Originally Posted by Issy:
I suppose that is one way of looking at it Cupcake and if it works for you then that is fabulous.
It didn't work for me - it is all about control I suppose. For me, having my own ( albeit) mortgaged front door is very important. Maybe I will have to shop at Primark for a while, maybe I will have to struggle but when I am retired I will have my own house. That is an investment for the future,
I have an awful landlady and as I sit in this crumbling mess, I feel sorry for whoever comes in next.
I don't look down on anyone - my personal choice is to be a homeowner, It is important to me for a myriad of reasons. Does not make me better than anyone else though.
I have been one before - the marital home was sold and money divided 50/50 so I am aware of both sides as well.
I guess you are entitled to your own points and opinions Issy, and like me and my family, you have to do what was best for you. I must say though that I definately wouldnt go back to buying now...but I guess if you had a dreadful landlady, then that is not good, and I can imagine that anyone who has experienced awful landlady/landlords would want to be a homeowner... We used to rent in the late 80s, and the landlady was great, but we decided to buy because we got good well-paid jobs, and frankly, people looked down on us for renting and you were regarded as something of an 'under achiever' in life if you weren't a 'homeowner..' I guess the 90s were a time when everyone felt like they had to be high-flyers: the smartest clothes, the sassiest cars, the best jobs, a good hold on the career ladder, and above all: their 'own' home.
Well it was OK at first, and the mortgage cost less than the rent and we were very proud to have our own little piece of England, and the security that came with it... but before long (maybe a year,) things started to accumulate rather rapidly.. we were told we had to get 36 conifers chopped down or trimmed by 6 feet, (which cost almost as much as chopping them all down!) or the house insurance wouldnt cover us, and that cost us several hundred... Then the flat roof on the garage needed repairing; several hundred, then the kitchen started springing leaks, and had several other issues (over a thousand to fix,) the bathroom needed replacing, (4 figure sum,) then the windows, (about 2 or 3 grand,) and then the central heating system.... (4 figure sum) and the boiler alone was 1.5K.) It just went on and on over several years, and we were utterly gobsmacked at how much all the repairs cost us.... It ran into well over 20 grand over about 5 to 7 years....and we didn't have enough surplus income, so we ended up taking out loans, and I can honestly say that at least 5 or 6 people I know, experienced the same...
Although for every person that says they had the same experiece, there is someone who says 'oh WE have an uncle/dad/brother/whatever, who does all our house repairs and maintenance..... Well for one thing: good for them! If they are THAT lucky, and secondly, I don't know if I believe them anyway, and even if they do do it, they probably charge! And then you have to question whether they have the correct insurance and are certified to do the work, (if it's electrics and plumbing and so on...) because if not, it will invalidate the insurance.
My husband came out of work in 2003, and we had paid the unemployment insurance for 8 years, and they would not pay him, because he had some redundancy (only 4 grand mind you...) so they said we cannot apply for it for 6 months! IMO they should have paid from the second he was finished from work. So THAT was the biggest waste of money ever.. we cancelled the insurance as soon as he got another job. And again, I know several people who have had the same experience with unemployment insurance...
Then we have had to pay for things that the insurance doesn't even cover of course...like things not covered under the gas contract and replacing seals on windows, retarmaccing the drive, replacing fences, and all sorts of things...
When people say you're 'lining a landlord's pocket' it baffles me, because what is the difference between that, and lining the bank's pockets? You borrow an inordinate amount of money, and if it's say around 90 to 100 grand, (and often it's more...) you probably pay double that back over the 20 to 25 years you borrow it... ... and it's often as much as - or more than renting...... so what's the difference? And you're not giving the landlord 4 or 5 or 6 hundred a month or whatever just to 'line his pockets,' you're renting his property and living in it and using it as your home.. and in many cases, the landlord has a mortgage that they are paying, and they have to do all the repairs and pay all the insurances, so I am baffled as to why anyone thinks or says that.... it's no different to paying the bank money and then you still have to fork out for repairs yourself... And although many think that buying brings security: well it does, until you can't pay the mortgage for whatever reason...
As for super's comments: ÂĢ200 to ÂĢ250 a week mortgage is not so rare these days... I have several pals who pay that, and frankly, it takes over half the entire salary with one of them! And the ÂĢ76 a week rent is fairly normal for social landlord... even some private ones aren't too bad: it depends what you have and where you live... My cousin actually rents privately, but rents through a property agent, and although she paid ÂĢ200 initially for the fees, she is now protected by them and so is the landlord, and she pays about ÂĢ105 a week for a 3 bed house, with the repairs done, and it's long term let, and she has been there 5 or 6 years so far...
Still, I am sorry to piss on your bonfire Issy: I am just posting a different slant and my experiences on buying and renting... and thanks for your constructive post, and not being rude and accusing my views of being 'twisted' just because the don't coincide with yours...! . To be honest, I would probably have agreed with you and your points 20 years ago...
I do genuinely wish you well,. Many people have been homeowners for decades and have found it fine... But I would never do it again, and just lately I have seen a number of internet and magazine features on why people are going back to renting. I guess there are certain perks to buying: like it is probably more secure than private rent, and you aren't going to be asked to leave with three months notice (or less,) but then buying is only secure as long as you can pay for the mortgage and afford all the repairs...
As I said, I am just going on my own experience and that of a few people I know who now prefer to rent.. and I genuinely think that renting has more advantages than buying... but each to their own, and I do wish you all the luck in the world and hope you have a better time being a homeowner than we did!