Skip to main content

Originally Posted by Karma_:
 

A lot of people feel the same. But was there this amount of news coverage and statements from the Whitehouse back then? (Can't remember). Admittedly I would have liked to have 'seen' more evidence than a badly photoshopped pic. I know the hanging of that other bloke (big hair horrible one) was macabre but it proved he was gone. Hmmm.

Well no K, because they were hushing it up!  I remember seeing photos in one of the anarcho type mags I think it was but a few mainstream agencies covered it too at the time. I studied world history and Politics at A level as a (very) mature student 10 years ago and when you realise what dirty tricks are done every day by governments all over the world and how they use their partners in the media to hoodwink us all it makes you really cynical.

Manufacturing Consent by Noam Chomsky is a real eye opener - but he is bloody difficult to read

FM

I don't know if what we are hearing is true, nor do I  think the death of Bin Laden will make the world a safer place. As Brisket said, there will always be terrorists.  I would rather Bin Laden had been called to account for his crimes and spent the rest of his life in jail, but that was never a viable alternative, and if he is dead, then so be it..........

Baz
Originally Posted by Veggieburger:
Originally Posted by Karma_:
 

A lot of people feel the same. But was there this amount of news coverage and statements from the Whitehouse back then? (Can't remember). Admittedly I would have liked to have 'seen' more evidence than a badly photoshopped pic. I know the hanging of that other bloke (big hair horrible one) was macabre but it proved he was gone. Hmmm.

Well no K, because they were hushing it up!  I remember seeing photos in one of the anarcho type mags I think it was but a few mainstream agencies covered it too at the time. I studied world history and Politics at A level as a (very) mature student 10 years ago and when you realise what dirty tricks are done every day by governments all over the world and how they use their partners in the media to hoodwink us all it makes you really cynical.

Manufacturing Consent by Noam Chomsky is a real eye opener - but he is bloody difficult to read

 

I've been doing Social Sciences for the last year and it's slightly touched on politics but I don't like it (have never really been into politics that much, tbh). I know it's an ignorance but there's some stuff I think I'd just rather not know when it comes to all that.

Karma_

And Pakistan was unaware he was there? Hmmmmm

It's all very well them saying he has been killed, and they have disposed of him at sea, but prove it!

He was allegedly living in luxury? The pictures they showed was hardly luxury.

I'm by no means a conspiracy theorist, but something doesn't seem right in all this.

 

Of course, his death is not going to stop their cause. We should all be very careful imo.

Jenny
Originally Posted by Mighty Quinn:
Originally Posted by Syd:
Originally Posted by Crunchy Nuts:

I want some evidence. Someone's bound to have filmed it on their mobile phone, right?

There must have been a fanatic out there with 'is/'er mobile poised........

unless there aren't that many mobile phone junkies in abbotabad

They are everywhere......poised for good or bad.....

Syd
Originally Posted by Jenny:

And Pakistan was unaware he was there? Hmmmmm

It's all very well them saying he has been killed, and they have disposed of him at sea, but prove it!

They don't need to prove it, because it would be so easy to disprove it if it wasn't true.

 

For me, this is like one of the main reasons often cited for not believing the conspiracy theory that the US didn't land on the moon: the USSR accepted that they did. The Soviets were the USA's great space rival, and would have been monitoring their space programme: if they knew the US had faked a moon landing, don't you think they'd have shouted it from the rooftops?

 

So it is with Bin Laden. If he was still alive, don't you think YouTube and the like would be bombarded with recordings of him mocking the West?

At most, the only valid conspracy theory is possibly that the US have captured him alive, and have him stashed away somewhere. Even trying to keep that secret would be incredibly risky for the Americans, though...

Eugene's Lair
Originally Posted by Eugene's Lair:
Originally Posted by Jenny:

And Pakistan was unaware he was there? Hmmmmm

It's all very well them saying he has been killed, and they have disposed of him at sea, but prove it!

They don't need to prove it, because it would be so easy to disprove it if it wasn't true.

 

For me, this is like one of the main reasons often cited for not believing the conspiracy theory that the US didn't land on the moon: the USSR accepted that they did. The Soviets were the USA's great space rival, and would have been monitoring their space programme: if they knew the US had faked a moon landing, don't you think they'd have shouted it from the rooftops?

 

So it is with Bin Laden. If he was still alive, don't you think YouTube and the like would be bombarded with recordings of him mocking the West?

