Skip to main content

Originally Posted by nuts:
Originally Posted by Eileen Over:

I have no idea what anyone is talking about.

I am just generally excited

You sitting on a feather? 

OOoooh do you know I actually found a sizeable white feather in my nickers last week.  How it got there I have no idea, and what's even more worrying how didn't I feel it?

Cinds
Originally Posted by El Loro:

I think this adaptation of Great Expectations is great. Ray Winstone was born for the part of Abel Magwitch - I can't think of anyone who could play the part better. Fascinating to see David Suchet as Jaggers, a somewhat different role to that of Poirot.

 

And Gillian Anderson as Miss Haversham is exceptional. A hypnotically ghostly presence as she almost floats around. There is something of the undead about her as she sucks the lifeforce out of those closest to her.

Oooh, excellent summing up there, El Loro.

 

I really enjoyed the portrayal of Miss Haversham;  it was somehow more poignant to see her as not quite such an 'old maid' as previously shown in other adaptations.

 

What did any of you make of the death scene?  I thought it took a deliciously mad tone and it made me think that this was more like the way she would have died.  Suicidal in her grief, dancing on the edge of spiteful madness until it totally overwhelmed her.

 

The Raymond was superb.  Magwitch was nicely brooding and menacing.

 

Wasn't quite so keen on some of this adaptation, and it could probably have done with being a 6 parter to flesh out some of the characters that seemed to take on more of a bit part in this screening.

Cosmopolitan
Originally Posted by noseyrosie:
Originally Posted by Yogi19:
Originally Posted by Gypsie~:

OMG he does look like keira knightly and I think she looks like a dark haired samantha janus

 

More than a passing resemblance to Keira Knightley.

Definitely! Could be her brother 

b.t.w.... I love the way Mark Kermode calls her Ikea Knightley 

That's how I shall think of her from now on.

Yogi19
Originally Posted by Yogi19:
Originally Posted by noseyrosie:
Originally Posted by Yogi19:
Originally Posted by Gypsie~:

OMG he does look like keira knightly and I think she looks like a dark haired samantha janus

 

More than a passing resemblance to Keira Knightley.

Definitely! Could be her brother 

b.t.w.... I love the way Mark Kermode calls her Ikea Knightley 

That's how I shall think of her from now on.

 

Thanks Yogi... but to be serious... I DO have flat pack furniture thats  less wooden than her *coff*

FM

HBC (sounds like a high street bank ) will be perfect for Dickens.

We did Great Expectations at school;  David Copperfield too.

 

The terrible thing is, I don't really remember too much about the storylines in either.  I do remember it being a bit of a hard slog at times though, so you'd be better watching the various film adaptations.  As some have said before, David Lean did a really enjoyable version (John Mills was Pip).

Cosmopolitan
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

I can't believe I've never read the book OR seen this before - so it was all new to me.   I loved it all.   I'm going to have to try to watch some other now or read the book.

 

I loved Raymond (naturally) and Gillian Anderson (but I still reckon Helena B-C will give her a run for her money)

Aww Kaffy. I'm sure there were some other Dickens' on yestersay.

 

EDIT: Yes, David Copperfield (two parter) and 'A Tale of Two Cities'

Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing
Last edited by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×