Skip to main content

Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
Originally Posted by Baz:

Can I make a suggestion ....if we are self governing .....and in order to clarify things ( and prevent a repeat of this in future ) ....maybe we should hold a referendum .....someone could do a poll ....something along the lines of *Should the term spoiler be restricted to nominations , evictions and finalist results * .....or however they wanted to word it. Just a thought .

Very good idea , Baz . I wouldnt know how to do it. Somebody will, i am sure

I'm sure they will  Skykark I just think it should be kept simple ....maybe Should all BB information be deemed a spoiler prior to the HL show airing * ? 

See.. I disagree already - that's too vague, despite what's been said, the only things I've seen that people think should be spoilers are chuck/walk out and warnings.     If you say all info, you're obviously going to get the no vote.

 

From what I see in the polls, you can post several options.

 

how about giving the option of

 

noms and evictions - which I think everyone agrees on

 

noms, evictions, walker and throw outs

 

noms, evictions, walkers, throw outs and warnings

 

Noms, evictions, warnings.

 

Everything 

 

Nothing

 

there seems to be an option for people to make suggestions too.

Lol .... I think that would make us all a bit Kaffs And you can bet your bottom dollar something that wasn't on the list ( like my new thread) would pop up and rock the boat I really think it has to be more simple than that ...but that's just me  

Well.. doing it the other way gives no option for people being chucked out to be classed as a spoiler because I don't think anyone has said that nothing should be openly discussed.   It would be pretty much hobson's choice with one question.

I think Skylark's suggestion ^^^ might cover that Kaffy  

Baz
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
Originally Posted by Baz:

Can I make a suggestion ....if we are self governing .....and in order to clarify things ( and prevent a repeat of this in future ) ....maybe we should hold a referendum .....someone could do a poll ....something along the lines of *Should the term spoiler be restricted to nominations , evictions and finalist results * .....or however they wanted to word it. Just a thought .

Very good idea , Baz . I wouldnt know how to do it. Somebody will, i am sure

I'm sure they will  Skykark I just think it should be kept simple ....maybe Should all BB information be deemed a spoiler prior to the HL show airing * ? 

The HL show is usually yesterdays news tho...perhaps just a question asking if we agree with news given as it happens.....as like the old LF days. With perhaps no news given for noms and normal evictions, without a "spoiler" in title of thread?

That would work  I think Skykark 

I don't.

Ok ....well I'm sure somebody in the know can devise a poll  

Baz
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
Originally Posted by Baz:

Can I make a suggestion ....if we are self governing .....and in order to clarify things ( and prevent a repeat of this in future ) ....maybe we should hold a referendum .....someone could do a poll ....something along the lines of *Should the term spoiler be restricted to nominations , evictions and finalist results * .....or however they wanted to word it. Just a thought .

Very good idea , Baz . I wouldnt know how to do it. Somebody will, i am sure

I'm sure they will  Skykark I just think it should be kept simple ....maybe Should all BB information be deemed a spoiler prior to the HL show airing * ? 

See.. I disagree already - that's too vague, despite what's been said, the only things I've seen that people think should be spoilers are chuck/walk out and warnings.     If you say all info, you're obviously going to get the no vote.

 

From what I see in the polls, you can post several options.

 

how about giving the option of

 

noms and evictions - which I think everyone agrees on

 

noms, evictions, walker and throw outs

 

noms, evictions, walkers, throw outs and warnings

 

Noms, evictions, warnings.

 

Everything 

 

Nothing

 

there seems to be an option for people to make suggestions too.

Lol .... I think that would make us all a bit Kaffs And you can bet your bottom dollar something that wasn't on the list ( like my new thread) would pop up and rock the boat I really think it has to be more simple than that ...but that's just me  

Well.. doing it the other way gives no option for people being chucked out to be classed as a spoiler because I don't think anyone has said that nothing should be openly discussed.   It would be pretty much hobson's choice with one question.

I think Skylark's suggestion ^^^ might cover that Kaffy  

not really - it only allows for noms and evictions to be spoilered because, if we're honest, nobody is going to say make everything else a spoiler?

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
 

That would work  I think Skykark 

I don't.

Ok ....well I'm sure somebody in the know can devise a poll  

or maybe I need to take the hint and piss off as Syd suggested?