At most, the only valid conspracy theory is possibly that the US have captured him alive, and have him stashed away somewhere. Even trying to keep that secret would be incredibly risky for the Americans, though...

i'm like you, i tend to go down the path of least resistance and accept things as they are more agreed on, just to give my coupla brain cells a rest. but, conspiracy theories can be a good read, provide some needed scepticism and encourage debate.

Mighty Quinn
Originally Posted by Eugene's Lair:
Originally Posted by Jenny:

And Pakistan was unaware he was there? Hmmmmm

It's all very well them saying he has been killed, and they have disposed of him at sea, but prove it!

They don't need to prove it, because it would be so easy to disprove it if it wasn't true.

 

For me, this is like one of the main reasons often cited for not believing the conspiracy theory that the US didn't land on the moon: the USSR accepted that they did. The Soviets were the USA's great space rival, and would have been monitoring their space programme: if they knew the US had faked a moon landing, don't you think they'd have shouted it from the rooftops?

 

So it is with Bin Laden. If he was still alive, don't you think YouTube and the like would be bombarded with recordings of him mocking the West?

At most, the only valid conspracy theory is possibly that the US have captured him alive, and have him stashed away somewhere. Even trying to keep that secret would be incredibly risky for the Americans, though...

Give it some time

It took OBL over a year to claim 911 as his own handy work and the US kept the USSR in grain everytime their crop failed(Don't bite the hand that feeds you)

 

 

 

Ensign Muf

So Barack Obama watched it live on TV.

 

So did they send a TV crew to set up all the cameras and mics like Sky Sports setting up for a big football match? Wonder if it was in HD or even 3D! "Err hello Mr Bin Laden, we're just here from Fox Sports to set up all the cameras for the big fight live tonight".

 

Surely this footage will be leaked somehow? I won't believe it fully until I see it and no I won't believe it if I see some footage of a body being thrown off the side of a boat either - it could be some madame tussauds style waxwork for all we know!

Crunchy  Nuts
Originally Posted by PeterCat:


Another MLK quote which I think is quite apt here:


"Returning hate for hate multiplies hate, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of stars. Darkness cannot drive out darkness: only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate: only love can do that."


Hi Peter

 

That is a really good and pertinent quote. I hope you don't mind me using it to challenge you on something.

If you do believe that, how can you say that you will get the bunting out when Mrs Thatcher dies?

Okay we know what she did to this country, but she is still someone's mother....She is also a very sick old woman... is that not poetic justice enough, if indeed that is what we are looking for?

FM
I wonder if the Russians were in on this? You would have thought that they had first claim after losing so many young conscripts. They were tortured, mutilated and missing, whilst idiots like Sandy Gall stood on the sidelines and cheered. Part of me would prefer a trial. Rather like Sadaam Hussein we would have then discovered the whole sordid truth. However this set of actions seemed more practical.
Garage Joe
I remember when 9/11 happened there were scenes of jubilation coming from the East and we were all....'omg the barbarians!'  And now the Americans are doing exactly the same thing and they're being patted on the back for it.

 

I don't believe what they did was right.  I don't believe shooting him (if that's what happened) and killing him was the way to go.  I also don't believe that for the past 10 years they didn't know where he was and now because some guy in Guantanamo Bay finally has enough of the torture and finally rats him out?  I don't know why all this is coming out now but my feeling on it is it's because Obama said he would end the war in Iraq and Afghanistan and bring their troops home and killing Bin Laden is the only way he could do that.  If they didn't know where he was all this time, the Facebook Groups are true and he is the World Hide and Seek Champion  They found Hussein in a hole in the ground ffs and they couldn't find Bin Laden living it up in a compound?

 

Whatever happened, it was nothing more than a revenge killing.  Yes Bin Laden was a terrorist, yes he committed more than enough crimes to deserve the death he got, but does that mean the US Government who sing from the roof tops about human rights had the right to carry it out?  I don't believe they did.  Terrorists always take up action for a reason, Bin Laden got peed off with US troops moving into Saudi which is allegedly what sparked off his terrorist lifestyle.  It doesn't excuse what they do, but I always think it's important to look at what motivates people to join these groups, not to sympathise with them but to understand that there are two sides to every story and it's not just as simple as  Them = Bad  US = Good.

