is this a joke btw toots because if it's not it's very disturbing...I used to love the Famous Five when I was a kid...poor Enid...between Fannys, Dicks and golliwogs, she's not standing the test of time very well is she?)
No its not a Joke Temps, I been informed its been removed from school librarys and maybe public ones so was really wanting to know if its true.
Why are you asking me?
well that's just ridiculous...where will our kids be without Kirrin Island and Ginger Beer *hopes she's kept all her books*
quote:Originally posted by china:
george was fierce,stubborn and proud-and quite possibly a lesbian
I always thought she'd turn out to be a Greenham Common type thingy too.
quote:Originally posted by china:quote:Originally posted by Templetonpeck:quote:Originally posted by china:
theyve changed the names in the new prints-personally, ive never had trouble with 'fanny' but 'dick' bothered me
Dick was a bit of a pain though..the self righteous little git...not like Julian...Julian was lovely
dick was always starving
julian was 'grown up' especially when he set his chin in a determined manner
anne was the housewife-she could make a home out of a tin can that girl could
george was fierce,stubborn and proud-and quite possibly a lesbian
timmy was a dog
I remember one story where Dick upset Anne and Julian told him to back off and went to comfort poor Anne who was scared and crying...I think I may have had a small crush on him after that
quote:Originally posted by Daniel J*:quote:Originally posted by Blizzie:
My eight year old only found out the other day that Dick is a real name.
He's still laughing about it!
Mary loves Dick.
Lol
I haven't heard anything and I work as a librarian. I think its probably individual policy. High school libraries often have quite contraversial stories in there, its reading for young adults, I think anyone who finds Enid Blyton too raunchy needs a serious head check.
I was told the other day that one of the most popular books at the moment is Before I Die, Jenny Downham which deals with sex, drugs etc so I don't think Fanny and Dick would cause such a problem.
I was told the other day that one of the most popular books at the moment is Before I Die, Jenny Downham which deals with sex, drugs etc so I don't think Fanny and Dick would cause such a problem.
quote:Originally posted by china:quote:Originally posted by Templetonpeck:quote:Originally posted by china:
theyve changed the names in the new prints-personally, ive never had trouble with 'fanny' but 'dick' bothered me
Dick was a bit of a pain though..the self righteous little git...not like Julian...Julian was lovely
dick was always starving
julian was 'grown up' especially when he set his chin in a determined manner
anne was the housewife-she could make a home out of a tin can that girl could
george was fierce,stubborn and proud-and quite possibly a lesbian
timmy was a dog
Dick was a supercilious numpty, and I bet Julian was only waiting for a couple of years' growth, when he'd be able to 'take' him Anne probably has "The Surrendered Wife" on her bookshelf. And George really is George these days
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Templetonpeck:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Tootall:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Templetonpeck:
ahhh you see if it was in America, that'd be okay...you see because in America fanny means something else....I can't get away with that joke twice can i?
(is this a
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Tootall:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Templetonpeck:
ahhh you see if it was in America, that'd be okay...you see because in America fanny means something else....I can't get away with that joke twice can i?
(is this a
quote:Originally posted by Templetonpeck:quote:Originally posted by Tootall:quote:Originally posted by Templetonpeck:
ahhh you see if it was in America, that'd be okay...you see because in America fanny means something else....I can't get away with that joke twice can i?
(is this a joke btw toots because if it's not it's very disturbing...I used to love the Famous Five when I was a kid...poor Enid...between Fannys, Dicks and golliwogs, she's not standing the test of time very well is she?)
No its not a Joke Temps, I been informed its been removed from school librarys and maybe public ones so was really wanting to know if its true.
Why are you asking me?
well that's just ridiculous...where will our kids be without Kirrin Island and Ginger Beer *hopes she's kept all her books*
ahhhhh!
pulling up to kirrin cottage in the horse and cart-joanne bustling in the kitchen making a special tea,timmy getting yelled at by uncle quinten-heaps of tomatoes,lashings of ginger beer, a HUGE ham
*sighs*
didnt it just fire your imagination
ive made myself hungry now
quote:Originally posted by china:
theyve changed the names in the new prints-personally, ive never had trouble with 'fanny' but 'dick' bothered me
im on about the NAMES blizzie, before you splutter and start nudging and winking
They changed the names?
