You can't compare Dancers to Singers

Topics

paace

Dancers can rehearse until they get it perfect, with singing you have to be born with a good voice. Before Diversity did their act last night they must have rehearsed it over and over with the ITV technicians and camera crew so they could get the lighting working in sync with the dance moves. So they had lots of practice performing on that stage.
The thing is where does an act like Diversity go from here? Susan can make lots of money from record deals.
I thought little Hollie was the outstanding voice on the show, way better then Susan.

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Former Member

thats not true. both have to practice and both have to have a talent to begin with. not everyone can sing and not everyone can dance.

5/31/096:03 AM

paaceMember

quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
thats not true. both have to practice and both have to have a talent to begin with. not everyone can sing and not everyone can dance.

If your not born with a good voice no amount of practicing can make you a good singer.

5/31/096:07 AM

old hippy guyMember

erm what about a musician then?, HE/SHE has to learn to play the instrument and learn to read or even write music, hours and hours and hours of dedication and pracitce
respect for the dancers, AND the singers....BUT I would pick some one who plays an instrument and plays it brilliantly (as did Julian) EVERYTIME,

5/31/096:10 AM

Former Member

quote:
Originally posted by paace:
quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
thats not true. both have to practice and both have to have a talent to begin with. not everyone can sing and not everyone can dance.

If your not born with a good voice no amount of practicing can make you a good singer.

and if you cant dance no amount of practice can make you.

5/31/096:12 AM

DuckyMember 10 years

quote:
Originally posted by paace:
quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
thats not true. both have to practice and both have to have a talent to begin with. not everyone can sing and not everyone can dance.

If your not born with a good voice no amount of practicing can make you a good singer.

Have you never watched Strictly Come Dancing? If you're not born with rhythm ........

5/31/096:12 AM

faerykelstarMember

I think Shaheen was far better than Holly.

5/31/096:12 AM

paaceMember

quote:
Originally posted by old hippy guy:
erm what about a musician then?, HE/SHE has to learn to play the instrument and learn to read or even write music, hours and hours and hours of dedication and pracitce
respect for the dancers, AND the singers....BUT I would pick some one who plays an instrument and plays it brilliantly (as did Julian) EVERYTIME,

Of course practice makes perfect with musicians along with talent and ability.

5/31/096:13 AM

faerykelstarMember

quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
quote:
Originally posted by paace:
quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
thats not true. both have to practice and both have to have a talent to begin with. not everyone can sing and not everyone can dance.

If your not born with a good voice no amount of practicing can make you a good singer.

and if you cant dance no amount of practice can make you.

John Sergeant springs to mind......

5/31/096:13 AM

CroctacusMember

quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
quote:
Originally posted by paace:
quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
thats not true. both have to practice and both have to have a talent to begin with. not everyone can sing and not everyone can dance.

If your not born with a good voice no amount of practicing can make you a good singer.

and if you cant dance no amount of practice can make you.

I agree...and if I was a bit braver i'd put up part of my holiday video and prove it!

5/31/096:14 AM

Former Member

ohhh id pay to see that video

5/31/096:18 AM

paaceMember

quote:
Originally posted by Duckypup:
quote:
Originally posted by paace:
quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
thats not true. both have to practice and both have to have a talent to begin with. not everyone can sing and not everyone can dance.

If your not born with a good voice no amount of practicing can make you a good singer.

Have you never watched Strictly Come Dancing? If you're not born with rhythm ........

My favourite show. There are some with two left feet who never improve but most of the amateurs on Strictly show great improvement after a few weeks.

Voices like George Michael, Freddie Mercury, Dusty, Pavorotti are wonderful and unique.

5/31/096:19 AM

Russell teh Muscle (Guest)

quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
quote:
Originally posted by paace:
quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
thats not true. both have to practice and both have to have a talent to begin with. not everyone can sing and not everyone can dance.

If your not born with a good voice no amount of practicing can make you a good singer.

and if you cant dance no amount of practice can make you.

5/31/096:19 AM

CroctacusMember

quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
ohhh id pay to see that video

No...you really wouldn't!

but...I won!!!

Maybe cos my lot and our mates were noisier!

5/31/096:20 AM

Former Member

quote:
Originally posted by FGG Aka Crocodile Rock:
quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
ohhh id pay to see that video

No...you really wouldn't!

but...I won!!!

Maybe cos my lot and our mates were noisier!

yayy well thats a good thing then

5/31/096:21 AM

HyacinthBMember

quote:
Originally posted by old hippy guy:
erm what about a musician then?, HE/SHE has to learn to play the instrument and learn to read or even write music, hours and hours and hours of dedication and pracitce
respect for the dancers, AND the singers....BUT I would pick some one who plays an instrument and plays it brilliantly (as did Julian) EVERYTIME,

Julian was superb IMO and I am so pleased he came a respectable third. Do hope he achieves something from this as he is so deserving.

I'm sure, had he played 'Stranger on the Shore' last night, he'd have been onto a winner.

They were all good in their respective fields and they all worked extremely hard. Fair play to all of them.

5/31/096:32 AM

LiverpoollassMember

quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
quote:
Originally posted by paace:
quote:
Originally posted by Gypsie:
thats not true. both have to practice and both have to have a talent to begin with. not everyone can sing and not everyone can dance.

If your not born with a good voice no amount of practicing can make you a good singer.

and if you cant dance no amount of practice can make you.

5/31/096:40 AM

BlackpudlianMember

quote:
If your not born with a good voice no amount of practicing can make you a good singer.

and if you cant dance no amount of practice can make you.

Unless you have the humour and charisma of Stavros Flatley!!!!

5/31/0910:15 AM

Ad-Free	Search Site	Start Dialogs
Upload Photos	Upload Videos	Upload Audio
Upload Documents	Use Signature	Block Members
View Member Directory	Mark All Topics As Read	Edit Posts Anytime
Post To Walls

Skip to main content

Topics

Add Reply

Membership Required

Remove From Your Block List

Manage Follow Preferences

Block

Premium Membership Required

VIP

Please wait...