Skip to main content

Originally Posted by sparkles:
Originally Posted by Pengy:

The tv proggie was quite poor.  I am surprised at how virtually everyone on here seems to hate the James Cameron film though.    It was actually good.  I am quite puzzled.  I must admit that I have never heard anyone say that people at the film academy say it shouldn't have got so many oscars either.  (as Rawky said.)  

for me the reason I didn't like Cameron's film was because there was a lot of historical inaccuracies.  I know things change with what we know and learn about Titanic but there was too much that was wrong for me.  Also I hated the way they treated Murdoch's character which was so untrue and quite upsetting for his descendents.  Whilst appreciating that it was a film for entertainment value, it was based on a true story so they could have handled the story a little better.  For instance, you'd think the only 3rd class passengers were Irish when in fact they were French, Irish, and a hell of a lot of Scandinavians!

 

It was beautifully filmed and the set and costumes were gorgeous and as an aside Leo's character Jack Dawson is alleged to be based on one of the real Titanic passengers James Farrell who is a distant relative of mine 

 

 

I think I'll stick to my documentaries like the brilliant 2 hour one Ch5 showed last week - now that was worth watching.

 

I hope the ITV series gets better although considering there's 3 more episodes and the boat is already sinking, I can't imagine what they will do 

 

FM
Originally Posted by Pengy:

Having watched yesterday's episode, I'll stick with it because it was much better than the first episode. 

Yeah I agree Pengy, I was actually quite engrossed in this weeks episode. As you get more background on the characters, they seem more engaging.

 

I've just started reading And The Band Played On by Christopher Ward who is the grandson of one of the violinists in the orchestra who carried on playing on deck as the ship sank. It's not about the sinking per se but about the aftermath from a family persepective. It seems quite good but I haven't read much.

FM
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:

I think I'm the only one who enjoyed the TV programme .............I think next week it might go back and see what went on before - it's four episodes and the boat has already sunk in episode 1 .

I enjoyed it too, i think the other episodes will be in a flashback sort of way

Perhaps we should start our own thread 

Think it will just be us two 

three!  I enjoyed last night's episode

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Veggieburger:
Originally Posted by Pengy:

Having watched yesterday's episode, I'll stick with it because it was much better than the first episode. 

Yeah I agree Pengy, I was actually quite engrossed in this weeks episode. As you get more background on the characters, they seem more engaging.

 

I've just started reading And The Band Played On by Christopher Ward who is the grandson of one of the violinists in the orchestra who carried on playing on deck as the ship sank. It's not about the sinking per se but about the aftermath from a family persepective. It seems quite good but I haven't read much.

I think that's what makes the difference Veggie - I even warmed to vile Vera last night.

Kaffs
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:

I think I'm the only one who enjoyed the TV programme .............I think next week it might go back and see what went on before - it's four episodes and the boat has already sunk in episode 1 .

I enjoyed it too, i think the other episodes will be in a flashback sort of way

Perhaps we should start our own thread 

Think it will just be us two 

three!  I enjoyed last night's episode

I hope you're not going to split us into class members cos I refuse to be in steerage 

FM
Originally Posted by Pengy:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:

I think I'm the only one who enjoyed the TV programme .............I think next week it might go back and see what went on before - it's four episodes and the boat has already sunk in episode 1 .

I enjoyed it too, i think the other episodes will be in a flashback sort of way

Perhaps we should start our own thread 

Think it will just be us two 

three!  I enjoyed last night's episode

I hope you're not going to split us into class members cos I refuse to be in steerage 

First class only for us 

FM
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
 

Perhaps we should start our own thread 

Think it will just be us two 

three!  I enjoyed last night's episode

I hope you're not going to split us into class members cos I refuse to be in steerage 

First class only for us 

You lot can go where you like - I'm sitting the lifeboat with my lifejacket on for the duration .... just in case.

Kaffs
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
 

Perhaps we should start our own thread 

Think it will just be us two 

three!  I enjoyed last night's episode

I hope you're not going to split us into class members cos I refuse to be in steerage 

First class only for us 

You lot can go where you like - I'm sitting the lifeboat with my lifejacket on for the duration .... just in case.

Is there room for one more? Budge up.

Soozy Woo
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
 

Perhaps we should start our own thread 

Think it will just be us two 

three!  I enjoyed last night's episode

I hope you're not going to split us into class members cos I refuse to be in steerage 

First class only for us 

You lot can go where you like - I'm sitting the lifeboat with my lifejacket on for the duration .... just in case.

Is there room for one more? Budge up.

there might be.... do you have a (full) hip flask?

Kaffs
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Soozy Woo:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Skylark24:
 

Perhaps we should start our own thread 

Think it will just be us two 

three!  I enjoyed last night's episode

I hope you're not going to split us into class members cos I refuse to be in steerage 

First class only for us 

You lot can go where you like - I'm sitting the lifeboat with my lifejacket on for the duration .... just in case.

Is there room for one more? Budge up.

there might be.... do you have a (full) hip flask?

I've got a bottle secreted about my person, we just need some ice 

FM

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×