Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by Syd:
Originally Posted by Amythist:

She was uproarishly funny until the plastic surgery took over

But sad all the same RIP Joan

Hilarity hides a lot.....tis sad..

Yes there was a documentary about her not long ago. She was very insecure underneath. They did a comedy roast thing for her, and she revealed she was genuinely hurt by the jokes. She also had a tough life, Lost her husband [suicide] lost her money too and had to start over again.

FM
Originally Posted by Sezit:

I loved Joan Rivers. it was "The way she told 'em" RIP Joanie. She was funny.

 

I cannot abide Jenny Eclaire who in my opinion, is a pish poor imitation of Joan. Jenny talks about her daughter, about her vagina and her gynacological bits, but she comes across as vulgar not funny. This is my opinion only.

Joan had more wit in her little finger  

FM
Originally Posted by Senora Reyes:

RIP Joan loved your comedy, your acerbic wit was second to none..

 

My only gripe with her was that I hated her.."All Palestinians deserve to die" rant

 

-For me that was unforgiveable..

It's a bit unforgiving to say it's 'unforgivable' barely a few weeks before her death.  Who knows what was going through her mind at the time!

 

Anyway, I get what you mean Senora. She was controversial to the last.  I liked her.  She really stuck her neck out and she just didn't care who she offended and probably enjoyed doing it.  Ballsy woman, as Americans might say.

 

When most entertainers her age are dining out on their notoriety of decades long past, she was still out there, carving out hers. 

 

Role model IMO.

Carnelian
Originally Posted by Sezit:

I loved Joan Rivers. it was "The way she told 'em" RIP Joanie. She was funny.

 

I cannot abide Jenny Eclaire who in my opinion, is a pish poor imitation of Joan. Jenny talks about her daughter, about her vagina and her gynacological bits, but she comes across as vulgar not funny. This is my opinion only.

Kind of agree but I'm that not up to date with Jenny Eclaire's routine - although I can't imagine it's changed that much.

 

Like all subjects in comedy, it's the delivery and humour that are the skill rather than the subject matter.  People rubbish Michael McIntyre for being lightweight, but in my opinion, if he can make mundane observations funny (and he mostly can) then that's his art. 

 

Likewise, if you can make the risquÃĐ gynaecological stuff funny, rather than tasteless, then that's your art.  Joan Rivers did make it funny (among others) but Jenny Éclair doesn't

Carnelian
Last edited by Carnelian
Originally Posted by cologne 1:

Wasn't she taking the mick ( or making a point ) with her comments about Palestinians? I thought that was the job of a good, intelligent comic.

As you make a point on here, there are some things that are sensitive..In the past you have been the first to point that out to me, when I have jokiningly made a comment on here that you have found offensive or insensitive so please don't go there..

Senora Reyes
Originally Posted by Senora Reyes:
Originally Posted by cologne 1:

Wasn't she taking the mick ( or making a point ) with her comments about Palestinians? I thought that was the job of a good, intelligent comic.

As you make a point on here, there are some things that are sensitive..In the past you have been the first to point that out to me, when I have jokiningly made a comment on here that you have found offensive or insensitive so please don't go there..

I wasn't making a personal point senora, comedians do a job. 

cologne 1
Originally Posted by cologne 1:
Originally Posted by Senora Reyes:
Originally Posted by cologne 1:

Wasn't she taking the mick ( or making a point ) with her comments about Palestinians? I thought that was the job of a good, intelligent comic.

As you make a point on here, there are some things that are sensitive..In the past you have been the first to point that out to me, when I have jokiningly made a comment on here that you have found offensive or insensitive so please don't go there..

I wasn't making a personal point senora, comedians do a job. 

Fair enough no worries..

Senora Reyes

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×