 

Anyhow, that's my rant on it all

Temps
Last edited by Temps
Originally Posted by spongebob squarepants:
Originally Posted by Cagney:
Originally Posted by PeterCat:
Originally Posted by Antiope:

Fuk knows why "crowds are gathering at the gates of the White House and singing.." though, as is being reported.  

Because the neoCons made Bin Laden into the boogie man, and a large part of the American public have bought into that. Therefore they're celebrating because they think the boogie man is dead.

As far as a lot of Americans are concerned he was worse than the boogie man. He was real. If they want to stand outside the White House and sing....good on them. 

spot on cags xx

I agree  with Cagney and spongee who can blame the Americans  they have every right to feel victorious it was on his orders that gave the go ahead for 9/11 there were British killed that day too, he was also willing to let his own men die whilst he hid all over the place ..ask the families whose relatives  died that day ..they will say justice has been done..

Marguerita
I can understand a slight unease from ourselves. There's an element of the Wild West about this chain of events. We don 't have much in common with the Americans and would have preferred Bin Liner to have his day in court. We like to subject such nutjobs to derision, disrespect, sarcasm etc. Yet! I can't think of any practical way to achieve that. Still alive, and in custody, he might present some further security threat to the Spanish, the Russians, the British, the USA, or any other country he has wronged. Maybe this way out, and disposing of his body in a secret location was a better way out.
Garage Joe
Originally Posted by Temps:
I remember when 9/11 happened there were scenes of jubilation coming from the East and we were all....'omg the barbarians!'  And now the Americans are doing exactly the same thing and they're being patted on the back for it.

 

I don't believe what they did was right.  I don't believe shooting him (if that's what happened) and killing him was the way to go.  I also don't believe that for the past 10 years they didn't know where he was and now because some guy in Guantanamo Bay finally has enough of the torture and finally rats him out?  I don't know why all this is coming out now but my feeling on it is it's because Obama said he would end the war in Iraq and Afghanistan and bring their troops home and killing Bin Laden is the only way he could do that.  If they didn't know where he was all this time, the Facebook Groups are true and he is the World Hide and Seek Champion  They found Hussein in a hole in the ground ffs and they couldn't find Bin Laden living it up in a compound?

 

Whatever happened, it was nothing more than a revenge killing.  Yes Bin Laden was a terrorist, yes he committed more than enough crimes to deserve the death he got, but does that mean the US Government who sing from the roof tops about human rights had the right to carry it out?  I don't believe they did.  Terrorists always take up action for a reason, Bin Laden got peed off with US troops moving into Saudi which is allegedly what sparked off his terrorist lifestyle.  It doesn't excuse what they do, but I always think it's important to look at what motivates people to join these groups, not to sympathise with them but to understand that there are two sides to every story and it's not just as simple as  Them = Bad  US = Good.

 

Anyhow, that's my rant on it all


Very well said, you took the words out of my mouth.  Whilst I am sure that countless people are relieved or pleased that he is dead, with justification,  I think the jubilation that has been reported is quite sickening, and makes those who have behaved like that little better than the people they were so quick to castigate for doing the same after 11 September.  Whilst I would have preferred to have seen Bin Laden captured and tried, I don't have a real problem with the fact that he has been killed, but I can't udnerstand how any civilised human being rejoice publicly in this way over the death of another person.

FM
Originally Posted by Marguerita:
Originally Posted by spongebob squarepants:
Originally Posted by Cagney:
Originally Posted by PeterCat:
Originally Posted by Antiope:

Fuk knows why "crowds are gathering at the gates of the White House and singing.." though, as is being reported.  

Because the neoCons made Bin Laden into the boogie man, and a large part of the American public have bought into that. Therefore they're celebrating because they think the boogie man is dead.

As far as a lot of Americans are concerned he was worse than the boogie man. He was real. If they want to stand outside the White House and sing....good on them. 

spot on cags xx

I agree  with Cagney and spongee who can blame the Americans  they have every right to feel victorious it was on his orders that gave the go ahead for 9/11 there were British killed that day too, he was also willing to let his own men die whilst he hid all over the place ..ask the families whose relatives  died that day ..they will say justice has been done..

What about the justice for the Afghans and the Iraqi's who had nothing to do with the Taliban, Al Quaeda or any other terrorist organisations who have been shot, killed, maimed, their lands destroyed by bombs falling far from where they should? Do they not deserve justice? Are they now allowed go to the US and shoot Obama?

 

Temps

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×