Thats riddiculous, have they sensored shakespeare? quote:Originally posted by china:
ahhhhh!
pulling up to kirrin cottage in the horse and cart-joanne bustling in the kitchen making a special tea,timmy getting yelled at by uncle quinten-heaps of tomatoes,lashings of ginger beer, a HUGE ham
*sighs*
didnt it just fire your imagination
ive made myself hungry now
Uncle Quentin!!! I was trying to remember his name...was he George's father? He was a bit eccentric wasn't he?
Wasn't there always some one with Scarlett Fever?
It could even be that Fanny and Dick makes the kids collapse giggling and then reading time is ruined by a gaggle of hysterically laughing kids...so it's easier to get through the lesson with Fern and Dave (or summat?)
Dunno... *ponders*
Dunno... *ponders*
quote:Originally posted by Tootall:quote:Originally posted by china:
theyve changed the names in the new prints-personally, ive never had trouble with 'fanny' but 'dick' bothered me
im on about the NAMES blizzie, before you splutter and start nudging and winking
They changed the names?
LOL!
they have!
but in fairness, when i used to read to my step-kids a few years back-you could hear them sniggering when i mentioned the names dick and aunt fanny
quote:Originally posted by Daniel J*:
There's a (whispers) golly in one of the books, isn't there?
when I was a child I only thought gollys were just like a teddybear not based on a person.
quote:Originally posted by china:quote:Originally posted by Tootall:quote:Originally posted by china:
theyve changed the names in the new prints-personally, ive never had trouble with 'fanny' but 'dick' bothered me
im on about the NAMES blizzie, before you splutter and start nudging and winking
They changed the names?
LOL!
they have!
but in fairness, when i used to read to my step-kids a few years back-you could hear them sniggering when i mentioned the names dick and aunt fanny
how old were they? I read the books when I was about 10/11 and fannys and dicks were far from my vocabulary back then
quote:Originally posted by Templetonpeck:quote:Originally posted by china:quote:Originally posted by Tootall:quote:Originally posted by china:
theyve changed the names in the new prints-personally, ive never had trouble with 'fanny' but 'dick' bothered me
im on about the NAMES blizzie, before you splutter and start nudging and winking
They changed the names?
LOL!
they have!
but in fairness, when i used to read to my step-kids a few years back-you could hear them sniggering when i mentioned the names dick and aunt fanny
how old were they? I read the books when I was about 10/11 and fannys and dicks were far from my vocabulary back then
step-kids?
about between the ages of 5-8
quote:Originally posted by china:
step-kids?
about between the ages of 5-8
*faints*
I bet the 8 year old riled up the other ones quote:Originally posted by Templetonpeck:quote:Originally posted by china:
step-kids?
about between the ages of 5-8
*faints*
dont suppose i helped much-once someone starts giggling, it sets me off aswell
well im off to have a look for summat for tea
*wishes anne was here to cook*
ina bit temps
quote:Originally posted by Tootall:
Ive been told its because Fanny met Dick and things in the books and its considered rude now? There was plenty of Fanny's and Dicks about back then when it was written so why ban it now?
I think you were possibly told wrong (they haven't banned "Swallows and Amazons" because of a girl called "Titty"
)What has caused most of the problems with E.B. is the racism and sexism in the books - from Noddy and the "nasty black golliwogs" to the Famous Five - with the depiction of travellers and any foreigners and the sexist attitude to girls and women.
quote:Originally posted by china:quote:Originally posted by Templetonpeck:quote:Originally posted by china:
step-kids?
about between the ages of 5-8
*faints*
dont suppose i helped much-once someone starts giggling, it sets me off aswell
well im off to have a look for summat for tea
*wishes anne was here to cook*
ina bit temps
Enjoy China
