Crystal`s (is that bowersox?)  is good but the compliments were over de top this week. It was over before I knew it

Lily, not bad. Trying too hard to be croaky country and not getting there.

Boys tomorrow. I`m struggling to find anyone outstanding this year. Last year was great. Danny Boy

I do like my pony tail man...Casey

I watched the boys last night.

Michael Lynche - This Woman's Work. Loved it

I liked Michael Lynche last night vocally, but there's something about him that gets on my norks. I think it's cos he goes a bit over the top with everything, I dunno.

Stil loving Aaron but he's gone off the boil a bit Danny Gokey was W.I.C.K.E.D. last week!

Cn i just say I thought Michael Lynche was a bit naff...I didn't get what they were seein/hearin at all...I thought it was as dull as a dull thing..and half the time he was dorwned out buy the music (as most of them are all the time)

I didn't get it either Croc.  

This is my first American Idol....could anyone tell me if they move to a bigger studio once they are down to the final 12? I'm not liking the set up at the moment, and the sound is really bad! (unless they all just can't sing that well of course. )

Can someone put up who went please cos I missed it watching the Eurovision thing

So far, Todrick (sang Queens someone to love last night) and Katelyn (blonde girl with the curly hair) have gone. Dont know if there's more to go though?

Ducky it goes to the Kodak theatre for the main shows after all the cuts (cant remember if it's the final 12 or final 10?) But it's HOOOOGE!

OMG Todcrick SMASHED it on his exit performance! NO WAY should he be going home

Wow a couple of surprises there that went.... def wrong song choice for the last girl that went... I liked her... I have no idea of names yes.. sorry, she was in the green dress... !!!

todrick and alex went in the boys and katelyn and lilly in the girls croc..

oops me comp is sooooooo slow karms and ducky already answered..........

Lily went??

I thought she was a fair bet to win the thing!

yep she looked shocked croc......when ryan interviewed her she said she thought she'd 'given it everything..and didn't know what america wanted'.......


dunno if crystal was mates with her or something but she had a right gob on..

her and crysal were/are the best two girls

Lily was the silver haired girl who sang in a jazz kinda way didn't she? I haven't got to that bit yet. Oh Alex looks glad that's over with.

Yes I agree.. Lily looked 'shocked' I really thought the youngster would've gone out of both of them.. and I think you are right.. Lily and crystal were/are the better vocalists...

alex was just too nervous...he had the real rabbit in the headlights thing going on.....every idol season though i compare it to the brilliant fantasia/jennifer hudson etc etc one.......that was acers

I was surprised that Lily went tonight, but I thought her attitude was really unfortunate and didn't do her any favours at all.  I was amazed at Crystal's behaviour during the show tonight - she must be the most sour faced. miserable old boot I've ever seen on the show.  No matter how good a voice she's got, I would hate her to win with an attitude like that.

I think he deserved to go just for having such a ridiculous name

ARe they doing Stones songs?

That'll be a bit bizarre for the girls...but I hope someone does Backsteet Girl

Why is Michael shaking his legs like hes poo'd himself?

This is pretty boring.

See??! Didn't I say Michael was OTT (cant remember if I used the word desperate) - but Simon is SO on my wavelength

If you see what I said last week...I couldn;t see what all the fuss was about with him...

This is quite borng as wel..not to mention out of tune

This Didi is getting on my nerves a bit

Ooh Casey next....we like him.

I like this....countrified Stones

He's getting on my nerves aswell

You are a REAL whinger tonight!
Give it a rest woman!

I still like Casey.

Me too... This girl has a really whiny voice....

And who have you come as? Moses?!

God.

Keep it real woman!

I am
Anyway...Andrew is pretty good...normal service resumed this week

Katie was OK...but hey're all fairly boring this week

I am still not overly excited about any of them tbh, at least last year there was Adam Lambert, Danny Gokey..etc. These lot are like a crap compared to them!

I hated Adam Lambert and his bloody screeching