I don't think that Syd was saying that  

"take responsibility for themselves and don't come on a BB forum"   

 

Seems pretty clear

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
 

That would work  I think Skykark 

I don't.

Ok ....well I'm sure somebody in the know can devise a poll  

or maybe I need to take the hint and piss off as Syd suggested?

I don't think that Syd was saying that  

"take responsibility for themselves and don't come on a BB forum"   

 

Seems pretty clear

I think she meant steer clear /not look at the main forum , until the HL programme airs ....

Baz
Originally Posted by Baz:

I will just say this though ....I think the fact ( which has been raised) that there are no BB discussion threads on the general forum any more is basically down to the fact that people used to like to discuss stuff as it happened , rather than the next day . 

I don't get that at all..... the spoiler things 24 hrs old?   It's been on about a week??

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
 

That would work  I think Skykark 

I don't.

Ok ....well I'm sure somebody in the know can devise a poll  

or maybe I need to take the hint and piss off as Syd suggested?

I don't think that Syd was saying that  

"take responsibility for themselves and don't come on a BB forum"   

 

Seems pretty clear

I think she meant steer clear /not look at the main forum , until the HL programme airs ....

so.. don't come on the forum then?   When it's pretty much an OT forum anyway?

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:

I will just say this though ....I think the fact ( which has been raised) that there are no BB discussion threads on the general forum any more is basically down to the fact that people used to like to discuss stuff as it happened , rather than the next day . 

I don't get that at all..... the spoiler things 24 hrs old?   It's been on about a week??

Eh ? I meant that the fact that the forum used to be full of threads was because we were discussing stuff from LF ....

Baz
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:

I will just say this though ....I think the fact ( which has been raised) that there are no BB discussion threads on the general forum any more is basically down to the fact that people used to like to discuss stuff as it happened , rather than the next day . 

I don't get that at all..... the spoiler things 24 hrs old?   It's been on about a week??

Eh ? I meant that the fact that the forum used to be full of threads was because we were discussing stuff from LF ....

yes, i posted that before you posted your clarification.   I need to lie down in a darkened room.

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
 

That would work  I think Skykark 

I don't.

Ok ....well I'm sure somebody in the know can devise a poll  

or maybe I need to take the hint and piss off as Syd suggested?

I actually take umbrage to this Kaffs, I never for one moment suggested (or meant to suggest) that ANYBODY 'Piss Off', I purely meant that because this is a Big Brother forum we may at times hear snippets of 'News' about Big Brother before it is shown on the 'highlights'. and if it meant so much to me 'I' would avoid entering the forum until 'I' had seen the 'Highlights'.

Syd
Originally Posted by Syd:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
 

That would work  I think Skykark 

I don't.

Ok ....well I'm sure somebody in the know can devise a poll  

or maybe I need to take the hint and piss off as Syd suggested?

I actually take umbrage to this Kaffs, I never for one moment suggested (or meant to suggest) that ANYBODY 'Piss Off', I purely meant that because this is a Big Brother forum we may at times hear snippets of 'News' about Big Brother before it is shown on the 'highlights'. and if it meant so much to me 'I' would avoid entering the forum until 'I' had seen the 'Highlights'.

That's two of us then Syd.

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Skylark24:

Can we just not make a thread about CBB, if we wish to do so,  with a starting title of CBB Spoiler, then others can read and chat away with the content of said thread then?? Others who may not wish to read, then can make their own decision whether or not to do so ?

This makes sense to me, skylark -  Mrs H's thread already has upcoming news and is labelled spoiler - so I never read it until after the HL show .     I don't see any harm in 'news' going in there (or a different thread if you don't want it lost in all the articles etc') and anyone who wanted to discuss something specific the day after when everyone's seen the show could start a thread - and maybe it would be more like the old days with people talking about what they'd seen and what they thought of it.   

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:

Can we just not make a thread about CBB, if we wish to do so,  with a starting title of CBB Spoiler, then others can read and chat away with the content of said thread then?? Others who may not wish to read, then can make their own decision whether or not to do so ?

This makes sense to me, skylark -  Mrs H's thread already has upcoming news and is labelled spoiler - so I never read it until after the HL show .     I don't see any harm in 'news' going in there (or a different thread if you don't want it lost in all the articles etc') and anyone who wanted to discuss something specific the day after when everyone's seen the show could start a thread - and maybe it would be more like the old days with people talking about what they'd seen and what they thought of it.   

Like I say , I think we need a poll .....we can then abide by whatever is decided . 

Baz
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:

Can we just not make a thread about CBB, if we wish to do so,  with a starting title of CBB Spoiler, then others can read and chat away with the content of said thread then?? Others who may not wish to read, then can make their own decision whether or not to do so ?

This makes sense to me, skylark -  Mrs H's thread already has upcoming news and is labelled spoiler - so I never read it until after the HL show .     I don't see any harm in 'news' going in there (or a different thread if you don't want it lost in all the articles etc') and anyone who wanted to discuss something specific the day after when everyone's seen the show could start a thread - and maybe it would be more like the old days with people talking about what they'd seen and what they thought of it.   

Like I say , I think we need a poll .....we can then abide by whatever is decided . 

I think a wise person would let it drop now Baz.

 

I always thought you were wise.

 

 

jacksonb
Originally Posted by jacksonb:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:

Can we just not make a thread about CBB, if we wish to do so,  with a starting title of CBB Spoiler, then others can read and chat away with the content of said thread then?? Others who may not wish to read, then can make their own decision whether or not to do so ?

This makes sense to me, skylark -  Mrs H's thread already has upcoming news and is labelled spoiler - so I never read it until after the HL show .     I don't see any harm in 'news' going in there (or a different thread if you don't want it lost in all the articles etc') and anyone who wanted to discuss something specific the day after when everyone's seen the show could start a thread - and maybe it would be more like the old days with people talking about what they'd seen and what they thought of it.   

Like I say , I think we need a poll .....we can then abide by whatever is decided . 

I think a wise person would let it drop now Baz.

 

I always thought you were wise.

 

 

Well I defo don't think I will reply to that one JB  

Baz
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:

Can we just not make a thread about CBB, if we wish to do so,  with a starting title of CBB Spoiler, then others can read and chat away with the content of said thread then?? Others who may not wish to read, then can make their own decision whether or not to do so ?

This makes sense to me, skylark -  Mrs H's thread already has upcoming news and is labelled spoiler - so I never read it until after the HL show .     I don't see any harm in 'news' going in there (or a different thread if you don't want it lost in all the articles etc') and anyone who wanted to discuss something specific the day after when everyone's seen the show could start a thread - and maybe it would be more like the old days with people talking about what they'd seen and what they thought of it.   

Like I say , I think we need a poll .....we can then abide by whatever is decided . 

so long as it's not a loaded question eh?

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:

Can we just not make a thread about CBB, if we wish to do so,  with a starting title of CBB Spoiler, then others can read and chat away with the content of said thread then?? Others who may not wish to read, then can make their own decision whether or not to do so ?

This makes sense to me, skylark -  Mrs H's thread already has upcoming news and is labelled spoiler - so I never read it until after the HL show .     I don't see any harm in 'news' going in there (or a different thread if you don't want it lost in all the articles etc') and anyone who wanted to discuss something specific the day after when everyone's seen the show could start a thread - and maybe it would be more like the old days with people talking about what they'd seen and what they thought of it.   

Like I say , I think we need a poll .....we can then abide by whatever is decided . 

so long as it's not a loaded question eh?

No ....no one wants that .....in either direction....that's why I suggested perhaps a mod shouLD do it . Anyway , I'm off for my tea now  

Baz

Can't we just carry on as we always did. . no need for a survey..  i.e. if something is happening, start a thread and say oooh it's getting exciting, spoiler alert..

 

What did people used to do when we were on C4 Forums? There were always a zillion threads about the current days action  intermingled with threads about stuff shown on the HL show too...  it isn't so hard to just be careful not to give too much away in the title, as used to happen on here when there was more discussion going on. . it's a different BB scenario with no LF now but, the Jeremy chuck out was hinted at and dealt with on here via a thread in the main topics section without a spoiler. .one other thread, one tiny mistake and everyone has gone bonkers..

 

As for leaving it to the mods to decide, the fact this thread was started by a Mod and then stickied is hardly an example of Mods making good choices for us. . I didn't choose the Mods and certainly don't want them making choices for me..  obviously am not including Lori in that as she is part of the lot that allowed us this place in the first instance and can make any rule she wants.. 

 

having said all that, over the last few BBs civilian and CBBs the discussion in main topics has reduced radically to the point of hardly any for a CBB  [3 I think] and not much more for a BB except maybe a few threads posted in the main topics with the updated daily stuff from C5 website which always contained C5's video or info title, so potentially a give away of sorts too ... then we have 2 threads are stickied, one for updates, that  used to be the norm for LF and kinda replaces it, and one for a HL show  discussion as it is aired. . Not everyone wants to chat live as the HL's are shown.. it's all got a bit bonkers   . .

 

I still reserve the right to growl a lot if I'm in a thread unconnected to something that someone then posts a spoiler in regarding the unrelated something  . .if that makes sense 

Mount Olympus *Olly*
Last edited by Mount Olympus *Olly*
Originally Posted by Baz:
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:

Can we just not make a thread about CBB, if we wish to do so,  with a starting title of CBB Spoiler, then others can read and chat away with the content of said thread then?? Others who may not wish to read, then can make their own decision whether or not to do so ?

This makes sense to me, skylark -  Mrs H's thread already has upcoming news and is labelled spoiler - so I never read it until after the HL show .     I don't see any harm in 'news' going in there (or a different thread if you don't want it lost in all the articles etc') and anyone who wanted to discuss something specific the day after when everyone's seen the show could start a thread - and maybe it would be more like the old days with people talking about what they'd seen and what they thought of it.   

Like I say , I think we need a poll .....we can then abide by whatever is decided . 

I agree with a Poll.....you'll be shocked to hear.

Yogi19

Sorry to read that Pengy has left the forum...hope she returns soon

As someone who had done updates on the forum we always had two stickies ...one for the HL thread and another (MrsH thread ) for all other BB info including spoilers.

If it was breaking news for the main board ,noms ,evictions. ejections ,new Hms we put (spoiler) in the title .Pengy made an error... one I have made on many occasions!!! but the mods usually PM me and make me aware that I need to change the title or they do it for me and explain in a PM why. EFFT has also made a mistake by making this public imo.

This is a BB forum  maybe the name of the forum should be changed, if all current BB info is off limits until the Hl show has aired then the forum will be redundant for BB fans most of the day....just a thought

FM
Originally Posted by erinp:

Sorry to read that Pengy has left the forum...hope she returns soon

As someone who had done updates on the forum we always had two stickies ...one for the HL thread and another (MrsH thread ) for all other BB info including spoilers.

If it was breaking news for the main board ,noms ,evictions. ejections ,new Hms we put (spoiler) in the title .Pengy made an error... one I have made on many occasions!!! but the mods usually PM me and make me aware that I need to change the title or they do it for me and explain in a PM why. EFFT has also made a mistake by making this public imo.

This is a BB forum  maybe the name of the forum should be changed, if all current BB info is off limits until the Hl show has aired then the forum will be redundant for BB fans most of the day....just a thought

The voice of reason.

 

Anyway - i did a survey.   It's not anonymous though, so I can probably predict what will happen.

 

I'll get me coat....

Kaffs

Hang on.......has Pengy left?........No idea what started all this, but perhaps knickers shouldnt get so knotted if someone accidentally posts something that can be classed as a *spoiler*.

The stuff about Ken getting kicked out was all over the news and social media way before the HLs aired and I think that almost everyone was aware of it...and tbh I don't think there has been anything more recent that was interesting enough to be classed as a *spoiler*

Kaytee

Nice to see you erin x

I will leave this thread, but i do want to say, Fluffs, you maybe could have handled this a wee bit better. a quiet PM would have sorted it. Making a thread, with rather patronising comments, were, in my opinion not needed. Yes say about spoilers, but the further comment wasnt necessary . Its not like the forum is flooded with people making comments about CBB. I feel you have embarrassed Pengy publicly, and i dont find that very pleasant. My opinion, thanks

FM

Some people, sadly, are still going on as if this thread was aimed at Pengy and ignoring all those that posted spoilers in the highlights thread, which is actually what I saw first. As far as I was aware we (forum members) had an unwritten agreement that spoilers wouldn't be posted in the Highlights thread or as thread titles.

Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×